Symbolism In The Merchant Of Venice

Superior Essays
Mohit Ray’s Shakespeare’s Construction of the Jew discusses the complex nature of Shylock in The Merchant of Venice. The central argument is that Shylock’s construction relies more heavily on “historical imagination” than on “historical reality” (Ray 1). Shylock is created using the contemporary and prejudiced views of the audience; this image “becomes the stereotype and historical image of a Jew” (1). Although Shylock is a very strong adoption of the traditional image of the Jew, Ray points out that he is a man of dignity that pleads on behalf of the Jewish race and humanity (1). He also reveals the reason why the Jews were despised by the Christians and Venetians, as well as how their prejudice influenced the Jews. Despite the continual mistreatment by the Christians and Venetians throughout the play, Ray insists …show more content…
His point about Shylock’s three distinct stages of rebellion against justice was backed by substantial evidence from the play and very compelling. I never would have realized the bigger picture and thought about Shylock’s speeches as speaking from his personal experience with mistreatment, speaking for all Jews, and even speaking for humanity. It started with Shylock confronting Antonio about how he spits on him, calls him ‘dog’, and spurns him (Shakespeare 1.3.122-138). In Act III Scene 1, Shylock clearly speaks for his people and tries to make them more human in the eyes of the Christians who think otherwise when he says, “I am a Jew. Hath not a Jew eyes? Hath not a Jew hands organs, dimensions, senses, affections, passions” (3.1.57-9). Then in Act IV Scene 1, Shylock addresses the fact that owning a slave should be no different than owning a pound of flesh. While Shylock does recognize that the Christians are treating their slaves like animals and conveniently uses it in his argument, they aren’t his priority because he is more concerned about his pound of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Is The Merchant of Venice promoting or criticising anti-Semitism? Shakespeare passionately portrays characters in the Merchant of Venice that exhibit his conflicting perceptions towards anti-semitism in which he both advocates, condemns and remains neutral towards. Shakespeare can be seen to promote anti-semitic behaviour predominantly but not exclusively through the Jewish moneylender- Shylock. Who falls short to the many accounts of bigotry noted and directed towards him in the play. Antonio, who was consequently in relation to the more dominant Christian society casted a belittling shadow over Shylock.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The ‘Hath not a Jew’ speech in Act 3.1 shows that Jews are attacked because of their heritage. They are unfairly persecuted even though they eat ‘the same food’ and are ‘hurt with the same weapons’. Shakespeare uses rhetorical questions, such as, ‘if you tickle us, do we not laugh?’ which emphasises Shylock’s desire for acceptance. The repetition of ‘Hath not a Jew’ and ‘if you…’ implies that Shylock feels that his plea should be heard after years of being ignored. The reiterations in the speech add prominence to his message; to the audience he seems almost desperate for the acknowledgment of his humanity.…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In an incident involving dehumanization and hatred, in Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice, a Christian merchant, Antonio, consistently animalizes the Jewish merchant, Shylock for his religion and business in usury. From the daily condescension, Shylock results to exact vengeance on Antonio to attain peace for Antonio’s abuse towards him. And the Jew becomes Antonio’s foil. In dehumanization, one treats another individual less than human. Usually, people dehumanize others through bullying and lowering the individuals for whom the people are while exalting themselves to a higher position.…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By means of the printing press and commissioned illustration, which in the period was varying graffiti and image based booklet propaganda, affluent individuals used imagery to put an improbable ideal in the commoner’s head of what a Jew embodied. In this way, Jews were politically and socially attacked by Christian officials or elite who could not openly show disdain towards Semites, but rather privately through this media form. Ultimately, hate was shown in production of artwork which portrayed the people as these aristocrats designated. These works were to allegedly punish Jews for their crimes against Christianity and force blame for fiscal and public failures on the lesser race. Jews were depicted as often conspiring with the anti-Christ, satanic, hooved and horned, and or malformed in ways such as verrucae, emaciated bodies with disproportioned features, or with tails.…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shylock was charged the endeavor to murder a Christian resident, Antonio. Antonio snatched the opportunity to change over his rival from Jew to Christian. In the entire show Shylock endured a ton because of his religion. Ordinarily it appeared that the author concurred with the foul play forced upon Shylock, 'the Jew'. From the entire dramatization and the Elizabethan conditions, I can state that the essayist, William Shakespeare, concurred with the bad form appeared to the Jew.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The tribute was about to flog Paul to find out why the Jews reacted so strongly to Paul’s words. This is halted when Paul tells the centurion and tribute how he is a roman citizen(22:29). This begins to shows us the view of Paul by both the Jews as well as the Romans. The Jews hold a dislike towards Paul and his new ways, while the Romans show a sense of apathy towards Paul. Throughout the text there is a constant pattern of the Jews showing a dislike towards Paul while the Romans only acted or lack thereof because of the Jews.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jewish People Dbq Analysis

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the 19th century, the France government accused Dreyfus as guilty, just because he is Jewish. The man who accused Dreyfus knew he was innocent, but used Dreyfus as a cover up. It was believable because of the terrible acts that Jews have been blamed for in the past. Document four shows Leon Trotsky as the cause of the Russian Civil War. The White Army needs someone to blame to rally their supporters, so they blamed the Jews as the problem.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When he describes his theory for their loathing of Jewish people, Campbell blatantly disses them to their face: "Krapptauer's sort of truth would probably be with mankind forever, as long as there were men and women around who listened to their hearts instead of their minds" (Vonnegut 179). The sad truth remains that these unfounded opinions will not go away but instead last "forever." However, the audience fails to realize his criticism of their group. Because they make decisions with their "hearts," they produce an unstable foundation that simple objectivity cannot fix due to their ignorance. The biased audience either assumes the validity of Campbell's exaggerations or thinks of his insults as positives.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This inversion of values (which includes using the world ‘poor’ as synonyms with ‘holy’ and ‘friend’) constitutes the significance of the Jewish people: they mark the beginning of the slave rebellion in morals” (195). From this quotation, readers can see the repetition of “Jews” throughout, and this emphasis is evident that Nietzsche has a convinced desire in his text, and the readers can feel strong reactions when coming across that. Nietzsche essentially says “inversion of values,” and it led to new meanings of “good” and “bad”, which implies slave morality. The Jews, being frail and troubled, outwardly did not have a way to be “good”. Nietzsche, based off his tone, views the Jews as accountable for the rebellion that shaped slave morality.…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It can be manifested in many ways from expression of hatred to discrimination against individual jews. In this act, we saw how Shylock was being discriminated by the Christians in the play. Antonio lends without any charges while Shylock lends money with interest rates. Thus this brings down Shylock’s profit margins and earns him a bad reputation. In addition, Antonio has constantly bullied, undermined, harassed Shylock and treated him like garbage.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays