David Hume The Design Argument Analysis

Improved Essays
Philosophy has been plagued with the subject of religion since the dawn of time. Each philosopher having their own opinions, many attempts have been made to prove and disprove their opinion and the opinions of others. The existence of God, a single, supreme being who created the heavens and the earth, is a controversial topic, but even among those who believe in the existence of God, finding a way to explain such existence has been nigh impossible. An 18th century philosopher, David Hume attempted to establish his opinion on the existence of God by critiquing the widely accepted ideals set forth by Descartes. Hume delivers convincing arguments against both the Ontological and Design Arguments by using his distinction between matters of …show more content…
According to the Design argument, 1) there is design in nature and 2) because design is the product of intelligence, 3) nature is the product of intelligence. Therefore, 4) God exists. Before truly divulging into Hume 's critique of the Design Argument, it must first be noted that this argument is an example of Hume 's Matter of Fact reasoning. This means that the argument is based solely on our experience of the world as a harmonious world of order and natural design. To apply this reasoning to God and the making/maintaining of worlds, we would require knowledge regarding prior creations. As the universe is singular in our experience, such knowledge is impossible to gain and as such, Hume believes that no argument from experience alone can establish certainty, only probability at best. For Hume, the Argument of Design also resembled an analogy. In this analogy, it is said that 1) if a machine is the result of intelligence, and 2) the world is like a machine, then 3) the world is the result of something similar to intelligence. By using an analogy, one could arrive at many different conclusions, each possessing similarities and differences. If we were to compare God and the world to a worker and a machine, one could argue that if there are several workers, could there not be several Gods? As there are “bad” workers, could there also not be a “bad” creator of the world? And as machines are made by mortals, could not God be mortal? Using an analogy, any conclusion can be justified, be it good or bad. Analogies require a great deal of inference, and as we do not possess the experience necessary to make such inferences, we cannot definitively use analogies to depict God accurately. We cannot say that the design of the world is proof of God 's existence. It would be hard to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In this paper I will explain and evaluate two popular arguments regarding the existence of God, A Scientific Argument for the Existence of God by Robin Collins and The Inductive Argument from Evil Against the Existence of God by William Rowe; then I will discuss how the conclusions are not compatible with one another due to the conflicting structure of the conclusions as well as how one cannot accept both conclusions without compromising one of the arguments. First I will explain the basis of Collins’ argument, which is one of the most frequently used arguments in favor of theism. In A Scientific Argument for the Existence of God, Collins centers around the observation of how finely tuned the physical constants of the universe are to the ability for any form of life to exist, if any of them were to change even the smallest bit then no life would possibly be able to develop not to…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cleanthes Vs Demea Essay

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Philosophy Final Paper In this paper, I will argue that Philo offers better arguments for explanation of God’s existence than Demea and Cleanthes. During Hume’s days, the 1700s, science was not very advance and many philosophical arguments were based off of empirical observations. This paper contains information regarding how the argument between the three panned out and contains my thoughts on the conversation. While I do not have all the answers on these matters, I will provide my views and arguments in hopes of presenting a different perspective.…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Hume's Argument

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Hume begins his argument by asserting that animals, just like humans, learn from experience and come to infer causal connections between events. Hume describes this principle by saying: “[animals] become acquainted with the more obvious properties of eternal objects, and gradually, from their birth, treasure up a knowledge of the nature of fire, water, earth, stones, heights, depths, &c. and of the effect, which result from their operation” (Hume, 70). In order to illustrate his point, Hume cites several examples: horses learn what heights they can safely leap, and dogs learn to fear the sight of a whip (Hume, 70). Furthermore, Hume claims that non-human animals certainly do not learn to make these inferences by means of reason or argument.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Counter Argument for the design basis solely on the lack of prove that the perfection of the creator, monotheism and many other design arguments are not proven. As the universe is so complex in design, there must be a complex intelligence Hume guesses as to whether or not this universe is actually complex. We have got nothing to compare it to.…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Religion is a matter of personal belief, faith, or dogma. The majority of religions are centered on the existence of one or more gods. The existence of God, or multiple gods, is a priori truth- no observation can show that God does not exist. However, there is also no observation that prove that God does exist. This dilemma has driven many philosophers to propose numerous arguments against and for the existence of God.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Argument from Design,” William Paley argues in favor of the existence of God by drawing comparisons between a watch and the universe. David Hume debates the existence of God using three characters in “Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion.” This essay examines “The Argument from Design” by William Paley on the existence of God. This essay defends Paley’s argument that the universe was intricately designed against Hume’s dissimilarity and imperfection objections. David Hume wrote his objections several years before William Paley wrote his analogy.…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While closely analyzing this subject, he comes to the realization that it is faulty. Hume’s argument is strong because of the premises he creates to from his conclusion. The principle of induction being faulty is the case due to, attempting to prove its existence invalidates itself, inferences…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The first objection is that we have no information of earth’s creation. Hume states the fact that everything we claim to know have originated from previous experiences of similar objects being created. For instance, with a watch we know it has to be created by a watchmaker because we can witness it being made and compare it to other similar watches in their design. However, he argues that we have no experience of the earth's creation, or any other universe's creations to associate our own universe to, and will never so it would be invalid to assume that an intelligent designer has created our universe in the same way in which a watch…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The existence of God, a topic discussed in both William Rowe’s and Robin Collins’ papers, but for two very different reasons. The argument of good vs. evil and the existence of an omnipresent, benevolent being such as God is a topic that many find very difficult to find answers for, and will continue to plague mankind for the rest of our existence. After reading the published works of Mr. Collins and Mr. Rowe, one may find it easier to formulate their own opinion. In the publication by Mr. Collins, he addresses the topic of atheism and theism in respect to physics.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion” is a philosophical work written by David Hume. In this book, he proceeds to consult and provide arguments in favor of God’s existence. All of his arguments are supported with premises spoken through the philosophers in his book (this esay on Cleanthes’s argument). In his argument, Cleanthes clams that the universe is a complex machine which has a plethora of ‘natural’ machines. These machines, both human and natural, all have a mans of working towards a common end.…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One being that complex ideas can be broken down into simple ideas and followed back to their root impressions. The second addition to his principle is that without impressions there would be no ideas. In this essay, I will define the Copy Principle in detail and argue the problem that Hume’s principle produces is within the definition and criteria…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The discussion on whether the idea of God is innate has been held among many philosophers. There are two philosophers, Rene Descartes and John Locke, who both have come up detailed explanation and understanding of the idea of God. Descartes believes that the idea of God is innate and inborn with a human mind. Yet Locke argues that the idea of God is not innate. Two philosophers’ opinions reach a disagreement.…

    • 1691 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hume’s Argument for the Belief in Uniformity of Nature Hume begins section seven of An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding by expanding on his definitions he introduced in previous sections. In this section, on the idea of necessary connection,…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Does God Exist Essay

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the vast study of philosophy, a particular question has baffled even the most intelligent minds. This question is, “Does God exist?” Philosophers have considered the answer to this question for centuries, each coming up with their own argument and reasons behind their thinking. A platform of debate often used is Antony Flew’s parable of the two explorers, who find a garden so beautiful, that one of the explorers is positive that there must be a gardener tending to it, even if he can’t be detected in any way. The other explorer is not so easily convinced that a gardener exists at all.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “What is the self?” has been and argument that many philosophers have attempted to answer. For David Hume there was no true answer because for him the self simply does not exist. Hume took an unprecedented approach to the self, but he did not stop there. Hume, the historian, told the tale of how we arrive at the idea of the self with major implications of how we as beings function. David Hume was a philosopher concerned understanding humans and how we derive information and knowledge.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays