Xun-Zi And Mencius Human Nature

Improved Essays
Both Mencius and Xun-zi are Confucians who differently interpret the conception of human nature. It is described as something that we are born with and we develop with time. Even though Mencius and Xun-zi disagree in many aspects they agree in a variety as well. Everyone is born with the same set of characteristics such as feelings, pity, sense or right or wrong, compassion and other acts that lead every human being to be humane in a sense (De Bary 129). Human nature are good acts or bad acts done taken and may lead humans in choosing which action or decisions they want to take and what aspects they want to flourish in there life. Anyone is capable of taking good actions if they flourish the good side and do good actions in society, politics, …show more content…
They both agree when it comes to public policies and how people are being treated. Part of being a Confucian like them is that they share same thoughts or believes in which they believe that things such as “values, above all the devotion to learning, culture, and the possibility of human perfectibility” (159) is really important within human nature. Similar to Mencius, Xun-zi describes human natures characteristic and feelings that people are born with. Mencius describes good things in human beings in which they can take good decisions to act properly and Xun-zi describes that human beings are “evil” because “one is born with feelings of “envy and hate” (179), which leads conducting in such a way that is not good for them and people might be harm from their actions. The reason Xun-zi describes the nature of humans as something malicious is because everyone is born with the decision to be good or bad and some choose to pick the wrong decisions, which leads them to not having respect or compassion for others. Both fundamentally agree about “human and humane politics” (10/3/2016).
Human races are actions taken by humans that may lead to corruption of power when coming into politics. Kings or government may take advantage of the power they have and act in inhumane ways against others. Mencius describes a case, which involved a king that was governing badly. According to Magagna meniscus mentions a well detailed analogy of how the king governed badly (10/14/2016), in which he points out that the king is not doing a good job and is slowly deterring the life of people with raising taxes to create

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Social Hierarchy of Inborn Traits: An Analysis of Cultivation of the Self and Innate Goodness of Human beings in Confucius, Mencius, and Xunzi This comparison analysis will define the social hierarchy of the cultivation of the self and the innate goodness of human beings as a point of conjecture in the writings of Confucius, Mencius, and Xunzi. The writings of Confucius define the social hierarchy of evil as an inborn trait, which must continually be cultivated by the wisest and strongest of people. In contrast to this, Mencius feels that human beings are innately good, but they must also continue to follow the living a good life through wisdom and self-development. In a similar way, Xunzi was not unlike Confucius in believing in the innate evil in humankind, yet he followed the similar process of…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Confucianism and Communism also share the idea of virtue. For Confucianism, virtue is what inspires and individual to study, unselfishly help with public service, and be kind within human relationships (Peter Dass). Communism virtues are similar when it comes to knowledge and public service. Under Communism everyone would be serving the public and in an ideal Communist society, the people would do so with the responsibility of not complaining or fighting back. Communism relied heavily on the support of the people and the Communist government could use the teachings of Confucianism to “guide religion to adapt to socialism behind the Chinese Communist Party” (Fisher 159) similar to how the Han Dynasty used Confucianism to model laws.…

    • 1547 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He believed we had virtues such as humanness, rightness and courage/ goodness. Humanness could mean many different things such as perfect virtue, kindness, goodness, and human- heartedness (p.114). All of these meanings of humanness express an individual that is warm hearted and care for the well beings of others. Confucius would like for each individual to give each other their basic human rights. Rightness has to deal with the acts that the individual is committing (p.115).…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Kang Youwei’s explanation of evolutionism tried to achieve both in order to preserve the Confucius teachings. His ultimate goal was Great Peace in human society (not profit maximization from a capitalist view), and laws and government were more important than biological reasoning. First, Kang Youwei framed Chinese Wenming under Confucian values. While the Western culture believed that civilizations could only advance through science and technology, Kang Youwei argued that progress required “the moral life of conscious beings”. In his work ta-t’ung, Kang Youwei argued that the world would evolve from a place that required “social norms, or li, permitted partial expression of human solidarity, allowing for ethical distinctions between near and far, or high and low,” to an age when “social customs would have cast off all such ‘selfishness’, and would perfectly reflect a spirit of undifferentiated universal love (jen).”…

    • 2079 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Confucius Argument Essay

    • 1086 Words
    • 4 Pages

    I’m sure we’ve all heard the quote, “Choose a job you love and you’ll never have to work a day in your life (Brainy Quote, 2015).” When I first heard the quote, it was from my 9th grade English teacher and I couldn’t tell you who had said it. But every day, she would repeat the same quote almost like clockwork and it stuck with me. With a little help from google, I found out that the quote belong to Kong Qiu or for many of us Confucius. Born around 551 BC, he lost his father at the tender age of 3 and grew up in poverty with his mother.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Confucianism and Taoism are two of the most popular philosophies throughout both Asia and the world, and both have a long history. While sharing a few similar elements, the two philosophies appear to contradict each other with their vast differences. One such difference is the approach that each philosophy takes towards the human condition, or what it means to be human. For Confucianism being human is developing a sense of self by incorporating the surrounding environment. To be human is to behave in a respectful way for the purpose of creating a hierarchical but harmonious society.…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Responsible for shaping the upper echelons of middle age Chinese society, Confucius reveals his thoughts on how society should should be run by the government as well as royalty. Furthermore, Confucius narrows his expectations to what he believes to be key values that everyone in society must conform to such as ren (kindness), li (everyday norms), yi (altruism), and zhi (morality). His writing evinces a very conservative stance when it comes to citizens conforming to these values. The Analects furthers its point through specific examples.…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the nature of man, if man is born with the desire of wants, it will lead him to false ideas of goodness that can result in violence and crime, making man a criminal. Xunzi believes that man should not follow their own nature, otherwise they will become lost. Instead…

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Confucianism and Taoism have very little in common. Confucianism stresses action, it says that action and ethics are the same. One of Taoism’s most valued precepts is the Wu Wei - doing nothing to do something. Where Confucianism orders the world, and creates it in society’s image, Taoism delights in accepting the seeming disorder, and finding the order in it. Confucianists practice, and Taoists think.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Purpose of Confucianism and Taoism Confucianism has two important concepts: li and ren – etiquette and compassion. These are two of the most crucial tenets of Confucian doctrine. Taoists have little use for the former, etiquette is no great preoccupation of Taoism, for that matter neither is doctrine. Yet they have great use for compassion, or tz’u. “I have just three things to teach” says Lao Tzu, “simplicity, patience, compassion.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mencius (372-289 BCE), worried about the harsh contracts between the ideal of a unified, peaceful, hierarchical feudal kingdom and the reality of nearly constant warfare between independent feudal states in which the large and powerful preyed upon and absorbed the smaller and weaker states (Mencius, On Human Nature). As a result, he adopted the belief that “all human beings have a mind that cannot bear to see the sufferings of other” (Mencius, On Human Nature), a very idealist way of thinking, in order to encourage a ceasing of the constant warfare. On the other hand, Xunzi (310-219 BCE) held a more pragmatic view: that all humans were innately evil. His experience of living through the final wars of the warring states period, which concluded with the Qin’s conquering of all of China’s feudal states (Xunzi, Human nature is Evil), had a huge impact on his ideas. He believed that ritual and rightness were always created by the conscious activity of the…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Anybody who has complete power to fix a situation should do so rather than not recognizing the issue at hand. The king does not feel as if he should deal with miniscule issues although that is what leaders are compelled to do. In today’s society, we see this issue right in front of our faces. Leaders are supposed to do the correct thing rather than cause larger issues but because they have all the power in their hands, they feel as if nobody’s feelings are important and they can do whatever they please.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout his life, Confucius identified many complications pertaining to the morality and well being of the Chinese civilization.(The Twelve Theories of Human Nature, Leslie Stevenson, David L. Haberman, Peter Matthews Wright, Oxford University Press, Sixth Edition, 2013.) Confucius diagnosed the problems in China to be the desire for wealth or profit, lack of familial respect, one’s words do not represent their actions, ignorance to the Way of the Sages, and the lack of benevolence in human action; his prescription for these problems involved self discipline, acting without a desired outcome, practicing familial respect, rectification of names, and actively studying (24). There are a total of five problems that Confucius states interfere with an individual’s pursuit to Jen and being a benevolent member of society (22). Jen, or the virtue of benevolence is only attainable if one incorporates his prescriptions into their lifestyle (23). The first problem Confucius mentions is people’s desire for profit (22).…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In learning, Confucius said, there should be no distinction of classes (Analects 15.38). Even if, in practical life, equality of educational opportunities proves difficult to achieve, Confucius affirms the theoretical equality of human nature, by virtue of which all men have an equal chance of becoming of high morality and great talent through education and personal learning. This great plasticity of human nature, one of the fundamental ideas of the Confucian school, had a profound influence on the development of Chinese…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thus we see that Confucius focused more on attainment of humaneness through moral character and attitude which he believed only a few people could possess. This is very different from today where a small act of kindness gives a person the tag of being humane. "The humane person is hesitant in his speech." (p. 44), these words of the master showed the level of…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays