The Great Gatsby Rhetorical Analysis Essay

Improved Essays
Not everyone finds books to be equal in value or importance because we all have our own tastes in writing. In the article, The Great Gatsby, lead literary critic, H.L. Mencken, criticizes and reviews one of Scott Fitzgerald’s more popular novel, The Great Gatsby. In his writing, Mencken what he dislikes and what he believes is lacking in Fitzgerald’s novel. To accomplish the feat of criticizing a well-liked book without invoking an indignant reaction, Mencken uses rhetorical strategies to convince the reader of the flaws of the novel.
Keeping in theme with the extravagance seen in The Great Gatsby, Mencken uses a similar strategy that Fitzgerald used throughout the novel. While describing the plot of the book, Mencken writes that “the garage
…show more content…
Mencken compares the short length of The Great Gatsby to Fitzgerald rushing “to his death in nine short chapters,” criticizing how quick Fitzgerald drew Gatsby to his death in the novel. This effectively illustrates Fitzgerald as a desperate fool who didn’t take enough time to fully develop and write the book to completion before it was released. It is a sign of a great writer when they can bring every character, no matter how trivial, to life in the reader's mind, and to make the reader live in the world of their creation through intriguing rhetorical devices and detail. Mencken dislikes that Fitzgerald didn’t expand into more of the characters besides Gatsby, comparing the rest to “marionettes- often astonishingly lifelike, but nevertheless not quite alive,” and dolls just there to fill a role. Mencken wishes the other characters lived and breathed like Gatsby’s character did; because Fitzgerald didn’t dig deeper into the majority of his characters it caused some to become unlifelike in fake in the context of the novel. The comparisons allow the reader to understand and draw connections between the flaws in Fitzgerald's writing in an easily digestible

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A reviewer on GoodReads.com who calls himself Tom Tobasco even labels the novel “a beautiful empty box” adding that the author spent so much time “working on the box and the wrapping, that she forgot she actually had a flipping novel to write! A story that is worth telling!” The message here, that readers want a plot that is easier to follow, demonstrates that while the prose and poetry may be of great value of their own accord, without the connection between readers and plot, that value is…

    • 1074 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many writers attract negative criticism, but few of them seem quite so hated by their belittlers as Stephen King is. According to Marcus Geduld in “Should Stephen King Get More Credit As A Writer From Literary Critics?” King’s prose simple “gets the job done” or is “just a hack” and can only describe a blurry world in general terms when he strays from his obsessions: horror. Undoubtedly, the role of the critics are vital. The critic is the second most important facet, next to the author and the work…

    • 343 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tell Tale Identity Essay

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages

    All of this repetition and italicisation further implicates the narrator as unstable and having a weak mental state further adding to the construction of identity by the narrator in this text. And this is important as writing in this way allows Poe to interact in a more personal way with his readers, making them feel as though they are observing the actions within the story first-hand and having them explained to them by the narrator as they read. But the narrator’s explanations are weak and their theory unsound, the events occurring within the story are described fairly truthfully by the…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Turning a billboard into God, a green light into hope, and an almost garbage dump into a nightmare are just a few ways Fitzgerald used symbolism in The Great Gatsby. Making the reader think more deeply about the simple aspects of his novel is one of the many ways Fitzgerald makes his novels more intriguing. However, this style of writing also makes the piece of literature more difficult to comprehend. Without symbolism, The Great Gatsby would be a simple story of simple people doing simple things, but with the way Fitzgerald utilizes the symbols in his book the story becomes a story of a man in an odd place with a desire for something…

    • 1525 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Oddly enough however, both Reader Response and New Criticism are in agreement that “we cant know for sure what the author intended” (Lynn). Even so, where Reader Response Criticism thrives is in the assumption that “the text itself is meaningless unless a reader responds” (Lynn). Where New Criticism makes a point to confine your analysis by valuing a literary work for its artistic complexity, Reader Response Criticism invites me to “actively create (rather than discover) meanings in the text” (Lynn). All this considered, once I actively applied Reader Response Criticism to Brave New World, I found myself taking in the text with a more meaningful and personal…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Orwell explains that his writing is a product of the times, and that if he had lived in peaceful times it would be likely that his fiction would be very different than it is ow. However, he writes about what is necessary to write about: anti-totalitarianism and pro-democracy. What is interesting to this reader was Orwell’s confessions at the end of the essay, stating that all writers are rather possessed by a strange demon because writing is really not very enjoyable.…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The poem “Alone” by Edgar Allan Poe has a similar, judgemental, tone to “Heart of Darkness” by Joseph Conrad. While Conrad is judging the colonists, Poe is using a speaker who is judging himself. Both authors care about the topics in their work. They are honest about the trouble facing them even when they could take the dark parts out of their works they choose not too, in order to give readers a better view of the…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, in order to convince the reader that changing words have unintended effects on the audience’s evaluation of the work, the author illustrates that the word “‘slavery’ doesn’t carry the same shock value, and so it toned down what Twain is getting at.’” Another example would be when the Smiley states that the values hidden in the book covered with a “comic veneer” are “transient,” which provides a reason for the action of the publisher to modify words that they view inappropriate. More importantly, these examples also…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He is a perfect example of what the people in his caste should be, but yet he feels that the stuff he does is empty meaningless and would prefer to use his writing abilities for something purposeful. In the beginning of the novel the director says “And that, that is the secret of happiness and virtue—liking what you 've got to do. All conditioning aims at that: making people like their inescapable social destiny” (Huxley 15). That quote points out Helmholtz’s flaw in…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Are We Rome Book Review

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Throughout his work, it is clear that Murphy prefers to relate Roman culture over an equal analysis of American society. This hinders his ability to fully address his thesis, he lacks a clear consensus to address the issues he raises about the future of America in the same way he dissects the fall of Rome. I agree with his thesis, I also believe that while we can recognize flaws today in the US, we are still in time to correct ourselves. Through, Murphy leaves the reader unsatisfied by limiting the solutions he proposes for these flaws, which also greatly degrades the literary quality of the…

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays