Argument Against Moral Relativism Essay

1569 Words 7 Pages
Argument against moral relativism

This paper will debate advantages and disadvantages of both moral relativism and deontology. I will argue against moral relativism by showing that deontology gives a better account of our moral intuitions than moral relativism. I will use examples from the film The Ballad of Narayam, and James Rachels’ “The Challenge of Cultural Relativism” to illustrate why moral relativism should be rejected, and deontology should be accepted.
Moral Relativism
Moral relativism takes the position that moral and/or ethical propositions do not reflect universal moral standards. Moreover, moral relativism takes the position that moral truths reflect those of social, cultural, and historical circumstances. It is a
…show more content…
The deontological perspective states that reason determines that categorical imperative is the foundation of morality. According to Immanuel Kant, the categorical imperative determines a set of universal principles by which the right action can be judged. According to Kant, deontology is a theory of morality, which states that if you want to know what is the right thing to do, then apply the categorical imperative. Kant’s reasoning behind formulating deontology was to establish an ethical and universal system that does not rely on any person’s subjective experience, but rather good or evil of an action is determined by logic and reason. The categorical imperative has three formulations, meaning that using one of the three formulations, you are asking yourself whether the principle describing your action could be rationally expressed as a universal law of nation. For example, in the case of killing, if I were to ask myself: “if I will it to be a universal law that killing is wrong under any circumstances, would it be rational?” logic and reason would say yes, thus the categorical imperative would allow me to determine that killing under any circumstance is considered wrong.
Son’s Position
Moral relativism is the belief that each culture has the power to decide what they consider and determine to be morally right. For example, in my culture, it is morally right to discard a citizen when

Related Documents