Natasha Rodriguez's Who Are You Calling Underprivileged?

Superior Essays
Underprivileged In Natasha Rodriguez’s essay, “Who Are You Calling Underprivileged?,” she argues that the word underprivileged shouldn’t be used based on someone’s ethnicity. The author then went on to explain that the definition of “underprivileged” didn’t fit who she is just because she’s of Latino/Hispanic background. Rodriguez also explained that researchers found that labeling these students as underprivileged can give them lower self-esteem, and that colleges should not automatically send out these brochures that are entitled, “Helping Underprivileged Students,” based on what ethnicity box they checked off during their application process. Instead, the author suggests that they use a different term other than underprivilege. In …show more content…
Just like the saying “don’t judge a book by its cover,” applies to this situation as well. Don’t automatically assume someone is underprivileged because of what they come from, maybe they need money, but that does not make them underprivileged.
The definition of underprivilege, according to Merriam-Webster.com, “deprived through social or economic condition of some of the fundamental rights of all members of a civilized society” (“underprivileged,” Merriam-Webster). Most kids who are called underprivilege don’t fit this definition. Students who go to college and are put under this category, are not being denied privileges of society because of their income. Rather, they are just in need of extra money to pay off for school, not saying they struggle in their own life financially. Secondly, labeling students underprivilege is wrong because it can cause problems in society. When we label individuals they most likely are brought up by assumptions. Typically, assumptions will eventually lead to being stereotypes, which will soon be put downs and turn in to bullying. Students will start to think that they are better than the students who are put under this category because of the definition of underprivilege, when these students just need help paying for
…show more content…
Just like Rodriguez stated in her article, it can cause people to have a lower self-esteem. (Rodriguez 207). When labeling individuals, a certain word that doesn’t fit who they are, it can have a long-term effect on their personality. Labeling can make people feel insecure in who they are by making them not want to apply to college, because of the brochures that get sent out to them. Labeling can also make them not want to associate with people who don’t have this label on, them because it can make them feel like an outcast.
It can also affect the way individuals feel in their life by making them lose motivation. They won’t be motivated to apply to colleges, go to college, or apply to any finance programs because they will have this label that they are underprivilege. Having to walk around with his label that they are considered underprivileged will make them lose all enthusiasm about accomplishments that they got for themselves. In Rodriguez’s article she states, “several colleges I was considering sent me material that made me feel worthless rather than excited about
Gouty

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Jobless Ghettos Analysis

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the United States, there is the belief that an individual, no matter who they are or where they come from, has the ability to succeed as long as they work hard for what they want to achieve. This belief is known as “The American Dream”. Despite “The American Dream” being a hegemonic belief, in reality it is not true. Within the United States there are systems that uphold inequality. These systems of inequality make it difficult for certain groups of people to achieve the so-called “American Dream” no matter their abilities. Race/ethnicity is a category of difference that greatly effects one’s position in society in the United States, especially for persons of color and even more specifically for people of Black or African American descent.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The children of the top one percent are very likely to stay in the top five percent because they are given the opportunity and told they are the best of the best. For example, when I was learning English I thought I was doing bad, but all my teachers told me how proud I should be because I was becoming bilingual. Their words made me believe in myself and actually became better at it. People would say that if the students dream of a better future they can achieve them by working. Yet studies have shown that a very low percent of the students that come from low income backgrounds are represented in higher education because they have many barriers to succeed. People would say that everyone can gain the same education if they have the desire to do so. Yet actual children from upper class backgrounds have more opportunities because parents provide them with tutors and spend more time in educational environments even before they started their institutional education.The income divide has received far less attention from policy makers and government officials than gaps in student accomplishment by race. (Glaber,…

    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When we are taken in by a label, we are taken in by opinions and others’ beliefs. Labels categorize, are designed to make you feel like an outsider, become verbal abuse, narrow our perception of someone. Using any word as a label blinds a person’s true identity. It covers the qualities a person may have. “To them, we looked like lowlifes, chinks, gangsters, and punks. In truth, we were two Filipino Americans headed toward Stanford and Berkeley, living in a town that swiftly disowned us with four reckless labels after raising us for ten years.”…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It makes them perceive the world in a different way, such as believing that they must wear suits to look acceptable to their peers. With that, comes the insecurities. The fear that maybe they weren’t talking or using the right words. It takes a lot of effort to put on a different mask and act like they are someone else. They will constantly stress over the different personalities of wanting to be true to who they are and acting as though they understand what feels like to live wealthy. Most students do it for upward mobility, but when they get hired into large law firms and are asked to help the less unfortunate, they feel uneasy about it. One male student said that the reason why he decided to stay away from law students who want to help the poor is because it reminded him of his own guilt. Higher stress levels were built from personal problems and resulted from the fear of academic insufficiency. When compared, about 62 percent of first-year working-class students felt deeply pressured to earn the best grades, while only 35 percent of upper-class students felt the same (Granfield). It comes from the notion that since the working-class students know that they do not have elite backgrounds, they must convert to being at top of their class to know that they are someone who is worth going to the prestigious law school. Granfield’s research states that stigma holds one back from being able to be a “complete citizen” because they cannot fully enjoy and participate in their social life. On the outside, these students may seem normal and look like a typical rich student, but it actually only adds on more psychological stress (Granfield). It’s one thing to hide about their background verbally, but it’s different when they must try to hide it outside of school. As in if a working-class student was with his or her parents had happened to come across an upper-class student at the grocery…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I can agree with that. However, I feel that we waste far too much time debating who is referred to as what by whom. Everyone is an individual, but in the grand scheme of society, not everyone is a special snowflake that always deserves their way. If we spend all of our time trying to find terms that make everyone happy and comfortable, then in the end what will we have achieved? What happens when the next person comes along and is uncomfortable or offended by the phrase “students in need”? Then the whole process starts again. Until that person is appeased. Then the next comes along who is offended by that term, and again, over and over. I spend a lot of time wanting to scream. While the author might be frustrated by the words society uses to label her, my frustrations are on society as a whole. It seems like everyone spends so much time tiptoeing around afraid to cause offense to anyone, that no real action takes place. Wouldn’t it be a better use of time to skip it? I feel that more people would be better served if all of the easily offended masses were just told to grow a thicker skin. Ignore the minor offenses and spend more time actually doing something. Perhaps funding the educations of more students? Or finding ways to better educate those who desperately want to go to school, or attend a better school, but don’t qualify for scholarships to prestigious private…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Our society runs rampant with all kinds of inequality. Racism, sexism, and xenophobia are just a few of the problems that plague our world. These problems all have the potential to hurt people socially and emotionally. However, there’s another type of inequality whose impacts go beyond social and emotional harms. Income inequality hurts people psychologically and economically, and its implications span a global scale. Andrew Carnegie writes in “The Gospel of Wealth,” “The problem of our age is the proper administration of wealth, that the ties of brotherhood may still bind together the rich and poor in harmonious relationship” (Carnegie). This problem hurts the whole world, but it tends to be more severe in third world countries. Income inequality…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Labeling is used as a way to categorize groups with some form of shared characteristics. Society labels and categories almost everything. The things they categorize can be labeled with certain things, certain characteristics, connotations, associations, stigmas, and stereotypes. Although labels can be used for easier references, they can become problematic. It's all about self-identity and the behavior of individual that may determine or influence the labels in which things or individuals are classified or categorized into. For example in today’s society if you're a muslim you're sometimes automatically associated as being part of ICES which is a terrorist group. In some of the english literature read today such as the play Romeo and Juliet,…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Simmons

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The article "The Danger of Telling Poor Kids that College Is the Key to Social Mobility" by Andrew Simmons brings up a great idea of what the teachers and counselors are telling the underprivileged students the wrong thing. As Simmons brings up students should not be told that college is the only way to reduce economic hardship and that’s the only point to try attend college. He expresses that students should see a college education as a stepping stone to a great career and be able to give back to the community or be able to create their own company. He also expresses that students are taught differently as those “from wealthier backgrounds to be innovators and creators while the poor kids who do very well in school are taught to be educated, capable employees.” I personally agree with the points Simmons brings up about how students should not be “taught to be educated, capable employees” but rather “to be innovators and creators.” After all, students should be treated all equally regardless of their economic background.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    While having a low socioeconomic status provides students with a lot of issues on its own, combining the disadvantage of poverty with being a minority can make success for these students even more difficult.…

    • 1706 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Taking the example of a low-income household, a child with minority characteristics may expose to segregation within the education system. As the first step of becoming a social being, learning is indispensable as school system defines how skilled and equipped you are for the society. For students with unfavorable racial, financial, and social backgrounds, certain school policies come across with injustice for having segregated education. From the essay “Race, Disability, and School-to-Prison Pipeline,” the author Hing argued that introducing specialized courses targeting minority is a sign of unfairness when the education system singles out students with “disabled” properties. By tagging others as “disabled,” the society takes the fact that powerful figures should take care of the powerless for granted. Here, helping these students becomes a justification to the unfair treatments enforced upon them, which diverges students with diverse backgrounds into different levels of social functioning. Those beings who have favored backgrounds with higher education soon enter their suitable social positions while the…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To better understand discrimination and everyday prejudice one must comprehend the importance of being privileged.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each person comes from a different background, whether it be into a wealthy family or impoverished one. However, the fairness in life is that every single person has opportunities throughout their journey, and it is up to them to grab ahold of them. Many people would believe that life has not been fair to them only because they have not succeeded, yet it is their fault for not making use of opportunities handed to them. As stated in Life’s not Fair - Deal With it! by Mike Myatt, “People have overcome...virtually every challenge known to man.” This clearly shows that achieving goals in life cannot be blamed on fairness or not, but rather on how one took advantage of the opportunities they found. On the other hand, some might argue that life's not fair because some people are given large amounts of money and assistance throughout their childhood, while others suffer to even find a meal. Nonetheless, fair is not everyone receiving equal treatment, but it is everyone getting similar opportunities to accomplish their goals. As a matter of fact, we do not have to decide what is fair, simply because life is already fair. It may be hard to see due to the difficulty we each face in our daily life. As Mike Myatt put it, “Flipping burgers is not beneath your dignity…[your grandparents] called it opportunity.” All in all, our experiences in life may not be fair, but our opportunities undoubtedly…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this memo I explain how privilege can cause large groups of people to receive unfair treatment due to their identity and background. It contains discussion how being part of a more privileged group in society gives me advantages while being part of a minority leaves people with significantly fewer resources.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why Are Labels Bad

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Once a person is labeled, it sticks with them their entire life. When I was in elementary I was known as one of the smart kids. Now I am one of the average kids in high school yet I am still considered one of the smart ones. I don't see this as a bad thing though considering some labels are not bad. I think a label sticks with a person for life because people will always remember the label you have been given, people may not be in your life during your time of change and will still consider you that label, and not all labels are bad and some people choose to keep those labels.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hey Haleigh, I really enjoyed reading your post. I agree with Karl Marx, that society is determined by economic organization, particularly the ownership of property. In today's society, people think power is everything. People with power, think they can get alway with anything. In my opinion, it should not matter if you are rich or poor, everyone should be treated equally. At the end of the day, everyone is the same from each other. I agree with the conflict theory, it is a constant struggle for people to be treated equally. I hope you continue to do well in this…

    • 101 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays