Stuart Hall Cultural Identity And Diaspora Analysis

Improved Essays
Stuart Hall in “Cultural Identity and Diaspora” says that Identity is not as clear or transparent as it appears to be, rather it is problematic (222). In postcolonial context identities can be seen as ever changing phenomenon and they are constantly shifting (10). According to him identities are not transparent and create problems for post-colonial subjects. Instead of thinking about identity as an accomplished fact, one must see identity as a product, which is never accomplished or which is never complete. In fact identity can be seen as a product, which is always in process (Hall, 222). Before throwing light on the trauma of immigrants, Hall discusses two positions of identity and relates it with cultural influence on the identities of immigrants. …show more content…
Hall argues that culture is very much there to shape identities of immigrants (223). He associates culture with identity because to him the identities of immigrants are always belonged to culture. Hall in Cultural identity and Diaspora gives two ways to understand identity. In the first position he defines identity as one shared culture and similarities amongst a group of people and the second position includes both similarities and differences amongst a group of people/immigrants, and moreover in this position identity is a matter of being and becoming (223). He describes these two position to understand the shifting nature of identities, but he clears that if someone wants to understand the trauma of immigrants in postcolonial context then the second position is more appropriate …show more content…
It involves both past and future. It is far from the issues of place and time and also from culture and history. It is about ‘what we really are?’ and ‘what we are becoming’? Cultural identities always a part of some history they come from a point which has a history. But they go through a process of shifting and transformation. Now they are not fixed as they were used to be fixed in past rather they are facing a constant game of power, culture and history (P, 225). It is not only about searching or recovery of past or a lost thing which on finding is going to protect immigrant’s sense of self and give them a position in past (225). Immigrants are always seen as “others” in foreign land they cannot get rid of their previous identities and faces difficulties to adopt new identities.
Identities do not have universality so they can shift or change themselves at whatever time and place as Hall describes this situation the formation of identity can be seen as ever-shifting or ever-changing process which is away from being fixed eternally in a postcolonial context (225). So Hall ideas of identity totally suitable for exploring immigrant’s trauma in a postcolonial society. He further explains that it is not necessary to know ‘who we are’ or from ‘where we have come’. In fact ‘what we might become’ is more important

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Being an immigrant to the new world was never a simple task. Adversity, opportunity, and adaptability lurked around every corner as these foreign families sought a new and better life. Struggling with standing out as a “new immigrant”, overcoming poor work conditions, pay, and unstable jobs, and seeking out new opportunities while adapting to necessary survival strategies are some of the many trials a new immigrant would face while coming to a new land. Having lived through it all, Kracha and Dubik from Thomas Bell’s Out of This Furnace saw every aspect of becoming an American.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Handlin and Bodnar highlight different facets of American immigration history from the point of departure to trans-Atlantic crossing, to arrival and the development of ethnic communities in the United States. Authors Lee, Miller, Peiss, Ribak, and Alamillo expand and reconsider the basic story presented by Handlin and Bodnar. In “Uprootedness,” Handlin presents to us that the crossing from Europe to America was “harsh and brutal.” These immigrants were torn from their communities becoming alienated in a new place.…

    • 1762 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The reading assigned is centered around the discussion of social identities given to the reader by Gwyn Kirk and Margo Okazawa-Rey. In this article the discussion of social identities are geared toward the identities we give ourselves and the identities society gives us. Kirk and Okazawa-Rey give plenty examples of how the social groups we tend to place ourselves might not be the same group society places us in. One example used was immigration in the United States. In many places all over the world most people identify with where they are from as their main “identity.”…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For this assignment I have chosen to look more in depth at Immigration in the late nineteenth century until early twentieth century, and how this life changing experience was handled by different ethnic groups. In turn I will compare and contrast the essays of Victor Greene and Mark Wyman who both portray immigration in their own light. Victor Greens’s essay titled “Permanently Lost: The Trauma of Immigration” uses tools such as music and ballads to display how immigration effected certain ethnic groups and their families. While Mark Wyman’s “Coming and Going: Round - Trip to America” focuses on pamphlets given out in the workforce and more concrete evidence as to how and why immigration took place the way it did. To my mind Wyman’s use…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the late 1800s, at the turn of the century, the United States experienced an influx of immigrants due to the industrialization occurring in large cities and states all over the country. However since the mid 1900s there was another rise in immigration, this time from the south. One of the large disadvantages of being a new immigrant is the lack of integration, not only that but immigrants face challenges every day. Apart from language skills, Immigrants in the United States face the loss of their cultural identity when they integrate into the mainstream society, and if they don’t, they may be subject to discrimination. This loss of identity then fuels various misconceptions of immigrants.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration: The History of Individuals In Hernighan’s Immigrants from Nowhere, it is shown through examples, imagery and pathos that one should not be categorized by their country of origin, but instead be defined by their experiences. First, examples are used to prove the issue of being treated differently based on origin. When the author was at a panel with another Canadian-born writer who had a European last name he was “…peppered with questions about his immigrant customs”(Henighan, 1). The Canadian-born writer was automatically assumed to be an immigrant based on his last name.…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identity is a key importance to the overview of any individual’s culture. Without the culture it begins to develop this confused identity that does not have a clear connection to oneself. Identity is important to the main body to understand history, language, and family connection. The loss of identity is caused by the forced assimilation to the Indigenous culture to create this blind imagery that one does not clearly demonstrate their own culture. Throughout the book Bad Indians by Deborah Miranda, it explains why an individual who has lost their true identity has lost the whole self of their character.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The authors' biography: I chose to write a critical account on an edited book entitled Fear, Anxiety, and National Identity: Immigration and Belonging in North American and western Europe edited by Nancy Foner and Patrick Simon. As the title indicates, the book is about the relationship that immigrants have with National Identity in western European countries and North America. When I read the title, the thought that came to my mind was that the issues raised and analysed by the authors in the book are current issues especially in this century where the place and role of immigrants has become more important than in the past. For instance, in the United States the Hispanic community has outnumbered the Whites in some states such as California.…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gloria Anzaldúa Analysis

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Addressing the complexities articulated within the act of ethnic identity enunciation, the art of writing is granted the power of eliciting a counter discourse. Ethnic identity, be it a heterogeneous construct fashioned by and through the narrative it sustains, unravels the interplay between competing discourses of power .To transcend the boundaries of marginality infused in the supremacy given to certain languages over others, voicing minorities plight of exclusion can only be maintained through the re- appropriation of their own linguistic medium .In the same way that language creates and determines discourse, identity is re-constructed; it is manifested in the very act of writing and narrating the shared experience of a given…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anglo Saxon Assimilation

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This sociological study will define the problem of Anglo-Saxon assimilation in the Canadian immigrant experience. Canadians from differing backgrounds define the problem of “dual identity” when attempting to assimilate into a primarily Anglo-Saxon culture. Isabel Vincent’s defines this phenomenon through the theme of a “mosaic” of Canadian culture that often divided Portuguese immigrants from Anglo-Saxon Canadian communities: “But we still had problems, and didn’t seem to belong. We never quite fit into the emerging Portuguese community” (Vincent, year?, p..145). In this manner, Vincent defines the divided sense of ethnic identity, which not only divided Portuguese-Canadians from the Anglo-Saxon community, as well as being divided amongst Portuguese…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This course has dealt heavily with personal identity and how it relates to culture. The text discusses identity politics, but in a different light, stating that it has created a culture that is far too sensitive to free speech. I find it very interesting that Stephens perceives social identification as…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Growing up as a young man, the word “immigrant“ never really crossed my mind,till i started to discover my family's history. I have immigrants on both sides of my family. My mother is from Belize and both of my father’s parents are immigrants, my grandmother is from Bermuda and my grandfather is from Poland. In the process of growing up, I started to ask questions I never knew the answers to and started to research as I never did before. Coming to a new found realization of the meaning of word immigrant .…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identity is quite a complex term. There are different types of identity including ethnic, national, personal, sexual and many others. Every person has a unique perception of reality, which forms there way of thinking and personal views. Identity pursues everyone throughout his or her life, and defines how we are perceived by others, as well as how others are perceived by us. Variety of different identities makes our world diverse, and makes each person distinctive.…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration in America and other countries is a very popular subject to talk about. It seems as though no one has the same point of view, and no one can agree which is the best way to integrate immigrants into society. Three writers, Andrew Cohen, Ruben Martinez, and Nell Irvin Painter, have all weighed in on this debate of immigration and given their opinion. While the participants in the debate about immigration share common ground over matters of fact and definition, they have not achieved consensus whether assimilation is still a requirement for cultural inclusion. As a result, rhetors that want to intervene in this debate should come in and explain the quality of immigration.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Heugh also talks about how with an increased rate of diversity and migration can cause national and ethnic identities to dwindle and make way for multiple, changing, and more individual identities. This is especially obvious when you look at it from the point of view of refugees and asylum seekers who have been thrown into these new social, linguistic, and economic situations that they have to adapt to so that they can successfully interact socially with…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays