Socrates In Clouds Analysis

Good Essays
Socrates is a great classical Athenian philosopher and he is credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy. When we talk about this person, we all know that he is known for bringing up a lot of great ideas, such as the Socratic methods. The ideas are characterized differently back in the ancient time. During the ancient Athenian time, there were two different images about the characteristics of Socrates. One of the images was written in Clouds by Aristophanes and the other was described in The Apology by Plato. Before getting into the details of these two different images of Socrates, we should have an idea that the purpose of each author should be completely different because of the difference of the genres. Clouds was a work of comedy, …show more content…
By Aristophanes, Socrates was obviously different from “philosopher” though he was called the philosopher, and he was even not the student of philosophy and truth. As describing in Clouds, a pupil of Socrates revealed that, “But the other day he lost a great idea because of a lizard” (line 168). According to our knowledge, a professional teacher should never be interrupted by anything if he was focusing on his thinking. What the pupil said had told that Socrates was not professional or focused enough, and he was even less serious about what he was thinking because he could easily lose his mind. Then, Aristophanes also characterized Socrates as the one who supported Atheism, “What do mean, ‘the gods’? In the first place gods aren’t legal tender here” (line 247). In Athenian 's’ eyes, the existence of Gods should be absolutely respected, and it was the responsibility of every person to believe in Gods, but what Socrates said was the opposite of what Athenian believed, he claimed that gods did not exist and he did not believe or respect anything about the gods, and things happened was because of normal behaviors. Later, Aristophanes provided an image that it should not be seen by a teacher. As we knew, patience was always needed for being a teacher, to Socrates, it was not, “What a moron! You’re a throwback, truly a neanderthal” (line 398). What Socrates said to Strepsiades was never the words that should …show more content…
In Clouds, Aristophanes expected the readers to understand that the existence of sophists could cause a lot of harm not only for the youth but also for the whole society, and this existence could even challenge the belief of Gods and Goddesses. Nevertheless, in The Apology, Plato provided a normal picture of philosopher, and Socrates was the one that truly lived in the life of pursuing the truth. Nowadays, it is difficult to decide which is the real image of Socrates, but there is no right or wrong to believe in either

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    No one knows whether death may not be the greatest of all blessings for a man, yet men fear it as if they knew that it is the greatest of evils. And surely it is the most blameworthy ignorance to believe that one knows what one does not know.” This is a quote from the Apology of Socrates. I understand we can not fear something that we do not know or understand, but also, isn't it allowed to fear the unknown? I do not agree with Socrates when he says we are not allowed to fear something that is unknown or something that we have no knowledge of. The only thing I agree with Socrates is when he talks about not knowing if death is good or evil.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Socrates Reflection

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The philosopher starts his refute by saying that his reputation is associated with wisdom and this trait is seen as unlawful [Plato 22]. He who has wisdom and a sense of higher knowledge, should not be punished for it. All Philosopher who taught topics that are up in the clouds are charged with the same charges every single time [Plato 24]. As mentioned before, Socrates was seen as an evil-doer and a corrupter of the youth, but Socrates countered to the jury that Meletus is a doer of evil. He makes jokes about a serious matter and is too willing to take other men to trial on accounts of topics he has no interest in whatsoever [Plato 25].…

    • 1813 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Socrates then proceeds to prove he cannot be both an atheist and a theist. The major problem with Socrates argument is that he is answering the wrong question. The original claim is not a contradiction as Socrates makes it out to be because it never says, “Socrates is an atheist who believes in daimonic activities and teaches this to the youth”. Socrates changes the original charge when he says, “Well then, you say that I acknowledge (believe) daimonic activities, whether new or familiar, and teach about them” (27d). This proves to be an inconsistency since Meletus’ calls daimonic activities, “believing in no gods at all.” The third premise is controversial in that it does not use Meletus’ definition of daimonic activities, but the definition that is colloquially synonymous with daimons.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Socrates was not corrupting the youth, but his teachings taught to question everything because you cannot be sure of anything. In the government's eyes, Socrates was starting some kind of movement by changing the way people perceived their lives and the way they perceived the gods. They unjustly accused him of crimes that did not fit the punishment given to him. Socrates’ was a good and wise man, but his teachings contradicted the Athens…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Religion was important to them because it explained the relation between gods and mortals, as well as the workings of the universe (P-194). Another accusation against Socrates was that he did not acknowledge the gods of the city state (A – 37). This accusation is shown in Aristophanes’ Clouds, when Socrates tells Strepsiades that the, “…the gods hold no currency with us.” (C-300). By having such an influential person teaching those beliefs, it would create separation in the Athenian belief system. The citizens also charged Socrates with acknowledging daimons and daimonic activities (A-37).…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Socrates, as a philosopher, goes around asking and questioning people on their beliefs and their knowledge. This is something that some gods do not approve of for it means Socrates is acting outside his human realm. By Euthyphro’s definition, Socrates is impious because he is doing something some gods do not approve off. Only actions that all gods approve off are considered to be pious. However, if an action is already deem to not be pious, then it does not matter if all gods hate it, the people will see it was impious regardless.…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Introduction Socrates is one of those individuals who helped in shaping the cultural and intellectual development of the world. From the reading of “Apology and Allegory of Cave” one can best understand him for his Socratic method of question and answer. He claimed to be ignorant and that the unexamined life is not wealth living for the human race. Whereas the Good Brahim story is an appropriate expression in defense of the low philosopher. Looking at Socrates’ attitude about philosophy, it can be notice that he denied having any kind of specialized knowledge, and at a point, he made an assertion that an unexamined life is not worth living.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For the first criticism I think that Machiavelli was right in criticizing Plato. As, Plato is just giving us assumptions without any proofs that what he is saying exists. Plato is building he our imaginary states with his assumptions. How we as people are required to believe Plato and what he is saying and there are no proofs for what he is saying. As the story of the cave provided for Plato, all what he is saying in the story for the cave is trying to convince us that the story is an example of the real world and how to achieve the idea of the good.…

    • 2024 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When people fear the unknown, they are unaware of the information that is present. When people take risks they have the potential to become a negative but also a positive situation, which results into fear because we never know the outcome of situations. In the reading, Apology by Plato, He created this reading because his speech defended what he believed in, which was that he is wiser than all men. This defensive system shows that he knows-that he knows nothing thus producing false wisdom as ignorance. Through Plato’s analysis he sees people who admire his thinking and sees those who are against it, thinking they brought him to trial.…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This justification is hard to believe for some readers considering that he argued against the existence of definite definitions of just and unjust and a professional in knowledge of all their features so profusely in “Euthyphro”. Additionally, by his demise, the world would be void of his philosophical contributions that he has convinced himself he should be remunerated for. Of itself, this outcome would be unjust. Socrates sustains this rationale, nevertheless. He gives “… that the really important thing is not to live but to live well”; also, “…to live well amounts to the same thing as to live honourably and justly” (Plato, 2003, p. 87).…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics