The White Southern Slavery Analysis

Improved Essays
During the 1800s leaders of the North began to condemn slavery and adopt the idea of abolitionism. Despite their efforts, the cruel and inhumane act of buying and selling human property continued to flourish in the South. Slaves on cotton plantations endured the harsh Southern weather as well as regular beatings from their masters which left many infertile. White southerners argued that the enslaved were well treated and taken care of by the masters; this, however, is absolutely false. Although many defended the practice of slavery, enslaved African Americans of the South were deprived of their cultural beliefs and family, used and mistreated by their masters, and deprived of basic human rights. Slavery was often portrayed as better for …show more content…
The White Southerners’ Defense of Slaveholding Article 3 claims that, “the wretched lot to which these poor fugitives are abandoned by the abolitionists, after they are stolen away from their comfort and protection of their Southern homes. "While it is probably true that freed slaves and free blacks were discriminated against in the North, it is preposterous to say that that discrimination was worse than the absolute lack of rights as a slave. The moment a person of color stepped off the slave ships onto the “land of the free” better known as America, he was deprived of his basic human rights. Slaves in the South had none of the rights that people associate with freedom. For example, an Alabama law stated, “It is illegal for more than 5 male slaves, either with or without passes, to assemble together at any place off the plantations where they belong.” One of the very first rights added to the Constitution was the right to assemble, yet slaves were not even allowed to gather in small groups. Thomas Johnson, a slave to Virginia, would often, "steal away to Jesus with other slaves, to some quiet place for prayer, over the stable, or in the kitchen when the master and mistress were away, though [they] knew that if [they]were discovered [they] [would] be locked up for the night, and that the next morning we should receive from five to nine or even thirty lashes for unlawfully assembling together.” The first amendment claimed that anyone in the U.S could utilize their freedom of speech at any time, however, Octavia, a slave girl from Oklahoma, recalls, “the slaves [being] punished for stealing, running off, not doing what their master told them and for talking back to their master.” The freedom of speech and assembly were basic humans rights that were given out to all those in the U.S. The Southern states,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Since free African Americans were not considered citizens, they felt just as distressed as slaves, being greatly restricted through a number of legislations in multiple states. Due to their lack of rights, many black leaders started to rise in the north, but they were conflicted in how they wanted to integrate into society; some leaders wanted to leave the country and settle in Liberia, while some insisted that they should stay in the United States as they were born there (Jones, et al. 275). On the other hand, in 1831, people in the south reinforced slavery in any way possible. At that exact year, Nat Turner led a slave rebellion in Virginia, freeing slaves and killing any whites that they…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, during the era of slavery, there exit pro-slavery advocates that argues that the American slavery system was not inherently wrong. It was only due to Douglass misfortune to have been in the hands of cruel and incompetent owners. That the majority of slaves are happy and appreciative of their master. However, I would argue that this is false, all slave owners no matter how nice and caring will eventually become demons that forget their humanity because the American slavery system corrodes the morality of all involve. This transformation is most apparent in Mrs. Auld, the wife of Mr. Auld master to Douglass at one point in his life.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In My Bondage and My Freedom, Douglass claims slavery not only affected him, but also slave holders, and the non-slave holding whites. I agree with Frederick Douglass because the slaves had their freedom/rights taken away; the slave holders were turn into cruel people, and the non-slave holding whites had less job opportunities. The slaves were victims, because they had no…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This unhappiness led to resentment and poor treatment of the white working class towards blacks. The resentment from the northern working class started during the era of gradual emancipation and built up after the general emancipation. “From the beginning of the emancipation era, various groups of whites attempted to limit free blacks’ access to political, social, and economic equality.” The main issue was that, in the ideals of republicanism during this time period, blacks were seen as slaves and only slaves in society. That was their role, their “livelihood” in the opinion of white people. As stated before, a lot of these slaves started working for white households after their emancipation and according to Harris, most of these households were former slave holders.…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout much of history, southerners and historians saw slaves as people who were dumb, incompetent, and extremely content with their way of life. They, the southerners and historians, believed the slaves resided in good conditions and the workload held a sufficient standard. But, slaves became unrestful and lashed out against the plantation owners and the southern society. These actions showed people how slaves did not approve of the way of life, nor did they appreciate the living conditions. After slaves began to revolt, the southern societies began to pass stricter laws and limits on the slave population with the notion it would put more control over the rebelling population.…

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery: the condition of being owned by one another. The abolishment of slavery was a positive occurrence in the north, but the south was dissatisfied. This provoked a great difference of slavery that rooted the nation a part. Since the early 1600’s blacks have been intertwined into slavery. From labor to sex trafficking, blacks were transported unwillingly to work for the slaveholders.…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Olaudah Equiano emphasizes this when he is boards a slave ship and states that: “I have seen some of these poor African prisoners most severely cut for attempting to do so, and hourly whipped for not eating”, this points out the cruelty that the Africans suffered because of the way Europeans viewed them. Mary Prince also gives another example of the way Europeans viewed their slaves when she states: “There were two little slave boys in the house, on whom she vented her bad temper in a special manner.” Views of inferiority in both African and European cultures drove slavery but they differed greatly in treatment. Olaudah Equiano and Mary Prince are both give good first-hand examples of how slavery was in the 19th century. Slavery is repugnant and it proponents no matter how well they treat their slaves are part of the problem. There is no decent justification for slavery and the term inferiority does not follow up well in this topic.…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the topic did in fact come up in conversations, southerners argued that paternalism allowed slavery’s defenders to assert that few owners were ever willing to sell their slaves let alone punish them. It was only those slaves “so vicious that they were sold, or banished, as a form of punishment by southern municipalities and states.” To the master, this paternalistic relationship meant that both slave and master had obligations to the other, and when a slave was caught committing an offense the slave was not living up the bargin and needed to be punished. It was this punishment that many abolitionists attacked, and southern slave owners were forced to defend themselves through whatever means necessary, be it violent or non-violent. However, violent defense would not be the final straw in the change in southern reaction to aggression on its most principled of institution. Rather, this would come later on following the many slave rebellions of the 19th…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most people that deny the credibility of the novel say that it was unfair to the southern plantation owners, saying that it gives an inaccurate portrayal of how the slaves live, and how the plantation owners treated their slaves. One thing that the critics of her book can’t deny is the fact that many families of slaves were broken up, which is something featured in this book. With the slaves being treated as objects that can be bought and sold at whim, there wasn’t regard for families, and some members of a family could be sold to a different plantation, or even a different state than another member of the same family. One thing that appeared in the novel is that the slave owners could abuse their slaves with impunity, or even kill them without being prosecuted, an example of this being the murder of Tom. This is at least somewhat inaccurate because critics of the novels found that there are several cases of slave owners getting tried and found guilty of killing their slave.…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Colonies Economic System

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Black workers were obliged to work permanently for their masters, unlike the white servants who were freed after a fixed amount of time. Also, slave codes had further limited the rights of blacks and ensured absolute power to their masters. The brutal and inhumane treatment that Africans have experienced from both their travels and work shows how the Southern economic system has caused for many lives to be destroyed. Although it is uncertain of the real motivations behind slavery, some argue that it was the idea that whites are above all other races while others say that slavery had been formed strictly for economic…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics