Why Did The Founding Fathers Abolish The Electoral College?

Improved Essays
How exactly does the Electoral College work and why did the Founding Fathers choose this system for us to select the new president and vice president of the United States? As we know that years prior to this, the Founding Fathers and other colonists in early America fled Great Britain in hopes of a fresh start. Obviously, when setting up the government for this new country, they would not create it the same as it was in Great Britain. The Founding Fathers created a flawed system but has and still continues to be the best option for us here in America, which is why we should not abolish the Electoral College system.
The Founding Fathers knew they wanted their leader to have limited power. These delegates did not believe the common people would have enough knowledge to make a good decision, therefore they did not believe that the president and vice president should be elected by direct popular vote. With many other possibilities the delegates at this meeting settled on the Electoral College system. Each state has one electoral vote for each of the senators and representatives in their state making this politically equal representation. The way this works come election day, the common people are not necessarily voting for the president or vice president directly but rather voting for the person who will place a vote on their behalf in Congress. The fewest number of electoral votes a state can have is 3 because 2 senators (equal throughout the country) and 1 representative (based on population). In Document D it shows that people believe this violates our political equality because in a chart in Document D it shows that the 12 states and DC with the lowest electoral votes has a lower population than all of Illinois but all together they have more electoral votes (44) whereas Illinois only has a grand total of 20 electoral votes. There is an explanation for this, as mentioned earlier, there is a minimum number of electoral votes that each state can have (3), people question why Illinois does not have more electoral votes. Simply because the amount of votes are based on the total number of senators and representatives which, is already predetermined by population and each state is given 2 senators. Although it may look to be unfair it is only because there has to be a minimum number allowed for each state.- In Document A, people question how the electoral college is fair when the nominee may secure the presidency with only 10 out of the 50 states. However, many of these 10 states are very much so
…show more content…
This is not true for all presidential elections but more often than not it is. Many people wonder why the the Third Party candidate often gets no electoral votes, and claim that they have no chance of ever winning a presidential election. Some Third Party candidates are more popular than others but most of America will vote for 1 of the 2 main parties. I believe that it is not the Electoral College system that does not give the Third Party nominee a chance, I think it is the fact that our votes weigh so heavily on the main parties that the only good a Third Party does is take votes from the other

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Abolishment Of The Electoral College Jena Shattil Period 7 U.S Government Americans currently choose their president through a system called the electoral college, which is an extremely complex system that many would call “undemocratic.” In this system, the president and vice president are indirectly chosen. Each state gets one electoral vote for each of their US senators and representatives. Each state will either vote democratic or republican, and the president, and the candidate will receive all of the electoral votes for that state. This system is very unfair, and gives the citizens almost no say in who will become president.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The distribution of Electoral votes over-represents citizens in rural states. Winner-take-all mechanisms are also hard for the third party to deal with. Taking our recent 2016 Presidential Elections, Hillary had been ahead of President Elect Donald Trump in the citizen’s votes, but the Electoral College had the majority vote for the latter. This gives an unfair advantage to the unwanted party that is favored by the Electoral College, basically throwing human voting rights out the window. If the popular vote candidate has less Electoral votes, they are highly likely to…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because party loyalists are typically going to vote for their party’s candidate regardless, the presidential election may not serve the best interests of the country. Altogether, the Electoral College should be abolished because the purpose of creating the system is irrelevant in modern times, since electors are no longer anonymous and independent agents. Despite this, several believe that the Electoral College has more advantages than disadvantages. Many think that the Electoral College helps small populated states have a voice and power in the important choice of electing the president. However, this argument is simply false, due to the fact that candidates actually spend all of their campaigning time in battleground states and urban areas rather than rural states.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In a presidential election, voters cast ballots for the candidate they prefer, though these votes only select their state’s electors. Electors, who are slated to vote for the popular-elected candidate, then vote in a second election to select the actual president. An electoral college system adds a layer of separation between the popular majority and the power of the federal government’s executive branch, while also giving the ability to misrepresent the popular vote. The electoral college is not democratic because the way of calculating the number of electors over represents the population in small states.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, they came up with the Electoral College. In this system, the president is chosen indirectly. Each state gets a number of electoral votes based on how numerous the numbers of the members are in the House of Representatives are,…

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For hundreds of years, we have used the electoral vote rather than the popular vote when we have had to select a president and vice president. In this essay, we will be examining the structure and function of the Electoral College, comparing the Electoral College to the popular vote and assessing the value of the individual citizen’s vote under the Electoral College system. The Electoral College was created in 1787. The reason, the Electoral College was created, was to give the power of electing a president to the states and not to the people themselves.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vote Vs Popular Vote

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dating all the way back in 1787 when the Founding Fathers drafted the United State’s Constitution, on Article II, section I of the document they also drafted the Electoral College. As the U.S. NARA puts it, “The Electoral College is a process, not a place.” That being said, what contributed to the Founding Fathers to establish the Electoral College was that they believed the typical citizen wasn’t educated enough to nominate a president on their own. * Therefore, the Founding Fathers took many key factors into developing the correct voting system.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the point when Americans vote in favor of a President and Vice President, they are really voting in favor of presidential electors, referred to all in all as the Electoral College. It is these voters, picked by the general population, who choose the President. The Constitution allocates every state a number of electors equivalent to the combined total of the state's Senate and House of Representatives commission at present, the quantity of electors per state ranges from three to 54, for a sum of 538. Individuals really vote in favor of a group of electors when they go to the voting polls on Election Day. These electors have agreed to support a party's nominee chosen for president.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some presidential candidates can typically count on a certain state to vote their way. California typically votes for the Democratic candidate, and Texas normally votes for the Republican candidate (Kimberling.) Without the Electoral College, candidates would be able to go to more states to speak to the public. They would even travel to smaller states to gain the popular vote.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College was designed so that the candidates running for President would need to campaign and appeal to all of the voters of our nation and not just a select few. It allows for even smaller states that a national candidate might never visit to require the candidate to show up and ask for votes. The every state has a right to hear and see the candidate allows the candidates to focus on issues that affect everyone around the country and not just one section of the nation. While the winner takes all fashion of issuing votes with the electoral college may be representative of the citizens of that state, it leaves out states that are not consider “swing” states for their issues being included. Candidates tend to campaign hard in states considered “swing” states and then ignore the states that they believe they have already won.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The two major candidates does not completely make up 100% of the whole nation’s vote. A fraction of it is for the third party candidates, but it will still go to one of the two major candidates. In addition, as included, the Electoral College elects the next president even if that individual failed to win the popular vote. Thus, as was also stated, makes an illusion of democracy. For instance, probably the most famous case regarding Electoral College bias was the 2000 election between former President George W. Bush and Al Gore, in which even the Supreme Court got involved.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    We as a nation, we should be able to decide the president and vice-president for our country. The Electoral College is a way for the Government to control the way politics are decided. People should decide the president, because people know the truth. The electoral college takes away our right to vote, and it is sound a little bit weird but it is the reality, some of the reason is because most of the time the popular vote it does not count in the reality, the smaller states favored the Electoral college because of the number of electors that they have and also, in the reality our votes do not count.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every four years, citizens of the United States of America choose their next president based off a unique system known as the electoral college. The way that this system works is interesting and is confused easily in the general public. In early November, when citizens go to the polls, they are not voting for the president directly, rather they are voting for their individual states to cast its electoral votes towards a certain presidential candidate. In the forty-eight of the fifty states where voting takes place, all the electoral votes go to the presidential candidate who wins the majority in their state. No matter how large or small the majority is, the presidential candidate gets all the votes.…

    • 1924 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College is in place to decide the president of the United States. There are people that agree on it and people that do not. The Electoral College System is an inadequate form of electing the president of the United States, there are better ways to go about choosing a president in a more Democratic way. Having a popular vote, or by deciding by congressional districts would be other options that Congress has thought about, and even states have signed in on being for a National Popular Vote. The Electoral College is a representation of the popular vote, on the other hand it makes it unfair at the same time.…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One Man One Vote Analysis

    • 1297 Words
    • 5 Pages

    States started to implement a “winner takes all” system of Elector, where the candidate with the most votes was promised all of that state’s Electors (Kimberling 5-6). Within a century, the original Electoral College became the one that exists in the United States…

    • 1297 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays