Religious Idealism

Great Essays
Religious sentiment had long been thought to be inferior to the concept of natural religion. The truths of natural religion were widely accepted as self-evident from the middle ages throughout the enlightenment. Only after the truths of natural religion were question and its self-evidence evaporated, did the pious find recourse with religious sentiment. This is best exemplified with the psychologist William James; he transformed religious discourse by denouncing Natural and Institutionalized religion while at the same time embracing and vigorously defending religious sentiment and experience. James' (who shares name alone) views on "medical materialism", "religious optimism", "unseen reality" and "survival theory" will henceforth be elaborated. …show more content…
James holds that religious experience is unique in that it allows for an optimistic, joyful acceptance of the universe that is not found elsewhere. The world is one of suffering and dissatisfaction and religion provides a key outlet for providing meaning in the face of this suffering. To James, the irreligious sufferer has limited options. The first is to simply accept that suffering and meaningless is endemic to the universe and become a pessimist. James has a problem with this viewpoint, as it prevents those from engaging in meaningful activities for themselves and other people. Another option is to accept the universe as the stoics did. The problem with this viewpoint in James' perspective is that this kind of acceptance is cold; it lacks the fervor and joy that is found in religious experience. The main reason why this is the case is that irreligious stoic is left to deal with the universe completely based upon their own power. A religious experience allows one to give into the forces of the universe, it is simply easier from a psychological perspective to remain useful. The irreligious sufferer is constantly forced to deal with the universe on his own, without any sense of psychological support system that can be found in religion. Religious experience gives the sufferer the faith that the universe is not entirely against …show more content…
James defines religion as an individual's feelings towards whatever he or she considers the Divine. The Divine is not strictly defined as a deity; James holds that Buddhists and even secularists can have some idea of the divine. The Divine is simply some sort of conception of a whole that exists independently of the individual. Religion to James requires some viewpoint about the universe as a whole that is neither complaint nor ridicule. This entails a kind of viewpoint that everything in the universe is not vanity and worthy of taking seriously. On the other hand, the universe is not something that can be dismissed or rejected. All religion requires the submission in some form or another to this divine in order to completely understand your relationship to it and fully realize these psychological, emotional and moral messages. The exact nature of religion helps clarify its

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Aquinas Argument Essay

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages

    God might have allowed us to suffer through pain so we can learn and we would be able to appreciate the good things in life much better. It may as well act as a cautionary sign from God to not do things that can instigate harm to our physiques or to the people surrounding us (Creel, 2013). Despite some philosophers’ such as Madden, Leibniz and Rowe’s arguments pointing out that the extensive and extent of evil in the world cannot justify the unseen greater good that may come about, it does not necessarily mean that there is no greater good that would occur or that God does not exist as some would have believed since these states of affairs are the kind which a supreme being would not allow God (Creel, 2008; Trakakis, 2006). Nevertheless, God cannot be held responsible for evil. This is because God does not possess human potentialities provided to human beings, which accordingly gives them the free will to choose between living up to the good nature initially brought to them, or doing evil (Creel, 2013).…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A major element discussed throughout moral philosophy is emotion. The Stoics and Augustine have similar views, but both have distinctive characteristics about their view that is different from the other view. The Stoics are very one sided and disregard any type of emotion. While Augustine feels this is sometimes the case, he also feels that emotions are necessary to help guide a person to what is good. Likewise, both views incorporate God and relate Him to emotions, or lack thereof.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He finds himself in the maze of circular reasoning about not erring about God because God is an entity that cannot err so the premise fulfills the conclusion. He is satisfied not knowing the reasons for his imperfection and relinquishes his critical intellect to mere some reasoning the supreme creator has. His reasoning for human errors is a simultaneous concurrence of intellect and will. He agrees that all the intellect should not be given to one person rather than be distributed amongst many. He also agrees that his intellect, faculty of understanding, memory or imagination are highly feeble and limited that of God.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An example to highlight this problem: Individuals of world religion ‘A’, ‘B’, and ‘C’ all have religious experiences which, on the basis of the Principle of Credulity, should be accepted as genuine. However, religious system ‘A’ claims there is a single God, religion ‘B’ claims there to be a multitude of gods, and ‘C’ claims there is no god at all. In addition, their experiences conform exactly to their religious belief system. What can one conclude from this? Each of these religions claim that their own religion is the true religion, and thus at most one of them can be right since they are mutually exclusive.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Mayan Religion

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    They provide an attractive contemplation of the spiritual life and a different point of view. For many, the spiritual side of life is an interesting subject to study on and develop. In conclusion, the Maya civilization beliefs are based on faith because none of their arguments is base on observation can’t be justified and proved. The way they thought life was created and what the universe was supposed to be is not concrete its all related to gods and spirituality which can’t be observed or proved. This being said, maybe one day we will be able to prove the Maya civilization beliefs and understand fully their point of view and…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Touching the Holy One of the main themes of this book is to understand that God love us unconditionally, and no matter where we find ourselves, God 's love for us is unchangeable, His love for us is not based on our merit, it is based on His goodness. Robert Wicks helped this reader to appreciate his own ordinariness, it is our lack of trust in His love that keeps us from approaching our loving and caring God; our self doubts, our negative thought, the pressure to be extraordinary are the things that keep us from receiving the love of God, the author emphasize the importance of having self-esteem, and he also help his reader to understand and accept their ordinariness. The author helps the readers to understand that failure to accept our ordinariness is cause by pride, people who are dependent on God, they have the ability to simply be themselves, with all their failures and to simply be themselves. They don 't value themselves above others, but they also don 't depreciate themselves and what they have to offer. They simply accept who they are in the eyes of God, their value is not found in their performances, but in who they are in God 's eyes.…

    • 2142 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Faith And Diplomacy

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Even though religious faith has the power to unite, it also has the power to divide. In many cases people having one religious perspective may unknowingly act prejudicial to those who have different perspective. This may be due the fact that many major religions promote doctrines that assert that it is the sole true religion. As Dalai Lama states: “We need a moral compass we can use without getting bogged down by doctrinal differences.” (139) He acknowledges that differences in religious perspectives can slow down ethical response to challenges or even completely impede it. That’s why being free of religious faith has its advantages.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Religion is therefore faith in a supreme external entity, called God, it is essentially the belief in something outside the boundaries of reason. Every being needs something to believe in. Back in the old days, religion speak the human needs that scientific theories could not satisfy. It was a means for people to find comfort in ignorance. Knowing more about religion did not increase doubt, but instead increased confidence, giving comfort to the…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, as time progresses, not only does religion benefit the human population, it also causes conflict and creates rifts between territories, nations, and people. The protagonist of the novel Life of Pi, Pi Patel, demonstrates the perfect balance of religious devotion and acceptance. His life, although fictional, can teach others to be more accepting of various religions and to be peaceful in the name of one’s own religion. Experts have been quite perplexed at the concept of religion. Even the earliest humans had some form of religion, which poses the question, “Why?” One answer to this question is that religion provides humans with the answers to questions that they cannot easily respond to.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I agree that both of Saint Augustine’s ideas are good ways to think of God as all seeing, but that humans still have free will. Knowledge of the future really does not cause someone to do anything by force. We do live and do what we want. God may truly be eternally present from the idea of God always being right there with you in all the good and bad. He is in the moment by the beliefs of the Christian faith.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays