Paul Frymer's Inequality Beyond Class And Race

Superior Essays
Inequality beyond Class and Race
According to Merriam-Webster, inequality is defined as an unfair situation in which some people have more rights or better opportunities than other people. In Paul Frymer book Uneasy Alliance, he shows inequality among race and parties is still seen in America democracy today. He demonstrates to his readers that not all groups are treated equally but more government officials are more responsive to white swing voters than any other voter. Frymer’s theory affirms this ideas that in American politics, African American are captured minority. For Frymer’s a captured minority is when both political parties attempt to allure more white swing votes by absenting themselves for black voters leaving black with no other
…show more content…
The two party system is very generalizable in the case of inequality when it comes to Frymer’s theory and Bartel’s findings. The idea behind the two party systems was to create a competition that would provide representation for a variety of groups, no matter their advantages or disadvantages in politics. Recently, the two party systems have shown to exclude some groups and treat them as invisible. These two party system tries to capture certain groups. The author Paul Frymer establishes African Americans as the captured group, while for Larry Bartels the captured group would be the poor; therefore the authors expressed some major concerns for both groups. First, captured groups often find their political interested neglected by their own party leaders because limited political choices. This two party system provides struggle for change, takes out the diversity of ideologies and limits ideology to two. Paul Frymer implies, “African Americans are need of policies and programs not easily provided by a government that favors an incrementalist approach to politics” (9). Bartels debates, that the political systems does not honor the public opinion or …show more content…
There are two empirical results that Bartels observes about the poor to support Frymer’s theory. The first piece of evidence to support this is campaign contribution. Bartel’s findings shed light on the fact that Senators are six times as likely to respond to the views of typically affluent constituents as well as middle constituents rather than have no contact in regard to the views of low income constituents (Bartels 280). These captured groups are at a huge disadvantage, according to Frymers, in getting social or economic issues passed because minorities ideologically hardly agree with white swing voters. These outcomes have a major consequence because the government is making it accessible to stop political action that might benefit captured groups rather than fulfilling these specific policies. One way this is done is by high income constituents using abundant amounts of contribution to override minorities. The second piece of evidence to support this claim is the responsiveness neither party’s gives to captured groups. Bartels argues “the preferences of people in the bottom third of the income distribution have no apparent impacts on the behavior of their elected officials” (Bartels 285). Paul Frymer’s theory would agree to Bartels empirical results because captured

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Tell Me A Joke Analysis

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Conflict Theory deals with seeing one group as being mistreated unfairly. It can be defined as proposing that each individual or group struggles to attain the maximum benefit, (Tischler, 2014). I chose this theory because I feel like it relates well to the joke. African Americans are not treated fairly in our society. Even after we had the first African American president, there was still hatred among this minority group.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Appeals to black voters will decrease parties total vote while poor does not. Due to the electoral college institution, the political party who win the more votes will take all in the state. That means party leaders only need half votes to win all the states vote. From Framers p48, White swing voters are critical to a winning strategy and these voters are believed to be hostile to black interests. Appeals to black voters will undermine both their own preexisting coalition and their appeals to white swing voter.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the times of the Civil Rights Era, activist of that time fought hard to gain the rights such as voting. Stipulations of that time for blacks trying to participate would be them having to take voters test or even pay good amounts of money to register. Today the little voice that blacks have is being threatened by voter ID policies. As commented on by John McWhorter “Yet the distinction here is fine, and few black people or other Democrats will be inclined to acknowledge it in a culture that fetishizes the exposure and denunciation of racism. Voter-ID laws are resolutely interpreted as “racist,” and they have set the relationship between black voters and the Republican party back for at least a generation”(1).…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One factor is that this society is based on racialization and has been set up to further Whites and hinder those of color for example tax benefits (Karenga, 2010). Another factor was economic detour which is policies that prevent Blacks from having personal belongings such as being a free agent (Karenga, 2010). Lastly it is noted that Black are comfortable with the inequality within this society (Karenga, 2010). A pressing point to make is that wealth and political empowerment go hand in hand. Dr. Karenga notes that you cannot have one without the other which means due to the lack of wealth, Blacks have no political power and due to no political power, Blacks have no wealth (2010).…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, being the first black president of the United States. The writers believe it distorts the truth that America is a now a “post racial era”. Darity and Hamilton say those who claim America as a post racial era state reason why racial disparity exist. One of which is: “Blacks are less frugal when it comes to savings”. Darity and Hamilton uses the economists as reference and argues blacks would save a lot more than whites.…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rising Inequality Essay

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Extreme inequality creates a voter paradox in which people are only willing to vote if they feel that the political process is working in their favor. Polls show that there are “large discrepancies between what most voters want and what the political system delivers” (148), and this reduces motivation to vote. In Stiglitz book we also learn about how the wealthy “who wish to preserve societies’ inequalities” use their control of the media to shape perceptions and convince Americans to support policies against their…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Though this can be the result of the “American Dream”, it is important to establish that drastic economical inequality will directly conflict with political equality. Economic inequality is beneficial to the extent at which people strive to achieve goals. However, when greedy business executives abuse their power and wealth, politics tend to be swayed with fiscal renumeration. People who live paycheck-to-paycheck and have a routinized labored job typically have low political influence because of time. They do not have high political efficacy because they believe they are not worthy to influence politics due to their lack of education and wealth.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ultimately, through this election the world learned of the divisive issues that plague the United States are greater than first perceived. Although, to say that whites are the sole factor of Trumps victory is incoherent with the facts. Whites voted against trump and should be known to have done so, just as minority camps should realize that members of their communities tipped the scale and voted for Trump—or did so by not voting, like the hypocrite Colin Kaepernick. Why is it that we don’t group these voters as members of the…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As a result of this, the lower class citizens are not being taken into consideration when it comes to equal opportunity in America. If the people in this country will not even admit that there is a problem, then how can the people even begin to fix the discrepancies within the social class system. In spite of the fact that Americans do not wish to talk about social status, there is a monumental contrast between the rich and the poor. There are definite class structures within the United…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Wealth Gap Essay

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For example, class is seen as objective (things that can be counted) and status is seen as subjective (opinion of individuals) (Gilbert, 2015). Weber also pointed out the importance of power and how it was administrated (Gilbert, 2015). The reason that these facts are relevant to the racial wage gap is because many African Americans and Latinos have had both their class and status stripped away from them because of their lack of resources, and they may feel powerless against the policies and injustice that are holding them back from achieving the same goals as White…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics