Analysis Of Brian K. Obach's Organic Struggle

Improved Essays
Organic Struggle, written by Brian K. Obach provides an in-depth overview of the organic movement in the United States. The author covers the history of the movement, the people involved, as well as the policies governing organic production. Obach also covers social justice and the future of the organic movement. Throughout the text the author ties together the political, social, and economic conditions of the movement. Obach details various schools of thoughts and major role players in the organic movement in the introduction. The author explains how some seek to defend the integrity of the NOP and federal regulation while others desire third party or private organic certification programs. Obach then goes on to explain how some within the …show more content…
At this period in the organic movement when the OFPA passed, former grassroots organizers now had to deal with politicians and lobbyists, which caused frustration. Additionally, activists began to fear large-scale organic players were abusing the rules of the NOP while others continued to support the system for the growth it created. In chapter six Obach talks about social justice, which he describes as the main reason for discontent within the movement. The chapter mainly discusses social justice in relation to workers, consumers, and local farmers. The author summarizes that changing American values is and will continue to be a challenge for organic …show more content…
The local food movement is the least organized of the three but its followers simply support the idea of consumers buying local food and knowing their farmer. Another school of thought embraces the NOP and desires to continue fighting for policy reform at the federal level. The final ideology does not support the current state of the federal system and seeks third party certifications for farmers. While all have similar goals and values, the methods they employ all vary. Obach concludes by questioning whether or not the organic movement and federal system in place works and if it will work in the future. The author explains that there has been much progress made in advancing the movement, creating better food, ecological, and social conditions. However Obach also points out current issues like big-organic and conveys the idea there is more progress to be made. In order for organic to displace conventional systems, activists will need to continue their battle at all levels, from educating consumers, to making policy

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    will produce their organic frozen vegetable line when they employ experts to help train local farmers to implement organic farming methods and grow organic produce. In this case, the research will provide the answer to whether the hypothesis is proven or disproven. The statistical data shows that the need and want for organic produce far outweighs the supply. Research shows that non-organic farms outnumber organic farms by almost ten times within a state. Research shows that there are ways to implement organic farming methods without increasing the cost of production.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book “Harvest for Hope”, written by Jane Goodall, outlines and inspires the audience to eat mindfully and healthily. The author explains how a great portion of our nutrient intake is unknowingly mixed with toxins, and made in miserable conditions. Dr. Goodall explains this successfully by analyzing the typical practices of industrial agriculture, which then leads her on to examine the repercussions of these techniques, pressing the point that we are fatally detached from nature and it’s ethics. This novel informs the public not only how to leave a small environmental footprint, but also how one can do so positively. Jane Goodall associates many of humanity’s problems to the way the nutrition is composed.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A red barn, with green pastures and cows roaming around happily; this is what enters most our minds when we think of farms, which is naïve. The truth is 90% of our food is industrially grown, where we feed cows through plastic tubes and give them antibiotics by the pint and corn is doused with chemicals. Michael Pollan, through “The Omnivore’s Dilemma,” tries to open the eyes of the American people to understand this and to question what we are eating. Similarly, artist Nathan Meltz and the Reuters article “Monsanto replacing GMO canola seed in Canada” work to answer this all-important question by further analyzing our food production. Together, these various sources let the readers comprehend conventional agriculture through multiple lenses…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This essay will open people's eyes and make them see why the industrial organic food chain is the best food chain to feed all of america and how important it is to eat organic. The name of this book is called “The Omnivore's Dilemma” and it is by Michael Polland and this book makes the reader really think about what have we really been eating and where does our food come from and the reality of the whole food organization but out of all the food chains the best one to feed our nation is the industrial organic food chain, the reasons why this is, is because it gets away from all of the corn that is basically in all of our foods and also to get away from all the processed foods and fast foods and in this food chain they don't put the bad products…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michael Pollan's piece “Big Food Strikes Back” in October 9, 2016 The New York Times Magazine begins with critique of a lack of the discussion about food system during 2008 U.S. presidential campaigns. Nevertheless, the food topic—being multi-dimensional—is inevitably a part of a larger, and more discussed, themes such as public health, climate change, and nation's' energy requirements, to name a few. Furthermore, the author in this article pinpoints the U.S. food systems' problems. The production of monocrops, which are subsidized by the government, result in high emissivity of the greenhouse gasses and have shown a negative impact on public health and ecology.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first section focuses largely on the toll that the current reliance on industrial agriculture has on the American environment, specifically the mass amount of fossil fuel going into it. In the second section he examines the problems with large-scale production of organic goods and goes on to demonstrate how small-scale local organic production lacks those same problems. Finally, in the last section he describes his own experiences hunting and gathering, but admits is not a practical solution. The book overall recognizes the negligence and ignorance that Americans have when it comes to their everyday food choices. It also presents potential solutions to changing this, however recognizes that there is not simply one…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michael Pollan explained the dilemma in his book explicitly. Michael Pollan gave a variety of examples, pictures, and reasons for us to understand the problem. He went through the whole organic process, including animal treatment, supermarkets, and the money problems. The good amount of strong points he put in each paragraph helps you understand the details better. The whole set up of the book is great for students you can easily find the dilemma.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    (Lappe). Lappe’s overall message is that turning to organic solutions for how our food is produced could greatly reduce each person’s…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Pollan depicts corn’s abundance as an “80 million-acre field of corn ... across the countryside like a second great lawn”. Pollan’s strong imagery emphasizes to the American public that they need to become more aware of the impact today’s corn demand has taken on our landscape. Americans need to realize that to fulfill their demand, corn requires expansive fields that will eventually dominate America’s landscape. Pollan continues his strong illustrations by reasoning that in order for corn to gain land it forces the “clearing of land [and] plowing of grounds”. This addition forces the audience to…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Stain of Sustainability Sustainability is discussed in “Attention Whole Food Shoppers” by Robert Paarlberg and “Sustainability by Christian R Weisser. Christian R Weisser speaks more about the idea of what sustainability is and how is important for society to be aware of it. Robert Paarlberg explains in his article the way the Earth is more and less sustainable because of everyone 's actions around the world. Both articles touch on the ideas that there are people out there helping change Earth for the better, and want to make earth sustainable for the future. The authors both explain how there are also harmful situations happening that hardly balance out the help from others trying to make a difference.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Locavore Synthesis Essay

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Locavore movements have become the new craze of the past decade. Consequently, locavores have helped improve the environment within communities and the economy of the small farm industry, but the nutritional value hasn’t improved like people want it to. Becoming a part of the locavore movement can help the environment tremendously in many different ways. “Eating local is better for air quality and pollution…”(Source A) Travel time is cut which is less pollution from the trucks that transport the goods. The travel time usually outweighs the purpose of buying organic foods since the air is not benefitting from it.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In chapter 5 of Organic Struggle, Obach examines the development of credibility for the organic movement and the ways in which it has spread into the mainstream of American life. Obach’s analysis gives credit for the of the growth of the organic movement to multiple forces which pushed it forward. In examining two different philosophies about the movement and what it should stand for, the tillers versus the spreaders, he examines different values which the movement is trying to achieve. Overall, Obach argues that the movement was spread significantly by resource mobilization, especially in how it pertains to resources for research and investment into getting the public to accept organic food.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He asserts “the fact that better food — measured by taste or nutritional quality (which often correspond) — costs more, because it has been grown or raised less intensively and with more care. ”(Pollan 23). According to The Rationalization and Persistence of Organic Food beliefs in the Face of Contrary Evidence by Olson, Erik L, the authors disprove Pollan’s claim through a content analysis of 710 reader responses for a Stanford study, which objective was to examine the ‘pro-organic’ and ‘organic-skeptic’ reader comments and determine the personal impact of organic food consumption, as well as the environmental impact of organic food production. The exposure of a Stanford University meta-analysis, which concludes that organically produced foods do not offer any significant nutritional advantages, as opposed to, conventionally produced food completely refutes Pollen’s claim. The study proves that just because a food has the label “organic” on it does not mean it is significantly “healthier”.…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Food Inc Summary Essay

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Food Inc. reveals the truth about our food and how we must fight a corrupt system in order to get something as basic and clean, healthy, and honest food. It is unfortunate that animals, growers, and even buyers, must all suffer at the hands of these companies just so that they can fill their pockets. It will take a long time before there will be organic and humane food sold in our supermarkets, but if customers demand better quality, then they shall receive better…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction: Throughout this class, we have discussed the transition process from conventional farming systems to certified organic farming systems and its many benefits. We began by the organic certification process and all of the steps and requirements for becoming certified as an organic producer, we talked about some of the challenges that organic producers will encounter throughout the transition period as well as in their organic crops, the transition to organic livestock production and the many rules and regulations in place to ensure animal welfare as well and quality of product. This paper will discuss Mike’s experiences with the transition process at Bantry Bay Farm in Prince Edward Island and how his experiences relate to material…

    • 1091 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays