Biography Of Hegemony And Project Classroom Makeover: Book Analysis

Great Essays
Elite student in the 21st century are often described as, quick, witty, or shape. Now as time has passed, smartness found in students is not creative or intellectual but rather standardized and generic. Originality, within the student body has fairly decreased over the years. As the school system becomes more standardized, students start to lack creatively when the hierarchies main goal is for individuals to fit in a one-size-fits all model. In “Biography of Hegemony” and “Project Classroom Makeover,” both authors address their concern that the hierarchy in schools and Wall Street are placing standards on individuals solely on the importance of name and test scores. Karen Ho, in “Biography of Hegemony,” develops an investigating into the experiences …show more content…
Ho has stated, “Could it be at all possible that the culture of success at Harvard drives over to skip right over the most important part...getting to know themselves” (181). Cathy Davidson, in “Project Classroom Makeover,” addresses her concern of the hierarchies that have shaped the educational institutions and used a “one-size-fits-all model” for their children. In retaliation, she seeks originality and individuality in her classrooms, no matter the cost. Hierarchies in the educational institutions and the workplace are changing the identities of students with the standards and expectations with the influence of the highly qualified …show more content…
Karen Ho describes the smartness found in students not creative or intellectual, but is rather standardized and generic. On the other hand, Cathy Davidson seeks out to find individuality in order to help her students reach their full potential. In “Project Classroom Makeover,” the girl with the striped hair, had the inability to pass any of her end of the year exams, but discovered she had a talent where she could draw high detailed images. The hierarchies within the education system set a standard that an abundant amount of students cannot achieve, limiting students to certain skill sets. Similarly to Ho’s case, she describes the elite students as “standardized and generic.” Many recruiters seek out top institution students no matter what their major and skills they have. An abundant amount of individuals, who have attended a different university are highly qualified for the investment banking or consulting firm, yet, will still be compared to an unqualified Ivy Students Most likely losing the job to the Ivy student. The recruiters come to the conclusion that elite students think faster and solve obstacles quicker than an average student in a moderate university. Because of the standards the hierarchies set in the classrooms and workplace, they influence the change in the meaning of smartness. Once that met to be witty, sharp, and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    However, a student can maximize their education at the mediocre university because they tend to not compare themselves to other students and excel in the same classes as they would not at a prestigious school. Gladwell’s use of these examples shows how underdogs and outsiders have a bigger chance to win than we…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A long-standing tradition and measure of academic excellence, the title of valedictorian has been an intense point of contention for high school students in recent decades. In her piece “Best in Class”, author Margaret Talbot considers the consequences of naming valedictorians in the highly competitive environment of today’s schools. Appealing to students and school workers, she assumes an approachable, conversational tone, examining multiple points of view without obvious partiality. Talbot uses numerous interviews, anecdotes, and personal experiences to explain the aggressive contest for valedictorian and the legal disputes that follow. Talbot’s selection of interviews emphasizes the extent of the conflicts and the sentiments that contribute…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “To be considered ‘smart’ in Wall Street is to be implicated in a web of situated practices and ideologies,” which boils down to someone who has studied at an ivy league and can only showcase an impressive GPA, as opposed to seeking for someone with better qualifications and a vast resume (Ho 167). If an individual, who fails to enter any elite university, works excessively hard in another university while balancing internships and any other extra curricular activities to place him or herself in the category of “highly qualified” gets put to the side over someone who paid themselves into an ivy league, would that not decrease the value of working at such an establishment? Firms seem to want the smartest and brightest people in their workforce, so on paper, it would make sense to pick from only ivy leagues, but it has been proven over and over that in many instances, most individuals who are enrolled in top tier universities with extremely high…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are so many different types of institutions, ranging from religious institutions to work institutions. But in Karen Ho’s article “Biographies of Hegemony” she talks about educational institutions and how “smartness” is not just knowledge based, but also appearance based as well. Karen Ho dives into the study of the new educational system and how manipulative Wall Street is, starting with Ivy League schools. The discussion of Wall Street shows exactly how much power it has over the student’s minds and their decisions. The concept of standardization, student inequalities, and the conformity in a school environment are all explored in the pieces “Project Classroom Makeover” by Cathy Davidson and “Biographies of Hegemony.”…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Born and raised in a small town, my classmates were my only friends. It was a middle- class school where teachers knew our name, our siblings, parents, and where we live. Never venturing out to other schools nearby, I had no recollection of other types of educational systems. Jean Anyon’s 1980 essay “Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum of Work” helped me take notice to a problem in school curriculums. Anyon is effective in the way her essay can be interpreted but it has not made any difference in school programs.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Learning as Freedom”, by Michael S. Roth, is primarily a response to recent sentiments that higher education is a waste of resources. Roth states that his opposition frequently wonder why people who aren’t going to make lots of money in their future occupation bother with going to college. (1). According to Roth, advocates of this perspective see attending higher education as “buying a customized playlist of knowledge” (1), and nothing more. Therefore, if the knowledge gained will not insure the buyer great financial success, than why expend the resources to go in the first place?…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Graff's eye-catching and relatable introduction immediately sparks the question of what if the school is at fault for missing out on tapping into street smarts. He mainly focuses on the way that most kids view book smarts as a negative trait and how schools contradict this by having…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shamus Khan’s Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Paul’s School is a excellent example of the sociological imagination at work. The book examines the school from all angles, from different perspectives, and compares it to the school’s earlier years. Kahn often includes anecdotal stories of specific students in between his sociological analyses which help bring the situation to life and provide a more in depth look at the student’s lives. C. Wright Mills, the American sociologist who claimed that the sociological imagination was being lost in most research, would have found Kahn’s book to be a rich examination of the culture of St. Paul’s School. I.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In fact, the concerted cultivation method gives cultural capital necessary to success in school. This idea is underlined when she analyzes Garrett Tallinger’s organization of daily life. Garrett, a white middle-class child, follows a tight schedule, enhancing his negotiation skills with adults, whereas the skills earned by Tyrec Taylor, a black working class kid, are not necessarily valued in school settings. This existing correlation between social classes, build a different set of skills as well as knowledge, resulting in class inequality. Back in my home country, France, especially in Paris, the school we attend depends on the district in which we live.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The author of the book My Freshman Year enrolled herself as a student at a college university for the purpose of educating herself about life at college. She discovered that there was more to being a college student than what it seemed. Her experiences after a full year as a college student changed her thoughts and behavior towards other students. After a view changing insight to college life, she wrote a book to inform students, parents, and teachers that it is important to open their minds to reach a full understanding as to why people may act the way they do.…

    • 1845 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The author Susan Jacoby in an essay “When Bright Girls Decide That Math Is “a Waste of Time””, states reasons for avoiding crucial courses in high school by intelligent girls. The purpose of the author is to demonstrate that girls have more use of professional courses in their daily lives. Ignoring crucial subjects make them incapable of even everyday tasks. Jacoby discusses the reasons for girls putting professional courses aside are “wasting time”, refraining from appearing attractive and being limited by a lack of moral guidance (121-123). Intelligent high school girls anticipate professional courses are a squandering of time.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Equal opportunity in education is as realistic in America as it is to lick your own elbow or fitting your whole fist in your mouth. Equal opportunity in education is the prevention of any discriminatory acts against students, staff and faculty; however, in Mike Rose’s, “I Just Wanna Be Average”, he argues that the educational system is completely unjust for those in a lower program and that those that are in those lower education programs are not being challenged to their full potential. Rose brings up many important points in his study about the educational system, but fails to mention other factors that could cause a student to not reach their true potential. These factors, such as race and social class, nowadays, contribute greatly in the…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum of Work by Jean Anyon, she explores how different social classes influence education. She achieves this by observing five different 5th grade classrooms that she divided into the categories of “Working Class,” “Middle Class,” “Affluence Professional,” and “Executive Elite.” A “Working Class” school is a school that values order and gives the teacher complete control over the students. These classrooms mainly work on copying and rote memorization without knowing the ‘how’ or ‘why’ behind what they are asked to do. An “Executive Elite” school is a school that values analytical and comparative thinking and they work on analyzing things and applying or comparing them to current situations or scenarios.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The speaker of “Do Schools Kills Creativity?” is Sir Ken Robinson, he is a British author and speaker. The specific purpose of the speech is to show how creativity is just as important as other academic subjects to a student. The central idea is to inform adults, specifically teachers and parents, on how schools kill creative minds by tapping on the more technical subjects such as Math, Science, and literature. He employed impromptu when giving the speech and used topical as his organizational pattern because his main points could be used in any order without disrupting his tone. Sir Ken Robinson started the speech by making people laugh through humor.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Institutional and social constraints that are applied to keep people “in check” have far-reaching consequences when it comes to education and learning. Generally, these constraints set certain standards that do not augur well with the process of learning. In essence, what matters more in a system subject to institutional and social constraints is adherence to the rules of the game and not freedom for self-identity and interests. In her work “Selections from: Reading Lolita in Tehran,” Nafisi Azar presents, from the experience she had with her students in the Islamic Republic of Iran, some of the strong social constraints that had even been institutionalized and became part and parcel of learning institution like The University of Allameh Tabatabai.…

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics