SAT Argument Essay

Superior Essays
The SAT “is a sternly worded dinosaur of a test, graded in an arbitrary manner with outdated equipment…the only reason people take it is because they have to.” Children begin taking standardized tests in pre-kindergarten and by the time they are high school seniors, they’ve taken an average of 112 standardized tests (Strauss 1), all with one purpose: to measure and quantify intellectual ability. However, there is a growing mountain of evidence that suggests the SAT is a poor measurement of potential college success. The SAT is regarded as one of the more important tests, as it is used primarily to measure a student’s potential college success. For high school students the SAT is the gatekeeper of the future. It is an unavoidable hurdle for …show more content…
During that time, national college rankings were released and prestigious colleges began competing for the top positions on the list (Wong pars. 17-19), prompting colleges to favor admission of those that would improve their rank. This practice has led us to the current college admission process that requires a laundry list of qualifications, with SAT scores at the top of the list. Although, the current college admission process has exceedingly focused on students ' SAT scores and is widely considered a merit-based system, that has not always been the case. Prior to the 1950s, college admission was ethnocentric, reliant on legacies and wealth. Some students were even outright blocked from applying to a school based on race or socioeconomic background, no matter how high their test scores were. Compared to the exclusive “old boy’s clubs” of pre WWII, the merit-based system was a welcome change to higher learning and a victory for equality. In the post World War II era, college admission first began its evolution into the merit-based system we have today, where high grades and test scores are both a pre-requisite and a deciding factor; the remainder of a student’s repertoire only act as tiebreakers between two qualified applicants. With the merit system, “the United States has sought to put a college education within the reach of anyone with the talent …show more content…
SAT scores are still a prominent factor for many school’s requirements. This prompted applicants to focus on the criteria that most influences the admission decision-SAT scores. Lloyd Thacker, founder of The Education Conservancy, states that “the admission process today…allocates opportunity by deciding who gets into where [and] allocates [admission] values by determining what matters in preparing for, applying to, and selecting a college” (Lloyd Thacker qtd. in Wong par. 9). Privileged individuals use the colleges’ most allocated values as criteria, and focus on that which most influences the admission decision, SAT scores. This emphasis on SAT scores has distorted educational priorities and practices to the point where students at some schools begin studying for the SAT in 6th grade in an attempt to get ahead of the competition (Wong par. 2). The distortion comes from the mass majority of students manic to get into highly-selective, exclusive schools that only have room for about 10% of applicants. Wong does point out that this mania may only directly affect students competing for spots at the most elite schools, but the mentality of access to an exclusive club is something that all schools want to emulate, if only to bolster their application rates, and by proxy, their national ranking. (Wong Absurdity of College admission, Cont’d. par. 2) Those wealthy children

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    College is a coupon for success. In today’s generation, one is seen to be most successful and more likely to achieve accomplishments if they have a degree; in addition, the better the degree, the more qualifications are perceived to be prosperous. The point in general is that college, itself, holds a lot of potential that affects an individual’s life tremendously, therefore students see they have the right to verdict and combat for the grade in which they consider is deserving and reasonable. In Brent Staples’ essay, “Why Colleges Shower Their Students with A’s,” he gives reasoning for the great grade inflation that is steadily increasing.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Behind the SAT” by Andrew Brusso tells the story of the test’s rise to importance and how a device meant to eradicate an American class system instead helped create a new one. James Conant, a former president of Harvard and the father of testing, believed that in the fifty years preceding 1940s the United States went from being a “classless, democratic society to one that was relentlessly falling under the control of a hereditary aristocracy” (Brusso 53). Finally, Jefferson’s dream of a natural aristocracy could be put into effect. Conant believed that the SAT would determine and then select this natural aristocracy, creating a “new frontier for opportunity” (Brusso 53). What he wanted was to choose these natural elites fairly and precisely, send them on to universities, and leave the rest of the public to “a more modest yeoman’s existence based upon education through high school...”…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    College Overhaul

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages

    He counters this point, by explaining the students whose admissions were declined, still went on to do great things at less prestigious colleges. But to Cole, he knows that’s not the answer and I believe this point really grabs the attention of his readers. Finally, he turns to the “high-stakes-testing mania.” Standardized testing often places inadequate labels on children, but people don’t realize the impact this has on children as they age.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Then, suddenly, their own numbers were not good enough.” (Page 322.) This quote demonstrates the fact that students feel that they are defined by their test scores and they measure their academic capabilities. C.J. and her classmates feel confident in themselves, until they hear that someone did better than them. The SAT, as well as any standardized tests, are said to measure students aptitudes and predict how well they will do in college.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “Why Elite-College Admissions Need an Overhaul”, Jonathan R. Cole, the author of the essay, made a very strong argument on why the college admissions process is not right or fair. Within his argument, Cole states what elite colleges look for now, why what they look for is wrong, and what colleges should do instead of their current process to prove his point. I agree with Cole in his statement that the college admissions process needs an overhaul because there are some phenomenal students who are being looked over by colleges. Although I agree with his statements, I do not necessarily agree with the way Cole thinks the process should be.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    HBCU Argument Essay

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages

    At Spelman, Morehouse, and other elite HBCUs, the candidate does not need a high SAT scores or GPA requirement. These universities adopted a more comprehensive mission in which they examine the candidate’s future potentials and view each candidate individually as a whole. This unique aspect of the HBCU identity will be compromised deviate from their mission by using standards established by elite non-HBCU institutions, to the point where they lose their identities as…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As time periods have changed, so have the college admissions procedure and criteria. As of today, many believe that the education system is completely flawed, with this comes along the use of standardized testing and whether it is used for the right purposes. Like those who believe the education system is flawed, educational psychologist, Joseph A. Soares at Wake Forest University believes that “we seem in danger of loosing sight of education as more than just cramming a student’s brain for an exam” (Soares 7). In his online journal entry, “The Future of College Admissions:Discussion” he argues that “our visions of admissions have been too often blinkered by numbers with dubious diagnostic value” (10). To better clarify that, Soares is describing that we have lost the true meaning and purpose behind college admissions and determining true education.…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    SAT DBQ Essay

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Imagine you were the so-called “perfect” student. You got A’s on every assignment, you were top of the class, and you understood concepts perfectly. Then, imagine not getting into the your perfect college, only getting accepted into colleges that did not correspond with your academic level. You got beat out to an unworthy student who never turned in an assignment a day in his life, but, who just so happened to get a better SAT score than you. Most students would be devastated; unfortunately this scenario is exactly what happens to many students who take the SAT.…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My heart pounded. My knees shook. I feared the other twenty students sitting around me could hear my heart leaping out of my chest as I read each question on the SAT. When I looked around the room, I realized they all had the same look of terror on their faces as I did. This test determined the rest of our futures; whether we’d get into the college of our dreams or not.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College is a big thing for students that are planning on a certain job in the future. If the SAT(Scholastic Assessment Test) and other “big” tests were not effective in predicting the future of participants taking the test, why would a BIG portion of colleges use tests as a valid method of admission purposes. Evidence Colleges want to know what type of work an individual can do, and how they perform.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Argument Essay

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the articles “Three Cheers for the Nanny State,” “Ban the Ban!,” and “Soda’s a Problem but…”, all three authors present their arguments with facts, opinions, and counterclaims. However, one article presents itself better than the rest. I believe that the article “Soda’s a Problem, but...” was the most convincing article. Sarah Conly- the author who wrote “Three Cheers for the Nanny State”- argues that the soda restriction is a good idea because people would be stopped from making foolish decisions that they’ll pretty definitely regret.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    High school students planning to attend college usually have a dream school in mind. But what will determine if they get to continue their dream or have to reevaluate their college plan? A student 's standardized test scores and can either make or break their college plan. A student 's ACT score or SAT score will determine if they are at the academic level to be accepted into a college. Test scores throughout all ages are a very object and fair way to measure a student 's knowledge.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without problems and solutions there cannot be progress. This is the case for present-day methods of college admissions. Flaws in today’s college admission processes have driven students to cram themselves into the ideal mold sought after by top colleges. This has had various negative impacts upon modern student bodies by favoring certain groups, causing negative health symptoms, and limiting their creativity. These dark trends are shining brighter than ever and have drawn much attention, thus bringing insight and remedy to many of these problems.…

    • 84 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students who have strong SAT scores will need to submit them if they decide to apply to a more selective college. They want to stand out in any way possible when there are many more applicants that have the similar resumes (Wong). “According to a 2013 article published in Stanford’s alumni journal, more than two-thirds—69 percent—of the college’s applicants in the previous five years with perfect SAT scores didn’t get in.” The SAT can also show that students are willing to study facts and vocabulary that they will likely never use in their everyday lives. This skill can show colleges that the potential student has a strong work ethic and a real desire for success.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone has time to be healthy Freshman 15 is an expression used to describe an arbitrary amount of weight students put on in their first year of post secondary studies, usually due to unhealthy eating and poor exercise habits. Students say they struggle finding a balance between work, leisure, and maintaining healthy habits, leading to a lack of exercise, and poor nutrition. These complaints are clearly caused by a lack of intrinsic motivation and a growing status quo of complacency, rather than actual time constraints. Despite the vast number of home workouts that one can complete in under ten minutes, students will still excuse themselves from any form of physical activity, in favour of inactive alternatives. The problem is further pushed…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays