Robert Marks's Arguments On 'The Great Divergence'

Improved Essays
The Great Divergence

In the last 200 years, there has been a major change of power in the world, coined The Great Divergence. It is hard to believe that 200 years ago, two countries accounted for about two thirds of the world economic output, India and China . It was at this very same time in history that countries of the Western Hemisphere, primarily Great Britain, began eclipsing these two powers of the world. Overtime, many historians have come up with arguments as to why this change in power occurred. Robert Marks analyzed many influencing factors surrounding the event, a few of them being, conquest, trade, natural resources, and the industrial revolution. Professor Jared Diamond studied why the wealth and power of the world became so
…show more content…
Robert Marks made many valid arguments as to what lead to the rise of the West. The most compelling argument made was that Western dominance was a product of several conjunctions, convergences, and accidents. Some of these major events that took place around the world was, China ending its naval control of the Indian Ocean, Vasco De Gama sailing around the Cape of Good Hope, China choosing to use silver as their monetary system, as well as the discovery of the New World, and the discovery of large coal reserves in Britain. Up until the early 1400’s, China’s naval forces dominated the Indian Ocean. This was where the Chinese general Zheng He led several expeditions in the early 1400’s to establish overseas trade routes, and show others that China was the most powerful country in the world . However, due to some political uncertainties, China decided to focus more on the Mongols to the north than controlling the Indian Ocean. Therefore, their navy was almost non-existent to exist by the year 1450 . So far, the Indian Ocean had been a very peaceful trading destination for merchants alike . Until the Portuguese explorer Vasco Da Gama introduced armed trading in the …show more content…
However, this raised another question. People of Papua New Guinea have been farming for almost 10,000 years, why weren’t they able to flourish like the West? The solution to this question is the availability in crops. Papua New Guinea’s farming was based on plants like the Taro Root, which must be planted one by one. Also, the Taro Root cannot be stored for long periods of time or else it will rot, whereas, wheat can be planted by the handful and stored for a long time. There was also very little protein found in Taro Roots compared to wheat, leading to protein deficiency. Along with the spread of crops to Europe, they also received domesticated animals such as, goats, sheep, horses, pigs, and cows. Whereas, the only domesticated animal in Papua New Guinea was the pig. Pigs were a good source of nutrients, however, they cannot be milked or used to plow fields like the animals that migrated from the Fertile Crescent. With there being no surplus in food Papua New Guinea, individuals were unable to focus on other technological advancements, like the formation of metal

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    During the 19th and early 20th Century, industrialization became the main cause for the development of new industries, as well as the expansion of many nations around the world. With the discovery of new ways to use the raw materials found during the First Industrial Revolution, in addition to the finding and creation of new resources such as electricity, steel, and chemicals in the Second Industrial Revolution, major countries around the world set their sights on having spheres of influence in other nations that served as the most opportune sites and destinations for the trading world and industrialization. This led to the transformation of several nations, as the world powers at the time became imperial powers when they began to dominate other countries not just in an economical sense, but socially and politically as well. Although countries such as the United States and Japan engaged in part of these imperialistic tactics, the majority of the countries that exemplified imperialism were located in Europe. Nations like Great Britain, Germany and Russia began to flex their regal muscle over most of the other the countries in the Eastern Hemisphere through the use of the manipulation of the newly found…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past two centuries, Europe’s grasp on the world has strengthened and tightened increasingly, the “Western” influence becoming one that is looming and inevitable. Europe’s pre-eminence emerged almost accidentally, the product of an incidental group of conditions in the world economic system that Europe and America were able to properly exploit. This western influence that they exhibited was one that gleamed of new technologies and modernization, expecting the eastern world to quickly adopt their version of idealistic treasures. In the 19th century, after an extended age of separation, China, Japan and Korea were burdened from the West to open to foreign trade and relations. Because of the Industrial Revolution in Europe and the United…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Raveena Malhotra Mr. Haldaman APUSH 6 April 2015 Imperialism By the early ninetieth century America had an escalating reputation as a major world power. The United States had obtained this power through its involvement in imperialism, rapid worldwide expansion, and competition between other larger powers. Some larger powers, which include Germany, Britain, Russia, and France. Although, America was a large colonial power, it was not a sudden growth.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the Europeans did not head out in search of the unknown Americas, the continent emerged in front of them offering a multitude of new things which the peoples of the Eastern continent had never seen previously. Thus, the Europeans were able to transform earlier patterns of commerce by doing what no other country had done: traveling across the Atlantic Ocean and moving completely new product back and forth across the continents. They were also able to change patterns of commerce by creating an explosion of global commodity trade, particularly in stimulants, such as sugar and coffee, and in African slaves. In these ways did the Europeans change connections of commerce, however since the Europeans had nothing of value to trade in China, they had to assimilate into their trading network through tribute, by giving…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Great Divergence by Timothy Noah explores the potential causes and solutions for the crisis of rising income inequality in America. I would label the book as enlightening and informative because even though I knew income inequality was an issue in the United States, I had a very limited knowledge as to the causes and solutions of this growing problem before reading Noah’s book. I found Noah’s book to be written in a much more comprehensible manner than that of previous books read for this class due to the more commonly used style and rhetoric that I am more accustomed to reading. The book has a logical structure as it starts by dispelling commonly believed myths about the causes of income inequality and ends with presenting possible solutions.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mongol Empire Dbq

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There has been a long-standing and prevalent Eurocentric view of history--today’s relatively stronger economic power of the Western countries, such as European countries, the United States, and even Japan, is inevitable due to the innate superiority of European Enlightenment thoughts, Christian religion, and later industrial developments. (Marks 2-3) However plausible, this view of history is absurdly wrong when examined under the light of reality. Back into the 13th century, most of the world is connected with dynamic trade and communication between diverse cultural groups. Among those involved this world system, from the 13th to the 18th century, Asia acted as a vital political, cultural, and economical player and Europe was far from domination…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Maritime Exploration in the 1400s 1000 CE the vikings made the risky journey to Greenland and North America from Scandinavia and only until they made technological advance did they feel comfortable dominating the land. Muslims traders made early connections with Southern and Eastern Asia and Marco Polo’s experience even preceded theirs’. The spice lands were known for their international contributions and China, India and Africa were known for giving Europe most of their luxury items.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Over 20 percent of all American children live below the poverty line. This rate is higher than almost all other developed countries” (Schwartz). Why is the world so unequal? The world is unequal due to geography. Where a civilization is in the world affects what they grow, domesticated animals, minerals and ability to make steel, and exposure to germs and disease.…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trade flourished under the Yuan however in 1368 when the Ming dynasty took over all that changed. The Turks were able to take control over the western Asian trade routes and halted much of the European trade with China. Europe still wished to trade with China however they had to find an alternate route. They went to the seas to find a new route to China to reignite trade. While searching for new maritime trade routes to China one of the largest discoveries in history happened, the finding of the…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Age Of Discovery Analysis

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Often called “ocean going Junks”(Kalivas, Lecture 1), these fleets were led by Zheng He, a Muslim Chinese admiral who was in charge of leading around 300 ocean going Junks in an attempt to wave the Ming Dynasty’s banner around the Indian Ocean. These journeys were meant to develop relationships in the Indian Ocean in order to foster trade. Eventually, the Ming emperors were no longer interested in the Treasure Fleet due to the fact that they were more concerned with the Mongols and Manchus that were threatening to China’s northern frontiers. The Mongols even led the emperor to move the capital away from the northern borders to what is present day Beijing. The Treasure Fleet during China’s Ming Dynasty proves that China had the navigational tools and technologies for maritime expansion in the Atlantic Ocean in the fifteenth century, long before Western Europe made the discovery of the…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the Europeans first discovered the New World, everything was bound to change. New political, economic, and social systems were bound to evolve. After the discovery of the silver, the global flow of silver had a number of social and economic effects between 1500 and 1750. Trade started to include China more extensively, and silver was the only currency that Ming China accepted in exchange for their luxurious products (Docs 1, 3, 5, 7). In exchange for this silver, the Europeans received Asian luxuries and commodities on a large scale (Docs 2, 4, 8).…

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between 1000 and 1800, there was radical change in Europe and in the Americas, not so much in China and India. The reason for this was the Industrial Revolution which was a result of the Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution, the Scientific Revolution was a time of change that fed more changes. This created a culture of change. The Industrial Revolution, changed everything, from the economy, to how people lived their daily lives and brought social change. With all of these changes, there are winners and losers.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Allen came up with his own theory on the Great Divergence. Allen’s analysis starts from the 16th century, in which economic differences between countries were negligible. Then the author divides the last five centuries in three periods: the mercantilist era, a period of discoveries for the European countries, that helped to develop an economical integration and ended with the Industrial Revolution. The second period of catch-up, in the 19th century, during which Western Europe and the USA focused on competing and developing with a set of policies: “creation of a unified national market (…); the erection of an external tariff to protect their industries from British competition; the chartering of banks to stabilize the currency and finance industrial investment; and the establishment of mass education to upgrade the labour force” (p.2). The countries that operated with these policies joined Britain to form today’s rich countries, while Asia and Africa were left behind.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    East Asia in the 19th to the early 20th century was a time period of change, new approaches and constant pressures. After a lengthy era of isolationism East Asia was experiencing pressure from outside forces. The West approached with strong intentions and new ideas and unique cultural traditions. The Eastern Asian countries were finding themselves behind in advances in several different realms, such as, the military and in technology. Japan and China were suffering under the pressures to surrender to outside forces and open up trade with foreign merchants.…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction The most powerful and prominent force in the world has without a doubt has been, the rapid advancement of technology following the industrial revolution. From the introduction of the steam engine by James Watt to the mass expansion of railway lines, technological advancement has increased productivity and globalization exponentially. By breakthroughs in communication, transportation, and information technology, the world in which we reside has become unrecognizable to what it was 200 years ago. This essay encompasses these three ways in which technological advancement has completely restructured and revamped the world of as we know it. Cementing itself as the most powerful force on the planet.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays