Peter K. B. St. Jean Theory Of Crime

Improved Essays
The book, Pockets of Crime Broken Windows, Collective Efficacy and the Criminal Point of View is a methodological approach to the study of urban crime. The author Peter K.B. St. Jean examines crime from an ecological perspective using a sociological framework. He focuses on the idea of neighborhood impact factors that lead to criminal behavior. He focuses on how certain urban areas are unevenly developed; which leads to how crime can occur more often in certain locations that offer specific criminals advantages. In my book report, I want to evaluate criminal behavior based on the context of St. Jean theory while also looking at how they relate to the context of my own theories. I will also identify the main points of theories and key findings …show more content…
Jean asks is "Why do crimes occur more frequently in certain neighborhood locations as opposed to others." The book talks about how limiting quantitative data was Instead of coming to his conclusion through limited quantitative data he instead focused on qualitative data. It was primarily through the information provided by community members or a community offender that St. Jean arrived at his conclusion. St. Jean’s research focuses on using extensive interviews with offenders and others to understand how to measure neighborhood disorder. He also looks to try an understand how collective efficacy influences certain individual's crime-related behavior. Essentially in his book St. Jean proposed that specific places within the urban environment provide high levels of criminal opportunity. His argument is that areas advantageous for criminals are an environmental disadvantage for a neighborhood. He found that the prevalence of drugs, robberies, and violent crime was dependent on the specific characteristics of favorable locations. The less guarded and protected parts of the neighborhood are the more advantages and control it gives to criminals. He talks about how drug dealers rely on the stability of three ecological advantages. Those being high demand, high supply, and high exchange opportunities. Essentially in his book St. Jean proposed that specific places within the urban environment provide high levels of criminal opportunity. Certain places …show more content…
The lifestyle theory is the idea that individuals have a high risk of becoming crime victims if their patterns of behavior expose them to victimization. I think, although this theory focuses more so on deviant behavior and weak social bonds it has merit within the context of St Jean Pockets of Crime. People are much more likely to commit criminal acts if the neighborhoods are run down and dangerous. Criminal behavior is much more likely if the places, people live in are in poor condition and community ties are weak. This then creates a potential cycle where individuals are more likely to hang out and spend time with people we these same ideals and in turn use illegal drugs, binge drink, and spend time in high crime areas often being armed and using

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    As social disorganization has been described as the disruption and breakdown of social structures, which then results in the loss of social control in certain areas of the community; the overall goal of the social disorganization theory is to link crime rates directly to neighborhoods ecological characteristics (Bond, 2015). As it had been established at the University of Chicago during the 1920s during a time of social unrest, it became well-established during this time and has remained a prominent fixture of criminology studies for more than 75 years (Siegel, p. 185). But while, each theory of criminology focuses on the different causes of criminality, I have found this theory to be most in line with my personal beliefs as I found that…

    • 1694 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    One will first analyze the primary crime prevention. The city of Walshville lacks social crime prevention strategies especially in zone 17. According to the report it was observed that more crimes were committed in DA 17. This can then explain how the lack of education can result in no employment, which can lead one to poverty. Bureau of Justice Assistance (1994) found that the lack of education an individual has can initiate human violence . Furthermore, there is also a lack of proper environmental design presented preferably in zone 7. It been reported that Bill Ave. consist of a lot of low rent apartment tower complexes as well as row town houses). McKay (2007) found that criminal activity is more likely to be committed in low rises as oppose to high rises as it is believed that it is must more difficult for someone to commit a crime such as B&E 's in these buildings. According to the selected crime indicator, there was about 139 break and enters equally divided between DA 15, 17,19 and 11. We will now look into the secondary prevention model. The Walshville report disclosed that disputes including domestic, family and neighborhoods are the leading cause of crime with 493 reports only in DA 17 for 2010. The reason why there may be an increase of such behavior is because of the lack of publically funded resources provided, this…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What this theory doesn’t take into consideration is the fact that a lot of people who commit petty crimes, such as theft, and who sell drugs to bring in income are doing so because they want to fit in with the people that they see as being “cool.” A lot of teenagers, and young adults, are in the process of forming their identity and while some are ok with having a personality that is opposite of what everyone else’s personality is, some want to fit in with the popular kids and this scenario plays out in urban communities over and over again. The kid in class who gets good grades is different from everyone else in that he wants to obtain the American Dream and is not interested in the activities that his peers participate in. He is ostracized because he is not his choosing a life of crime, however, the person who gets involved in criminal activities does so because, often, they see that everyone else is doing it, so they should to. In addition to that, a person may choose to get involved in theft and drug dealing because they come from a family of criminals. Many times, people come from families where they’re taught that making money through legitimate means is normal and that’s what they grow up…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Criminologists believe that social disorganization plays a major role in why crime is much higher in these communities. They feel that it is much harder to control crime in areas that have more people, delinquent peer groups, and minimal resources. Agnew (1999) explains that deprived communities tend to have less access to jobs that are stable and well paying (p. 131). This leads to a population that is more angry and frustrated. This increases the level of strain in the community and further enhances violence and crime. These depressed communities have developed a culture of their own. There are more heads of household that lack responsibility. The children in turn are released out in the community without supervision at a much younger age. The criminal activity among youth is much higher, and at a much younger age than more established communities. Over time, a large majority of this youth grows into adults and stays within the same community. The population of criminals in these divested areas has now doubled. This process has continued to repeat itself, making the concentration of criminals much greater than a similar populated, but distinguished community. History has shown us that these depressed communities send the most individuals to jail each year.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Examples are thefts of bicycles, motor vehicle parts and accessories, shoplifting, pocket-picking, or the stealing of any property or article that is not taken by force and violence or by fraud. Attempted larcenies are included. Embezzlement, confidence games, forgery, check fraud, etc., are excluded” (2014). While doing this research and analyzing the crimes, the first theory that can to my mind was the routine activist theory. Routine activities theory stresses that criminal behavior takes place with the three variables that reflect our everyday routines. In this theory, it states that there should be a motivated offender, a suitable target, and the absence of a guardian (Walsh 2015, p. 61). The reason why this theory came to mind was because we all know when our neighbors’ leave the house or when or what our neighbors’ brought. I have lived in both of the cities and in both of the cities there was always someone in the neighborhood whose house will be…

    • 1393 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Elijah Anderson’s “Code of the Streets”, there is a myriad of social institutions that can influence crime in neighborhoods. The “street code” is described to be that based on the amount of respect and power one earns by actions they take to gain a reputation or result in unfortunate predicaments. A social institution that can influence crime is family. If the family is exposed to the “street life”, the child will more than likely become part of it. Other institutions include peer pressure, a child’s or adolescent’s need to fit in and be accepted will more than likely increase their involvement in a crime and become influenced to do so. Lastly, exposure to prisons themselves influences crime. More often than not, families that are oriented…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first theory that will be used to understand the crime discrepancy between Crimeville and Peaceville is Social Disorganization Theory. This theory assumes that most people agree on basic norms and values (Exam 3, S 63). It also suggests that individuals would commit more crime if there were lower amounts of social control and if the individual was inadequately socialized (Exam 3, S 63). This theory continues by stating the locus of criminality deals with how well a neighborhood can come together to prevent crime (Exam 3, S 64). Per this theory, crime is a natural occurrence in the absence of neighborhood institutions and it is more prevalent as a group behavior (Exam 3, S 64). Adverse neighborhood conditions such as family disruption, rates…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first specific area the author addresses is the political one surrounding New York City in which certain police administrations during that time were claiming the reduction in crime was a direct result of new police strategy and policies. After examining tactics such as community policing, foot patrols and problem oriented policing Conklin asserts police tactics likely had very little, if anything, to do with crime reduction. Conklin does say it is more likely the number or offenders incarcerated during that time had more to do with the decline than policing techniques. The author points to the rapid expansion of incarceration as a direct link to the reduction in crime but also brings up the great cost to tax payers and the impact upon offenders lives and the lives of their families as an issue needing to be addressed. After examining the link between police involvement and reduction in crime Conklin than moves to examine societal factors that may explain the occurrence in question. Conklin examines the change drug use and the possible effects that may have played in the subject matter. Specifically, the shift seen during in drug of choice by consumers away from crack cocaine and toward marijuana. The author concludes that while drug patterns may explain a reduction in certain types of crime it cannot be connected to every category of crime in which the reduction is seen. Conklin discusses the change in use of crack cocaine as a possible factor for a decline in murder and robbery rates but not in burglary or motor vehicle theft. However, despite the possible correlation drug use in general stayed relatively stable during the 1990’s. Because of these factors no direct conclusions may be drawn from the usage of drugs use and crime rates. Next the viability in a change to the availability of firearms as a cause is examined. This area is…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Specifically, to the book “Code of the Street”, it is the examination of learning criminal engagement based on the interaction with the poor environment which shapes one’s actions. In other words, this particular theory approaches to answer the Who, What, When, Where, and Why questions in relation to crimes being committed because of a person's environment. Behaviorism plays the role of an environmental factor influencing behavior (McLeod, 2007). To explain, we all learn behaviors or bad habits from our surroundings such as, where we resin. As a result, we observe these behaviors whether they are good or bad and we as people acquire them through conditioning and based on what we have observed and learned we create a stimulus-response. For example, as demonstrated in my analysis I explain how Anderson made a connection between youths being influenced by “street culture” like drugs, violence, lack of education because of poor education systems, and poverty to likely be set up to fail and have the outcome of behavioral problems. To add, simply living in such an indigent environment places youth at risk of falling victim to aggressive behavior. For instance, the urban neighborhood I grew up in is a low and middle-class community with a majority of individuals who are under subsidized housing with more than two people living in a two bedroom apartment, unemployed or low wage jobs, and no education or highest level of education is a high school diploma. In addition, the community is filled with violence, drug and drug dealers, and people with self-destruction mindsets that are only focused on living in the moment and little concern for the future. The Behavioral…

    • 1348 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In reading 15, Physical Deterioration, Disorder, and Crime, O’Shea studies Wilson and Kelling’s the broken window theory of crime. The broken window theory states that social control and disorder can influence the people of a social disorganized neighborhood to not commit serious crimes. O’Shea raises an argument that the relationship between physical deterioration, disorder, and crime are not straightforward or additive. Rather physical deterioration interacts with social disorder to affect levels of crime. O’Shea states that crime and disorder are not randomly distributed but found in clusters. Sociologist found that crime and placement is related and that crime is found in certain geographic areas, and that the cause of crime is related to various social conditions such as single parent families, low education,…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shaw And Mckay Analysis

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Sampson and Groves brought the development what causes social disorganization with weak social ties giving rise to the Systemic Model crime (Sampson &Groves, 1989). Bellair built upon Sampson & Groves and Shaw &McKay’s findings with finding that interaction among neighbors should be frequent and infrequent to stabilize a “connected” social network and increases social control (Bellair, 1997). Bellair also mentions Social interaction among neighbors that occurs once a year or more is more common in relatively affluent and homogeneous communities, and it transmits moderate proportion of the effects of these variables on at least one of the crime rates…”(Bellair, 1997). A final development was made by Sampson et.al. which continued to build on social disorganization theory and creating something known as collective efficacy(Sampson et.al, 1997). All of these news developments for social disorganization theory continues to be supported or unsupported just like with all the other theories. Poverty and Collective efficacy crated by Sampson et. al. seem to be the focus of Shaw and McKay’s Social Disorganization theory today. To lower crimes rates those two things will have to be focused upon to bring…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They both unswervingly weigh the most significant influences that serve as causations for participation in illicit activities. The Social Disorganization Theory concludes that “crime is largely a product of unfavorable conditions in certain communities” (Gaines and Miller 43). This can be applied directly to criminal justice due to the realization that a large sector of criminals are not inherently bad people. Rather, they are morally equal to any individual, but were simply victims of their environment. If someone is constantly emerged in an atmosphere where horrendous activities are deemed acceptable or even admirable, they are significantly more likely to succumb to similar opportunities. The Strain Theory is similarly effective as it concludes that the yearning for monetary success is to blame as the most significant factor contributing to the commitment of crime. Money as the motive applies to the criminal justice system in many investigations where they are searching for a motive that may lead them to capturing a criminal. Wholly, both theories are tremendously useful in terms of understanding crime in regards to criminal…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The theory explains that criminal behavior is learned through interaction with those in the community. The theory further explains that learning of delinquent behavior occurs within familiar personal clusters. Criminal behavior is motivated by the definition of the favorability of legal codes. The more favorable the legal system definition is to a person the more likely they are to engage in crime. Differential association varies in duration, frequency, intensity, and priority, and the pace is reliant on the group. Therefore, the increase in juvenile delinquency and crime rate in Chicago and its environments are a result of the learning from close…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ecological Theory Of Crime

    • 1015 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In relation to ecological theories, social disorganization originated in the 1930s from members of the Chicago school who were studying urban crime and delinquency. The theorists behind this development were Clifford R. Shaw and Henry D. McKay, sociologist also affiliated to the Chicago school and to Institute of Research in Chicago (Shaw and McKay, 1942; 1969). Even though many criminal justice works attribute social disorganization to Shawn & McKay, the backgrounds of this theory are said to be the works of the professors Park and Burgess. In other words, the studies done by Park and Burgess, such as their urban ecology theory and its findings, directed Shawn and McKay’s research of juvenile delinquency. Their interest on previous studies, ecological theories, lead to the formation of the social disorganization theory.…

    • 1015 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crime Pattern Theory (Brantingham and Brantingham 2008) examines people’s activity patterns, especially when traveling to, or gathering at particular places, in terms of ‘paths, nodes and edges’; and whether places are ‘crime generators’ (many crimes happen there simply because lots of people are passing through, some of whom happen to be opportunistic criminals) or ‘crime attractors’ (criminals are specifically attracted there because of features that make crime less risky, less effort or more rewarding).…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays