Under The Spell By Joan Acocella

Improved Essays
The Harry Potter series can be an enjoyment for children or a literary failure depending on the reader. Joan Acocella, the author of “Under the Spell” thinks the Harry Potter books are an amazing series that took a new turn on fairy tales. She was able to enjoy the series while feeling a connection with the characters. Harold Bloom, the author of “Can 35 Million Book Buyers Be Wrong? Yes.” has a different view of the series. He believes that the books may be interesting, but they lack literary structure and reading a book that doesn’t help you gain knowledge is a mistake. While reading the essays you may be entertained but begin to realize the lack of proper literature throughout the series. Both authors had a different view on the Harry …show more content…
In the essay “Under the Spell”, Acocella talks about the series being great books and very interesting. She states “The great beauty of the Potter books is their wealth of imagination, their sheer, shining fullness” (Acocella, 530). This part of the essay shares the authors’ thoughts on the books and how great she believes they are. The author is saying that the books are well written and that they are full of creativity and independent thoughts. Acocella also states “After all that, I would love to tell you that the book is a big nothing. In fact, it’s wonderful, just like its predecessors” (Acocella, 527). This quote follows Joan Acocella’s description of her experience on waiting in line for a Harry Potter book. She waited several hours for her book but said it was worth it because the book was just as wonderful as the books before “The Goblet of Fire”. However, Harold Bloom believes that the books were a literary failure but still fascinating. He states “Though the book is not well written, that is not in itself a crucial liability” (Bloom, 538). Bloom wrote this in his essay to express his thoughts on J.K Rowling’s writing but still show that’s not all he thinks about the series. Harold Boom also states “Her prose style, heavy on cliché, makes no demands upon her readers” (Bloom, 540). The authors’ belief on the books being literary failures is supported by this statement. …show more content…
Joan Acocella believes it can help children feel like they have more power and understand situations in life better. In the essay she states “But that is the main virtue of these books, their philosophical seriousness. Rowling is a good psychotherapist, and she teaches excellent morals” (Acocella, 535). This part of the essay is explaining that the books teach children to share their feelings and thoughts, and better ways to handle their behaviors. She also states “The subject of the Harry Potter series is power, an important matter for children, since they have so little of it” (Acocella, 532). Children usually feel like they have less power because they are young and cannot make decisions on their own. With this book series children feel like they have the powers that the characters have, which causes children to feel more important. Harold Bloom had a different point of view on this, he believes Harry Potter doesn’t help a child grow as an individual or gain a stronger personality. He explains this when he says “A vast concourse of inadequate works, for adults and for children, crams the dustbins of the ages” (Bloom, 541). The author is saying that work like Harry Potter is filling our heads with material that isn’t going to help us. Reading the Potter series may be fun, but Bloom would prefer if someone read a book that had proper literature

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Racism American and Resistance to Change: Art Education’s Role in the Indian Mascot Issue. In Elizabeth De La Cruz’s’ article, the author vividly describes and to capture the feelings of Charlene Teter as well as many other Native Americans. When it comes to the lack of sensitivity and politically incorrect usage of Native American Indian Mascot is used in society, but more so, in the sports realm. Many people misuse the Native American mascot in sports and do not really think that it is harmful. However, Teter’s cultural shock when attending the University of Illinois made her aware that the Indian mascot was being misrepresented.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To say that I am a reader would be a stretch. I can not remember the last time I picked up a book for my own personal pleasure. Some would say that should bother me, but I can’t agree with the reasoning behind it. Mostly people bring up how books have broadened their horizons and changed their way of thinking, which is something I can’t relate to. Instead, I would say that I agree with what a good book should do, but I can‘t say I have found a good book, or a page turner if you will.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1997, J. K. Rowling’s first of seven books in the Harry Potter series was released. The book quickly became a best-selling phenomenon and so did it’s successors as most young adult readers found themselves hooked and simply couldn’t get enough of Harry Potter. Although the series became highly popular, it also brought wide-spread controversy with some parents and teachers who were under the impression that the book promoted the occult, witchcraft, and evil. This perception led to attempts to ban the book series from many schools and libraries. Contrarily, the Harry Potter series should not be banned because it provides lessons on moral values, promotes a healthy mind, it facilitates creativity.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Growing up, all my teachers told me to read books. They told me that reading books is good for your and, it would make you smarter. When I was younger, I really didn’t understand how reading fiction books made me smarter. I always thought non-fiction were the books to increase your knowledge because they were real events. Real is better than fake so, I really didn’t understand how you could learn from fictional books until now.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the Novel Under A Cruel Star, Heda Margolius Kovaly sheds light on the repercussions of not only the German concentration camps in World War 2, but also shows how the War led to the adoption, practice, and repercussions of a hostile communist government. In this novel courage, not only in a power to survive, but in a power to provide for family, is the most prevalent issue brought about in Hedas retelling of her time in the concentration camps and her time as wife to a communist official. One of the most endearing facts about Heda in her retelling of her experiences is that fact how despite everything that she had observed, participated in, and been subjected to she still remained “human” in that she was not misguided by hate and anger but…

    • 2032 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    J.K Rowling is an exceptional author and is seen as a big role model in the modern world. She continuously demonstrates her ambition to succeed in every novel she gets published. She has taught many people the importance of failure and why on the contrary of some beliefs, it’s actually a good thing. She speaks about this concept in her 2008 Harvard commencement speech. J.K Rowling emphasises three key points in her speech which are to pursue your dreams and interests even if they don’t lead to success, success can be born from failure, and that imagination can help a person relate and empathise with others.…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Have you heard the story about how J.K. Rowling saved books from being outlawed. When J. K. Rowling was a kid she wrote everyday and night. So everyday the characters would talk to her. J.K. Rowling wrote such good books that most of the time the words came off the page. Everyone one loved her books.…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The course is not simply for those who want to watch Harry Potter movies and write a synopsis of them; rather, it delves into the literary roots of the stories. “The class examines the Harry Potter novels in relation to their literary qualities,” Pugh said. “We read all seven Harry Potter books and dig deeper into the function of the story. We also discuss what makes this series such a phenomenon, what makes it unique and not so…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Teare speaks of how over the years of advancing technology the youth have become less inclined to read stories as they would prefer to capitulate to commodity culture that provides them with different forms of entertainment. However, the Harry Potter stories reverse this effect. “Account after account in the press features a parent describing the change in her child (most often it is a mother and son), who has learned to love reading by reading these books:...” (Teare 551). The Harry Potter series opposes the belief that children prefer different forms of commodities rather than reading.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the editorial, "Is Harry Potter Evil?", the author Judy Blume discusses the danger of allowing people to censor books so freely. Alex Beam, author of "Why Stop with Mark Twain's 'Huckleberry Finn'?", points his fingers towards the people whom he feels are making foolish decisions by banning books. Although both articles discuss the problems and dangers of banning books, they do so in different ways. They use many of the same techniques, but with different approaches. In "Is Harry Potter Evil?", Judy Blume makes many points about why censoring books is wrong.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It’s hard to believe today that Walt Disney was once fired because he “lacked imagination and had no ideas,” or that the Beatles were cut from a record level because the company didn’t think that they had a future in show business. (Weismen) Still harder to believe is that J.K. Rowling’s world famous book ‘Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone’ was rejected by no less than 12 publishers before it was finally published in 1997 at the insistence of Bloomsbury chairman, Nigel Newton’s daughter Alice. (Vincent; Lawless “Nigel Newton”) The story of an 11 year old orphan thrust into an unfamiliar world of magic and set on a course to defeat the dark Lord Voldemort who killed his parents transformed into a 7 book series that has sold nearly 500 million…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is unsurprising for a seasoned author like J.K. Rowling to write an empowering piece; however, what is astonishing is the poignant way in which she delivered the commencement speech to the Harvard graduating class of 2008. Her speech was meant to enlighten the graduates about life after college by focusing on the benefits of failure and the importance of imagination. The commencement speech followed a topical pattern, thus she centered her speech around life after college and the equal importance of failure and imagination by utilizing her own life experiences as a mere twenty-year-old to explain her main points. Not only was the speech easy to follow because she clearly stated what she would speak about, She delivered the speech in a truly…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The fantasy genre has a great appeal to readers. One of the primary reasons is that “[r]eaders…want something that gives … a sense of wonder, a glimpse at the impossible made real, sights … never otherwise see[n]” Cox says. J.K. Rowling effectively displays this, in her novel Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. With aspects of typical fantasy setting, the incorporation of mythical creatures and magic, Rowling has created a fantasy novel. The fantasy genre has general guidelines when it comes to creating a story for it to be qualified as fantasy.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book entitled “Sophie’s World” was written by Jostein Gaarder, who was born in Oslo, Norway, in 1952. He was an intellectual author that teaches high school Philosophy. Gaarder often writes about Philosophy and its main Contribution to the society and oneself. He published his first book in year 1986 and one of his best-sellers is the Sophie’s world that was published in year 1991. Sophie’s world is a novel that talks about a girl named Sophie who explored through the History of Western Philosophy together with his teacher in Philosophy, Alberto Knox.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a beginning reader young adult books captivated me with what, at the time, were intriguing and comprehensible plot lines. Thus began my love affair with books. Eventually, those plot lines became my adversary, when their simplicity triggered a soporific rendition of the book. It persisted until the gifts of classical literature unwrapped as I learned to penetrate, explore, and discover meanings in, for example, Dickens’ lengthy description of a clock tower did I truly find my beloved. Although young adult books had their place in my life by inspiring a love for reading, classical literature has opened up a whole new perspective, teaching me to seek out knowledge while still yielding enjoyment as I consume each book.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics