Argumentative Essay On Right Vs. Responsibility

Amazing Essays
Right vs. Responsibility
Why states should protect one another.

Along the sunny shorelines of Lesbos, Greece, a small body washes ashore. A child, in a failed attempt to seek refuge from the terrors in Syria. Teary eyed volunteers grasp the child, and bury it modestly. The government stops these Samaritans from grave digging, resulting in complete outrage and many unanswered questions. Implicitly, they ask this: wouldn’t you want your family given burial if you were unable? Is it not within human nature to lend a helping hand? This paper will argue that states assisting other states can be beneficial (commensalistic, at the very least) not just economically but morally. Two major questions will primarily be addressed, as well as related questions
…show more content…
Under this topic, there is the issue of wealth and who has it. The more developed countries (MDCs) are the ones with the ability to assist other states because usually, they have less internal conflicts to deal with and more money to work with. Lesser developed countries (LDCs) tend to have too many internal issues to remedy before they can begin helping others. A report from the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (ICISS) argues that “what is at stake here is not making the world safe for big powers…but delivering practical protection for ordinary people, at risk of their lives, because their states are unwilling or unable to protect them” (Responsibility to Protect, 11). The ICISS rather bluntly brings reality to the situation; it is not the wealthy and powerful people, it is the regular and everyday people whose lives are in jeopardy. People who would otherwise not be, are involved in violence because of their state. Similarly, Luke Glanville articulates that in a commission by the UN, experts in a High-Level panel state that “governments have the primary responsibility to protect their own citizens from such catastrophes, when they are unable or unwilling to do so that responsibility should be taken up by the wider international community” (Glanville, 11). Glanville furthers the Panel’s point: the “issue is not the ‘‘right to intervene’’ of any …show more content…
These examples bring to light the question of the morality in their decisions, and their consequences. A contemporary situation is the island of Lesbos, Greece, where hundreds of refugees have washed up on the shore, deceased, in attempt to escape Syria. Volunteers gave the bodies simple burials, out of respect for the departed and their families. Eventually, there were so many bodies washing ashore that the ceased the burials. People were disgusted, because they felt for these people so strongly. The state chose to stop burying citizens of other states. This relates to the example of Antigone’s persistence in the burying of her brother, Polynices, in Sophocles’ Antigone. Polynices was branded as a traitor and had lost his citizenship to Thebes; King Creon refused to bury him, letting his body rot. Antigone could be compared to the volunteers who buried the refugees because they knew it was right—she wanted to give her brother at least a simple burial. King Creon, representing the state, considered Polynices a non-citizen and did not allow for a burial, as he explains that “an enemy is always an enemy, even in death” (Antigone, 522). Both of these examples showcase the state exercising their right to choose who to provide aid to, but any moral person would be left uneasy at

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    With this in mind, Antigone is later accused of civil disobedience, or the refusal of a citizen to obey a certain law enforced by a ruler or the government. A true display of civil disobedience by Antigone is when she states “I will bury him myself./And even if i die in the act, that death will be a glory” (Sophocles pg. 63, lines 85-86). This quote represents civil disobedience because Antigone is defying the law of not burying a deceased family member and has no worries about it because she knows that it is right. In a way, Antigone herself can represent the strong value of family, which is hindered by the law favoring authority since Antigone wants to do anything in her power in order to honor her deceased brother.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ismene answer Antigone when she asked her to help her with “You mean to bury him? In spite of the edict” (line 51). Even Antigone's own sister who is also the sister of Polyneices will not help he bury their fallen brother. This shows that everyone else in the kingdom but Antigone see’s Polyneices body staying unburied as the right thing or they are too afraid to take action. But not Antigone, she knows deep in her heart that this was the right thing to do no matter what others say or do.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When Kreon attempts to cover up the fact that Antigone had attempted to bury her brother by telling her he would pretend it hadn’t happened and would just tell the people she was sick and needed time to rest, in Sophocles’ Antigone, Antigone says, “Dear god, shout it form the rooftops. I'll hate you all the more for silence -- tell the world!” (100-101) telling Kreon that she will not stand to be treated differently than anyone else would have been. If Kreon decided one of her brothers is to be buried and the other to be let sit and rot to prove a point and warn the people what will happen if you defy the law, why should she be held above the law? Sophocles writes, “I would not welcome such a fellowship. Go thine own way; myself will bury him.…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Sophocles makes us think about whether we should follow moral or political laws in his play Antigone. Antigone is the sister of a recently deceased traitor who has been sentenced to no burial by Creon, who acts as the king and also Antigone’s uncle. Antigone makes the moral choice to disobey the law and bury her brother, following the law of the gods. Creon sentences Antigone to death after her arrest. Creon faces the conflict of being a strong leader who sticks to his law, or letting Antigone go with the possibility of portraying a passive leader that does not abide by the rule of law.…

    • 1478 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    My fellow Thebans, I am here today to justify Antigone’s actions in burying her brother. As I stand here and profess my feelings, I hope you can imagine yourself in Antigone's shoes. Many believe Eteocles was a traitor for starting a war on this country, and did not deserve to be buried. Antigone is being taken as a traitor for burying her beloved brother. Antigone’s actions are justified in the way she honored her brother in a proper burial.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The war between the two brothers was something unexpected in the town of Thebes, therefore, both Antigone and Creon had different opinions about Polyneices and the war between the brothers. Antigone certainly does not pick sides, and we can see it as we read this passage on page twenty-two, Antigone explains this to her sister Ismene. “Creon will give the one of our two brothers honor in the tomb; the other none. Eteocles, with just observance, treated, as law provides he has hidden under earth to have full honor with the dead below. But Polyneices’ corpse who died in pain, they say he has proclaimed to the whole town that none may bury him and none bewail, but leave him, unwept, untombed, a rich sweet sight for the hungry birds’ beholding and devouring.” As Antigone explains this to her sister, we see where she is having trouble with only one of her brothers getting buried, and the other one getting nothing.…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This may have been the start of eradicating the disease. Boccaccio describes the change in funeral traditions. Why is there a change? Normally, funerals would have officials, mourners and solemn prayers but changes had to occur. Now priests did not, “go to the trouble of pronouncing solemn and lengthy funeral rites, but with the aid of these so-called sextons, they hastily lowered the body into the nearest empty grave they could find.” (pg.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Sophocles’s Antigone, Antigone, who was mourning for her diseased brother, morally believed it was right to break the law and bury him. Antigone tries to get her sister, Ismene, to help her in the act of burying their brother, but she refuses (Sophocles). Ismene states that she cannot break the law, or disrespect her citizenship by burying him (Sophocles). Their brother, Polyneices, was treated unfairly by not being buried alongside with his brother Eteocles, who Creon, the King, allowed a burial and respected farewell for. Creon strictly rules the city in a negative way, and control those in the city to what he believes is right.…

    • 1937 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both of her brothers fought in a war, one for Thebes, and one against. They killed each other in battle and King Creon honored the one that fought for Thebes with a proper Greek burial, but has forbidden anyone to bury Polyneices, the brother who fought against him. “But Polynices, a dishonored corse, (so by report the royal edict runs), no man may bury him or make lament -- Must make him tombless and unwept.” Antigone believes it is her duty to give him a proper burial, and if she fails to do so, she believes his soul will wander. She views that family is more important than the law, because if she disregards King Creon’s decree and buries Polyneices, she will face…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Nobody encourages her to defy Creon’s orders and provide a proper burial for her brother, but rather, it is a decision that results from Antigone acting in accordance with her free will. When Ismene tries to convince Antigone that burying Polynices is not worth the risk and punishment of death, Antigone replies, “You have your excuses. I am on my way / I will raise a mound for him, for my dear brother” (Antigone 94-95). In this instance, Antigone is effectively taking a stand for what she believes in as she values family ties and loyalty as well as the virtue of courage. As a true tragic hero, Antigone does not let society influence her decisions or dictate how she should act and feel.…

    • 1983 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays