Plato Republic The Noble Lie Essay

1183 Words 5 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
As with all other topics discussed in “The Republic of Plato,” the section in which he discusses the myths of the metals or the “noble lie” is layered with questioning and potential symbolism, possible contradiction, and a significant measure of allusion. In Chapter X of “The Republic,” Plato presents “The Selection of Rulers: The Guardians’ Manner of Living.” In it, he discusses the necessities of education as they apply to the appropriate selection of and reparation for the community’s

middle of document…

He asserts that they must never be willing to act against that collective interest.
Socrates expands on his metaphor of the metals and explains that the future rulers must be fashioned as precious metals are fashioned by careful artistry and craft. But first he asks Glaucon: “. . . can we devise something in the way of those convenient fictions we spoke
of earlier, a single bold flight of invention, which we may induce the community in general, and if possible the Rulers themselves, to accept?” (The Republic of Plato X:III-414). Such a tongue-in-cheek question, the reference to “a single bold flight of invention” is what
has come to be known as commonly rendered by “noble lie,” a self-contradictory expression which is no more applicable to Plato’s comparatively harmless storytelling than to a 20th century political campaign publication. Such use of the “noble lie” suggests that he would agree to the use or be unconcerned about correcting the lies,
for the most part dishonorable (certainly not “noble”), that are now most commonly thought to be unabashed propaganda.
Returning to the metaphor of crafting precious metals, Socrates tells that while all men throughout the land are brothers, the god who was responsible for the creation
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • Essay on Justice in Platos Republic

    He states that the people will undergo a precise training. Certain music and physical activity will only be allowed. Plato wanted a good upbringing to make the right ideas permanent in them, so that the bleach of pleasure, grief, fear, or death, would not wash the true colors from their souls. “For, in my opinion, you regard the right opinion about these same things that comes to be without education- that found in beast and slaves- as not at all lawful and call it something other than courage” (430b)

    Words: 1165 - Pages: 5
  • Essay about The Republic by Plato

    practice for the praetor to accept his predecessor’s edicts and thus only introducing certain amendments and new provisions. W. W Buckland refers to the edict of the praetor as the “most potent instrument of law reform in the last century of the Republic” . By adopting the edicts of the previous praetor, the new praetor would be lock-stock and barrel carrying laws from one year to another and developing the ius honorarium. As from the second century, edicts were being promulgated which modified the

    Words: 1586 - Pages: 7
  • Plato and Confucius Essay

    In books II-IV and VIII-IX of the Republic, Plato shows that dikaiosune is the only state in which a person may find harmonious fulfillment. 5. Dikaiosune is an agent-centered ethical ideal. 'Plato shifts from an act-centered to an agent-centered concept of justice,' so that one who becomes a philosopher embodies dikaiosune (Annas: 162). Essay – Plato vs. Confucius 4 6. By the time we get to the end of the Republic, we have more than a theory of justice in the narrow sense. We have been told

    Words: 4610 - Pages: 19
  • Plato and Aristotle: An Analysis Essay

    contrasts between their methods is that Plato used analogies to make his points. He examined a political state by comparing the state with the human soul. Unlike Aristotle, he also used a style of approach in which he made his points through dialogues involving Socrates. He also designed an ideal state run by people he referred to as “The Guardians” which differed from Aristotle’s approach in Politics, in which style and form more closely resembled an essay or monologue. In Politics, Aristotle

    Words: 1173 - Pages: 5
  • Essay on Plato And Justice

    individual that work simultaneously. You must have them all working together to form a just community. But what happens when one part doesn’t do its job? For instance what if a person commits an immoral act in a just community? Plato says there is such a thing as a “noble lie” which are masses of people who can’t know everything but must believe

    Words: 760 - Pages: 4
  • Essay about White Lie Is Still a Lie

    tell truth which is that he is failing. He lies because he does not want people to think that he is of inferior intelligence). Another reason can be because of selfishness. Someone can lie and possibly harm others, just to gain attention or to gain a possession (for example, from personal experience, a child will lie and say that his friend's toy is his so he can take it home with him.) On the other hand, in some situations, telling the truth leads to more bad than good. So with this lying is used

    Words: 699 - Pages: 3
  • Essay on Plato

    Plato is an ancient Greek philosopher. He is best known as the author of philosophical works of paralleled influence. Plato was a member of the circle around Socrates. He became a close associate of Socrates along with other men. His acquaintance with Socrates altered the course of his life and he became interested in philosophy. He began to write dialogues. This became the hallmark of his philosophical exposition (“Plato” Gale). Plato’s works were commonly referred to as “Socratic”

    Words: 1523 - Pages: 7
  • Justice in Plato's The Republic Essay

    Socrates expresses that,“…is it because of the spirited part…that we call a single individual courageous (Plato 99).”  It can be found if one has courage in the spirited part.  In the state, the soldiers represent courage. They fight and defend for their city. They obey the rulers and are their allies.  To ensure that the rulers and soldiers will fight for their city; Socrates proposed a noble lie to maintain the city’s justice.  He will try to persuade the rulers and soldiers that they do not have

    Words: 954 - Pages: 4
  • Essay about Plato

    leader emperor Justinian. Around the time of establishing the academy, Plato made further studies into his philosophical works and wrote articles such as symposium, the republic and cratylus. Plato continued teaching at the academy up the time of his death in 347BC. Among his students was Aristotle, another renowned philosopher. Plato viewed belief as “an activity that presupposes cognitive access to intelligible”. Plato believed that any capacity that involved understanding belonged to the

    Words: 1605 - Pages: 7
  • Plato and Aristotle’s Forms of Government Essay

    The last aspect of the soul, one that Plato believes is the intellect, is wisdom. Like the ego, it is the tiebreaker between courage and appetite and balances them out in moderation. The one who processes wisdom is the one who, according to Plato, is fit to rule. Plato believes that the problem of the parts of the soul is harnessing both the appetite and the courage (31). This leads Plato into discussing the special classes of the citizens known as the guardians. The best guardians are the rulers

    Words: 2298 - Pages: 10