# Pythagoras & Protagoras Essay

905 Words May 9th, 2008 4 Pages
Thesis Statement
Protagoras denies a perfect form for all things, while Pythagoras clearly presents the better case with harmonia. Pythagoras, known as “the father of numbers” through his Pythagorean Theorem is regarded as the first to seek for the form of all things . From Protagoras’s perspective, named as one of the “Sophists” by Plato, there would probably be no exact form for anything. Without an understanding of a true source from which all form flows with, we eliminate all possibility of discovering the greater truth form carries with it. Pythagoras on the other hand deeply searches for a reason for the cosmos in every function of life, and that, carries a significant purpose for form. Mathematical formulas and
After all, the Greek word harmonia, does mean “fitting together” , because number does give purpose to proportion, and proportion does give purpose to harmony, thus giving a form for all things. On the contrary side Protagoras claimed that nothing was solely right or wrong, true or false and that through a man’s own authority, "man is the measure of all things” . Therefore everyone’s opinions differ from one another, which mean that what might seem true to one person might appear false to the other. This would leave us with no objective truth to cling to, no absolute form for anything. Protagoras developed this theory into what we call relativism . This supposition pretty much enables anyone no matter who you are or what you do to be correct in your own opinion about anything. This perspective is very broad in a sense where each and every person’s beliefs are inevitably and infallibly true, taken to a personal level by resulting as a truth for that person only. No one else would be able to fault or criticize that person for believing in a certain truth, because it’s only perceptible by that one individual only. A relativist would say that human beings don’t carry a certain type of DNA which identifies a perfect form for our body, because they don’t believe in one ultimate function for anything. Now, if relativists do believe all things are inevitably

## Related Documents

• ###### Essay Differences Between Thales And Anaximander And Anaximenes

theories to be too vague and essentially combined them. Anaximenes explained that air is what holds everything together and is spread throughout all objects. Pythagoras philosophical life began in 525 BCE. Pythagoras and the Pythagoreans based all of their philosophical findings on mathematics and believed that everything consisted of numbers. Pythagoras believed that mathematics was the ultimate way to purify the soul, he is the founder of the religion Dionysus. Pythagoreans developed the concept of form…

Words: 929 - Pages: 4
• ###### Philosophy Account of Man Essay

Heraclitus- “Man has fire stuff in him in the form of heat.” * Anaximander – “Man is a human being that has evolved from animals of another species which are lower than his.” * Pythagoras- “Man is a dipartite of body and soul .” That a soul is immortal, divine, and is subjected to metempsychosis. * Protagoras or the sophists- “ Man is the measure of all things, of all things, that they are, and of things that are not that they are not.” SOCRATIC PERIOD 1. Socrates- the acclaimed greatest…

Words: 913 - Pages: 4
• ###### Essay on Plato's Philosophical Influence

Platonic Academy, in Athens. At his school there was more attention given to literary form and less use of the method of illustration that depicted the Socratic manner of display. Among his some of his works the more genuine include, "Phaedrus", "Protagoras", "Phaedo", "The Republic", "Minos", and the "Ion" (Taylor 12). In his writings he uses dialogue with a technique that no one has used before. He was able to form the Socratic method of question and answer through it. Plato was devoted to writing…

Words: 690 - Pages: 3
• ###### Essay Religion And Its Effect On Society

constantly, and it’s impossible to know anything for sure (p.33). Parmenides believed in a single reality that is fixed and unchanging. He believed that knowledge is acquired only through rational thinking, because our senses are an illusion (p.33). Pythagoras was the first to use the phrase philosophy, and call himself a philosopher (p.34). He said that an explanation for all things in the world could be found using numbers and numerical relationships (p. 34). He believed in 2 worlds; physical and abstract…

Words: 766 - Pages: 4
• ###### The Parthenon Essay

look but showing a cherished event between the Gods and the Athenians. “… use of the human body as units of measure and the idealized human form to define perfect proportions, the Parthenon literally embodies the words of the Greek Philosopher, Protagoras, who lived in Athens during the construction of the Parthenon: Man is the measure of all things” (Beckham). Moreover, all the Gods and Goddesses in the Parthenon are sculpted in human form. Humans are mortal beings with vulnerabilities such as…

Words: 1416 - Pages: 6
• ###### Essay The Great Philosophers From Greece

period. He was taught the doctrines of Cratylus, Pythagoras, and also Parmenides. These doctrines are where he gained his foundation and his study of metaphysics and epistemology. Socrates is known to be Plato 's biggest motivator and role model. Socrates execution is what officially made up his mind on dedicating his life to philosophy. (www.biography.com) In the first period of Plato 's writings and traveling, he wrote The Apology of Socrates, Protagoras, Euthyphro, and also Hippias Major and Minor…

Words: 1320 - Pages: 6
• ###### The Ethical Values of the Music Art of the Ancient Greeks: A Semiotic Essay

numbers (1, 2, 3, 4; whose sum is 10, symbol of universal life, of the macrocosm)¡Xthe tetractys / ƒäƒÕƒäƒâƒÑƒÛƒÙƒÆ ¡Xa unique miraculous universal power, Pythagora made up the scale that bears his name, in which the melody is generated only by the rolling of these numbers, the relations expressed by them being absolute and perfect consonances. Pythagora¡¦s name is also related to the famous "music of spheres" that will accompany the movement of the eight celestial spheres and there are his disciples who…

Words: 2787 - Pages: 12
• ###### History Essay

Rational/ Humanistic perspective * Focused on humans (perspective, condition) * Created some of the greatest monuments in Greek culture * Polis- expanded emphasis on freedom/dignity of individual * Pericles (495-429) * Protagoras said, “Man is the measure of all things.” * Limitations to Human Freedom * The gods limited the range of human activity * Interfered in human affairs * Fates * Certain events happen for a reason…

Words: 3987 - Pages: 16
• ###### English Essay

right' or ' straight angle(obtainable for example foldinga leaftwice,so thatthe two foldsforma cross) by was connected with the purelynumerical ratios3 : 4 : 5, or 5 : 12 : 13 sidesof rectangular Thesetwo discoveries, appears, it (the triangles). led Pythagoras the somewhat to fantastic that generalisation all things was are, in essence,numbers,or ratiosof numbers or thatnumber ; the ratio(logos reason), rational the essenceof things,or theirreal = nature. Fantastic this ideawas, it provedin manyways…

Words: 13708 - Pages: 55