Vanishing Indians In The 19th Century

Improved Essays
Life in the 19th century was hard for the Indians to adjust to. The Westerners decided to claim as much as they could. So how could the Indians adjust to such living conditions that had just been pushed onto their land? In recent years the Americans only remembered the Indians when we celebrate “Thanksgiving” and of course the myths and legends of Pocahontas. Sure that was part of the Indian culture only affecting the influence it had on America. There are many things can contribute to this. Indians didn’t have much respect or say in what they wanted. Many of them tried to fight for their land because to them it was sacred land that their “ancestors” gave to them. The Indian removal act proved to the Indians that no one cared of their land and just wanted to prosper for themselves rather than for history and …show more content…
Whether the Indians vanished it wasn’t a choice to adapt to the modern ways, it was more of a possessive way of pushing them out. Their tribes meant everything to them trying to remain independent they did not feel necessary to get comfortable with the modern ways and to stick by their own beliefs. The “vanishing Indian” was not true due to the fact that we kept pushing them west. There was no way for them to vanish because of our constant desire of land. The source from Touring Indian country 1888 and 1894 talks about the “few indians” that live in such land and the Indians are now indulged into “agricultural and industrial pursuits” this land has a garden which had no real guidance for the Indian culture. The “vanishing Indian” had created much to discuss. Whether the Indian was noble or ignoble proved to the Americans if the Indian could be civilized. The whites reasoning became that inevitable extinction of the Indians. They hinted at the loss of hospitality and courage only regarding the Indians as savages. This ensured the Americans that the Indians were headed towards

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Other causes were temporary, but this had a long and lasting effect on the Native American population. The beliefs of the natives were different then the settlers and they wanted the natives to be like Americans. So they started discriminating Natives through culture and beliefs. Today the natives have rebuilt, but not without problems because they still only have a small portion of their land and a dwindling native culture. Have you ever been stripped of everything you believe in and forced to live somewhere?…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Board believed that the barbaric Indians couldn’t live next to the civilized American, so they had to change them. This article is very historically worthy because it shows how much say the Natives had over their own land and how the white people seen the Natives. In my opinion, the Dawes Act is very biased because the whites assumed they couldn’t live next to Indians because they are different. I think if they went at this a different way they may have had more positive changes instead of negative changes. So many lives were lost because the Indians just wanted to be themselves and live…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indian Removal Act DBQ

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The government believed that the Indian Removal was a way of saving Indians and their culture from western settlers and their influences. The Native Americans viewed the Indian Removal as a the U.S. expansion intended to get rid of them, and their land that belonged to their ancestors. The Cherokees were very much like white settlers, they even had slaves to complement their farming, but they weren’t white. In a time plagued with inequality, the nation failed to meet up to the preamble premise of justice. Indians were not considered to be American citizens which restricted them of land and a voice in government.…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other reasons that might be regarded were disease brought by the Spaniards, the internal division within the empire, and most of the Indians stopped fighting once their leaders were defeated. From a neutral perspective, the Indians should have dominated the Spaniards, because they were greater in size and they fighting in their environment. 7. The impact of the conquest for the native population was not in any way ideal for them. They were forced by the Spaniards to accept their culture, change their lifestyle, and their culture and traditions were diluted.…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American’s came to the New World to escape from a government that was taking what was rightfully theirs, but began to take what was rightfully someone else’s. Settlers left their home, because their previous government was taxing them, giving them acts and laws to follow that were unfair, but it was okay for them to travel somewhere new and do the same to the people who lived on the land. Indians survived on their ways of life for centuries before the settlers came to the new land, why would they need to change their ways because of the ideas of the settlers. The settlers wanted the Indians to be, live and act like them. Abandoning their ways and beliefs.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indian Culture

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages

    American expansion into Indian territory came with many challenges and oppositions for the native people. More than anything, the Indians wanted to coexist with the white man in one shared country. Most of Indian culture seemed to favor peace in times of conflict. The Indians trusted the federal government, the treaties, and new U.S. policies but these were worthless in saving their lands. They were promised justice but repeatedly ended up being impacted negatively by something they perceived as positive.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    They acted as if they were a part of the culture, so that they could take the money. People fought and died for that land, but white people took it like it was nothing. White people thought that they deserved that land more, even though American Indians originated from the land, but the government refused to believe this.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I understand the era of expansion that America was experiencing, but land ownership was no excuse for the cruel nature of the Indian removals. The biggest surprise to me was the lack of compromise that was present during this time. There was no attempt at acceptance for the Indians. This was even after the majority of the Indian nations turned to acts of assimilation hoping to live among the settlers. Jackson was unyielding in his opinion of the Indians and carried it out by taking full advantage of his presidency.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jamestown Racism

    • 1105 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Indians were not taken into consideration when the settlers made a decision. The settlers wanted the Indian peoples land . The settlers “ were chiefly interested in displacing the Indians and settling on their land, not intermarrying with them, organizing their labor, or making them subjects of the crown” (Foner 54). The Englishmen did not want to mingle with the Indians that they were completely against marriage between the two communities . The racism to the Indians pushed them out of their lands and away from their resources.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The arguments made for Indian removal were very heartless and mostly economically or politically oriented. They talk about how unprofitable the land is in the hands of the Indians and how “one nation must perish to make room for another”. The arguments made against Indian removal are quite opposite; they mostly made points stating that Indians are humans just like the whites and that it is because of the treaties made with Congress that they have come to “dearly love” their lands. However opposite the arguments may seem, both sides agreed that the Indians were improving. The Natives were not only attempting to create their own government, their people went to school and attended places of Christian worship.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays