Maria Full Of Grace Comparative Analysis

Great Essays
Compare and Contrast the Ways in which Attitudes Towards Immigrants are Exposed in "The North" by Gregory Nava and "María Full of Grace" by Joshua Marston
The goal of this essay will be to investigate the context of immigration through the US borders by examining two films i.e. The North by Gregory Nava and Maria Full of Grace by Joshua Marston. This is due to the increase in anti-immigration rhetoric that is depicted by media outlets today. Interestingly, most individuals admit that their constructs of immigration issues stems from what the media presents to them. Public opinion on immigration issues greatly influences immigration legislation in a country. Juan F. Perea posited that what the general public believes or is made to believe directly affects how a country effects their
…show more content…
Before she left Colombia she was instructed to on how to conduct herself so as to not raise suspicion. The audience at this stage is exposed to the notions of how Americans view other races of nationals from countries that are not branded as desirable. The airport officer closely scrutinises Maria’s appearance and thereafter escorts her to the interrogation room. Border control officers scrutinize passengers without any clear regulations but through the power of observation and the relative system of individuation can be well illustrated by the films airport scene. The vagueness of US regulations on the inspection of aliens leaves it open to the interpretation of the airport officer to determine the legality or illegality of inspections. This makes many people susceptible to cultural stereotyping by the border officers (Newman 164). This raises the question of why Maria was stopped and no other drug mules. This performance mimics the reality in many of our airports today as it did not show clearly why she was stopped. Most can conclude that the attention to Maria’s appearance by the airport officer was a determining

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Handlin and Bodnar highlight different facets of American immigration history from the point of departure to trans-Atlantic crossing, to arrival and the development of ethnic communities in the United States. Authors Lee, Miller, Peiss, Ribak, and Alamillo expand and reconsider the basic story presented by Handlin and Bodnar. In “Uprootedness,” Handlin presents to us that the crossing from Europe to America was “harsh and brutal.” These immigrants were torn from their communities becoming alienated in a new place.…

    • 1762 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The novel I read was The Devil’s Highway by Luis Alberto Urrea. The Devil’s Highway is a true story about Mexican immigration to the United States. It retells the devastating journey of the group of men who attempted to cross the U.S. border by entering one of the deadliest regions in Arizona known as the Devil’s Highway. There were twenty-six men who entered the region, and only twelve survived. This journey was the largest number of border-event deaths in history.…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this assignment I have chosen to look more in depth at Immigration in the late nineteenth century until early twentieth century, and how this life changing experience was handled by different ethnic groups. In turn I will compare and contrast the essays of Victor Greene and Mark Wyman who both portray immigration in their own light. Victor Greens’s essay titled “Permanently Lost: The Trauma of Immigration” uses tools such as music and ballads to display how immigration effected certain ethnic groups and their families. While Mark Wyman’s “Coming and Going: Round - Trip to America” focuses on pamphlets given out in the workforce and more concrete evidence as to how and why immigration took place the way it did. To my mind Wyman’s use…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Death of Josseline, there are many conflicting world views. The author interviews and visits people with many different cultural backgrounds and views on immigration. These include border patrol agents, human rights activists, environmentalists, and the ranchers who live near the border. This conflict can be felt between these viewpoints all throughout the book. It gives the reader a clear perspective of what’s going on at the border.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Enrique’s Journey illustrates a strong argument on the issue of immigration that is cleverly hidden in the binding of the narrative novel. In effect, Sonia Nazario is able to extend her arguments with a higher degree of success by appealing to emotion more so than logic. Her use of pathos significantly outweighs any arguments grounded on logic, therefore she inherently establishes a persuasive text that encourages the audience to avoid objectivity and read the book through a lens of emotion. More so, the humanization of the issue of immigration by establishing empathy with Enrique and the various sub-narratives in the book add to the emphasis placed on creating a persuasive text rather than a balanced and informative nonfiction book. Photography…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the late 1800s, at the turn of the century, the United States experienced an influx of immigrants due to the industrialization occurring in large cities and states all over the country. However since the mid 1900s there was another rise in immigration, this time from the south. One of the large disadvantages of being a new immigrant is the lack of integration, not only that but immigrants face challenges every day. Apart from language skills, Immigrants in the United States face the loss of their cultural identity when they integrate into the mainstream society, and if they don’t, they may be subject to discrimination. This loss of identity then fuels various misconceptions of immigrants.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I am working on an article based on immigration, written by Jeanne Marie Laskas, in order to demonstrate how she uses figurative language, appeal to common sense to persuade her audience. Laskas in her career as a writer has written some interesting articles for magazines, and has six books in her account. Many of her articles are about migrant workers in the United States. Most of these she wrote to describe the conditions in which they work, and how they seem to be invisible in the eye of the rest of America. In “Hecho En America,” published on GQ Magazine in September 2011, Laskas brought people attention on immigration that is a current subject in the United States and in many other developed countries.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Octavia Butler Absolutism

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Patternist murder of Doro is indicative of Butler’s belief that absolutist cultures, by nature, are bound to fail in the long run, as they are incapable of competing with the collective cooperation of cultures. If one were to examine twenty-first century American immigration policy under same lense Butler held to the twentieth century (Mind of My Mind was published in 1977), one can observe a milder form of this culturally exclusive mindset in supporters of strict immgration laws. Additionally, twenty first century Germany is facing a monstrous influx of refugee immigrants, and a subsequent social clash of unique cultural values, as well as debate regarding how it should be dealt with legally. Octavia Butler analyzes past aboslutist manifestations of cultural prejudice to explore the dangerous intercultural mindsets that human beings are capable of. Just as twentieth century cultural imperialism spawned argumentative literature, one can infer that the probable existence of this mindset in modernity will spawn psychopolitical literature as it related to modern social structures, law, and international relations.…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This annotated bibliography is designed to give readers a comprehensive indication of readings regarding the “The effect Immigration has on the United States.” In recent times, majorly because of the presidential election there has been a lot of discussion on the subject of immigration. And so, I used various sources from journals, books, blogs and T.V. interviews to get information from a broad range and an insight of different perspectives about the subject of the impact immigration causes. Card, David. " Is the New Immigration…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The immigrants of America have enabled the country to move forward. Since the first settlers set foot in North America, immigration has suffused the American Experience. Indeed, many of the values that unite Americans as a nation are tied to immigration. Immigration has not only framed the American vision of the U.S., but has globalized the view of different cultures in the world that combines America as a whole.…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For most of American history immigration has been confronted; not too differently it remains a current debate to such degree that it has brought to light the reasons for massive immigrant movements and incredible measures used to stop immigration flo. The constant controversy of immigration has brought both authors to dispute the fact that immigrants have made a great impact on our society. In “Imagining the Immigrant : Why Legality Must Give Way to Humanity” (374), professor John J. Savant discusses the reason that caused the immigrants to flee from their country. In this manner, he encourages citizens to perceive their hardship and accept that immigration has always been part of American culture.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    government and some of its native-born citizens reject immigrants’ entry into their country. The article implies an idea of immigrants triggering a great deal of extortion, fear, and health concerns among Americans. Smith incorporates Rodolfo Mendoza-Denton’s— a psychology professor at the University of California-Berkley who studies stereotypes and intergroup relations—perception of immigrants entering other countries into his article. According to Rodolfo, “When [immigrants] arrive in the midst of a stable population that’s already worked out who gets what, the most common human reaction is to hog resources, not to share.” In other words, Rodolfo believes that immigrants are equivalent to scroungers or leeches, whichever one is more repulsive.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In “Should immigrants assimilate?”, Alejandro Portes and Min Zhou address the pressure to automatically assimilate that continues to hound second generation immigrants. They weigh the costs of this automatic assimilation and the effects of evident discrimination of a second generation immigrant that follows if assimilation is refused. Mary C. Waters’ article, “Debating Immigration”, acknowledges the inconsistencies of public debate and credible studies dealing with second generation immigrants and their assimilation. Waters’ argument widens the scope of Portes and Zhou’s take on the process of assimilation by providing a positive perspective and hindsight on the topic. Waters takes into account Portes and Zhou’s argument on how a second generation…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration has been the subject of a national controversy over the years in the United States. More than one hundred and thousands of immigrants are migrating to America every year. As some immigrants are legal, while others are illegal. Some are getting away from religious prosecution and political mistreatment while others come to search out the America freedom, benefits and protection. Either way, the migration of an immigrant had an exceptionally critical impact on numerous areas of American life.…

    • 1462 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Before throwing light on the trauma of immigrants, Hall discusses two positions of identity and relates it with cultural influence on the identities of immigrants.…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays