The Celluloid Closet Analysis

Good Essays
In a country that promotes the mantra, “United we Stand”, it is actually quite easy to feel like an outsider. It seems as though WASPS control our world and all those who don’t fall into that category lack the means to change politics, society, or the economy. Throughout America’s history African Americans, Ethnics, Poor people, gay people, and women have struggled as outsiders. On the other hand, these groups have been able to gather themselves and assert their own self-image in culture as well. There seems to be a constant struggle between larger corporations associated middle class that use culture for social control, and marginal social groups that fight back to represent themselves accurately. Because of this struggle there is a duality …show more content…
Gays were excluded mostly in films. Strict production codes for movies like the Hayes Code made gayness forbidden in films up until the late 20th century. Hollywood’s strict rules forced gayness to be closeted and overt at best: “…Hollywood’s sly hints and inadvertent leaks, whereby it, for example, through Katherine Hepburn’s androgynous character in Sylvia Scarlett merely ‘Introduced the possibility of homosexual activity in the film…’” (Ross 168). According to the documentary The Celluloid Closet, gayness was made to be something to laugh at, to pity, and to fear thanks to Hollywood’s early construction of implied gay characters (Avila 8.1). For many closeted gay people in the community, watching this inaccurate representation in movies made them question if there was something wrong with them. Early in Hollywood’s history there was no outlet for an accurate portrayal of life as a gay or lesbian individual. For others, although the representation was inaccurate, they were just happy that it was represented in film at all. The Hayes code forced writers and directors to be very subtle when portraying gay individuals. Eventually when the codes were loosened up, gayness was talked about more directly. However, it was sill only used to criticize gays. It was implied time after time in movies that if you were gay you would be unhappy and die a tragic death. Gays and lesbians were portrayed as villains and as menaces to society. People in the studios who did want to change these representations of gays oftentimes did not because they feared losing their job and popularity. These early depictions of gay individuals were possible because of the agency of the Hayes production codes and the corporate studio

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    During the Lavender Scare there was a widely held belief that homosexuals were abnormal and a threat to society, because they eluded the traditional morals of America. By claiming to be homosexual meant that they instantaneously had to participate in sodomy or unnatural sexual activities because their anatomy did not allow for the traditional penal-vaginal sex. As well during this era women were not thought to have sexual pleasures, they had sex for procreation and only for the pleasure of the man. Conclusively, since women did not have the pleasure , recreational sex was not common and sex before marriage was unmoral. In comparison to today , the topic of sex was very closeted which is why homosexuality was criminalized.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One instance of weak censorship is violence in movies, as described by Kirby Dick in his documentary, This Film is Not Yet Rated. In it, Kirby discusses the unscientific way movie raters define what gives each movie its rating. He challenges the current, ambiguous method raters use to censor movies today. I agree with the director’s claim that our society today has become desensitized to violence. Violence in movies does not get censored nearly as much as sexual scenes do because of a long-existing taboo the American culture has had on sex.…

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Simply being gay and it just being normal doesn’t occur too often. Instead of just liking or hating homosexuals for their personality and traits, they are just completely hated based off of one part of who they are. People will see them as gay before they recognize them as a person. So if they don’t like gays, they will immediately dislike and have negative dispositions for them even if they didn’t do anything wrong towards them. Harassment is a real obstacle that gays face, there was once a time that my sister and I, who I note is a lesbian, were walking in the city after the 2015 Pride Parade.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Although, today that is not the case, and this gay culture is slowly but surely disappearing” Slowly but unmistakably, gay culture is ending”(383). The world is now more of acceptance of the term “gay”. Sullivan refers to those who are openly gay as apart of the “gay culture”. Culture is defined as”a particular society that has its own beliefs, ways of life, art, etc.”(Webster) which alienates these people from the rest of society. Giving it a negative tone to what it means to be apart of a gay community and sets a negative tone to homosexual in general.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Whitewashing In Hollywood

    • 1336 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Fans of Star Wars protested Boyega’s casting as one of the mains (John Boyega can’t reason with racists). On the popular site Tumblr, fans reacted by pairing the female lead Rey and the antagonist together rather than accepting the relationship between Boyega and Daisy Ridley’s characters. John Boyega spoke out against fans, saying “It’s not a normal thing to think like that” (Boyega) when talking about the resistance against this. The Hunger Games is another film that dealt with protest against POC casting even though Katniss is whitewashed. In the books, Katniss is dark haired, eyed, and skinned but was cast by Jennifer Lawrence who is blue eyed and blonde haired.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Homosexuals had a breakthrough into mainstream publicity. Even so, they still hid themselves by trying to appear straight so that they could be employed. With the DSM, people considered homosexuals mentally ill which caused them even more issues with employment. As time went on and the hippie movement happened, more homosexuals joined it and it allowed people to feel free and happy for some time. President Obama’s designation of the Stonewall area as a National Historic Site is a…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Abigail Graber's article “Television Encourages Viewers to Reject Homosexuals”, Graber faults media depictions of LGBT people as part of the reason gay people are discriminated against in places such as the workforce (Graber). Negative stereotypes in media depicting homosexuality as taboo and perverse have helped spread homophobia. Stereotyping LGBT people only furthers perceptions that being LGBT is abnormal, and thus treating them differently than heterosexuals is socially acceptable. Newsweek reporter Ramin Setoodeh notes that most gay men depicted in media are that of the effeminate flamboyant type that is widely regarded as a stereotype (Setoodeh). The idea that almost every gay male is effeminate and do stereotypical acts like “snapping a Facebook picture of Lady Gaga” (Setoodeh) is outdated and inaccurate.…

    • 1596 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Not everyone agrees with same sex marriage and some choose to show this through violence. There are a lot of reports of hate crimes against people who are homosexual because some believe that the lifestyle they chose is a sin. Some individuals choose to inflict harm on others to try to scare people into doing what they believe. By the government not allowing same sex marriage for a long time, it denied people their rights to do as they please with their lives. People who are homosexual were deprived of the same rights that heterosexual people had.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The author of the second article would also advocate that the homophobia needs to stop in the United States. It is unfair to keep gays and lesbians off of television, and it is unfair to act like they don’t exist. The author Nico Lang makes you question how much of the homophobia is still around in the United States. I never realized it was as big of a problem as it still is. Truly I thought in today’s world that everybody accepted everybody no matter the ethnicity…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Then, people in society try to tell them how to act according to what television and media says. Then, judge them for acting in that way. This is why it’s hard for homosexual men to be considered masculine because we are growing up looking at television shows that shows homosexual men as being feminine and saying that they are abnormal for the way they act. Therefore, they are villains of society and need to be taken care of. However, television has taken a turn on the stereotypes that are used to portray homosexuality.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays