The Price Of Preference By Shelby Steele Analysis

Improved Essays
Affirmative Action: The Price of Preference In “The Price of Preference”, Shelby Steele takes a stance opposing affirmative action and focuses his discussion primarily on the effects that it has on African-Americans. Steele reasons that while affirmative action was created with good intentions, he argues that black people have more to lose from it than they gain. Steele believes that affirmative action strayed from its initial goal of anti-discrimination enforcement and instead escalated into a form of social engineering through preferential treatment. Essentially, the main issue presented by affirmative action is the manner in which it attempts to bypass the development of formerly oppressed groups to the stage where they are fully able to …show more content…
Under affirmative action, the characteristic that earns blacks preferential treatment is implied inferiority. In integrated situations, blacks may be seen as intellectually inept since those around them view them as beneficiaries of affirmative action rather than merit. Since the effect of preferential treatment is the lowering of normal standards to increase representation, Steele argues that it places self-doubt within the minds of blacks which undermines their academic performance. This self-doubt in turn places them in a mental state of perpetual inferiority, impeding their potential for success and creates another obstacle in the development of blacks. The second liability of affirmative action is how it prompts blacks to capitalize on their past victimization as a source of power and privilege. Since victimization justifies preference, Steele asserts that in order to fully reap the benefits of preferential treatment, an individual must become invested in this victimization to some extent. Thus, affirmative action tends to lead blacks to become invested in their own victimization which is, ironically, the very status they are trying to overcome. The third fault with affirmative action is the illusion of reparation that it creates for blacks, with it being legitimized as something ‘owed’ to blacks. However, this overlooks the fact that it is simply impossible to repay blacks for the historical suffering of race. Furthermore, Steele notes that nothing can fully mend the injustices that blacks have endured but it is possible for them to be corrupted by gestures of reparation such as affirmative

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In his essay, “The Case for Reparations,” Ta-Nehisi Coates confronts the permeation of racial discrimination throughout American history and examines its lasting legacy in modern times. Using primary accounts and historical examples, Coates traces the influence of racism from the foundation of American democracy, through the Civil War era, the inception of Jim Crow laws, the Great Migration, and continuing to modern times despite continued U.S. governmental efforts to create policy that promotes equality and eradicates racial discrimination. Coates emphasizes the discrimination, racism, and hatred African Americans have faced throughout the various periods in American history, eventually concluding that the social, economic, and political…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    NEA uses this material as evidence that all black and brown people are doomed to a lifestyle less successful than whites. On the other hand, WRJ members claim that black and brown people’s actions are due to the oppression that has been going on for several years. WRJ discusses white privilege and how that makes it easier on white people to succeed in their lives. WRJ’s thoughts…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In White Like Me, Tim Wise explains from a personal experience of the ways in which racial privilege shapes the lives of most African Americans and white American, openly racist or not. The book shows the broadness and deepness of the abnormality within institutions such as, education, employment, housing, healthcare, and criminal justice. By determining the importance of racial privilege and its cost, Wise provides an amazing that will inspire anyone in understanding the way that race shapes the experiences of people in the United…

    • 86 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Affirmative action is probably one of the most misunderstood employment practices that we have discussed so far in class. When I first heard of affirmative action, others described as something beneficial only to African Americans. It appeared to be a quota system where you had to hire a certain number of black people in order to keep the government off your back. Some made it sound like the every black person benefiting from affirmative action were unskilled and undeserving. The main purpose of affirmative action was to reverse the long term effects of past policies that may have had discriminatory effect on individuals now protected by employment law.…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Ferguson Fiasco

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Ferguson Fiasco Power and Race The Ferguson Fiasco is a study into the misuse of power and authority. Officer Darren Wilson confronted two young African Americans, Dorian Johnson and Michael Brown, who were walking in the middle of the street. The officer speaks through the window of his SUV ordering the two young men to move from the middle of the street to the sidewalk according to Dorian Johnson. The official testimony given by Dorian Johnson is Officer Wilson saying “get the F___ on the sidewalk.”…

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “In Living Color” by Jana King some views on racism create an inequality on society. Nowadays, people are still thinking that racism is over, I disagree with them, because when I came to New York and I went to school nobody wanted to talk to me just because I could not speak English well. I understood that racism is still used in a way we think it is not racism. Also, there are people who treat colored people as hyphenated because they do not are like them. However, to resolve these problems several institutions have created an affirmative action to help people who suffer from discrimination.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Affirmative action policies allow for equal opportunity and throughout history have helped end discrimination in the workforce as well as many different type of organizations. Minorities are given the opportunity to compete for job opportunities and admissions to educational institutions. However, not everyone agrees with these types of policies and believe that this is a form of “reverse discrimination” against white individuals (1). These individuals argue that minorities that include people of color and women are given preference and although the qualifications may be the same amongst all, the minorities will be granted the opportunity simply because of their skin color or gender. In “Affirmative Action and Fairness” Robert Fullinwider discusses how affirmative action is viewed differently…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pojman also understands that there can also be some negatives in affirmative action, such as the argument of merit. My stance on this argument is that I agree with Louis P. Pojman and disagree with Edwin C. Hettinger. In this paper, I will argue that affirmative action does have its advantages and disadvantages and that using it to restore past discrimination is a justifiable reason…

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jobless Ghettos Analysis

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The most prominent evidence that supports their findings of a racial hierarchy is that a “black applicant with no criminal background experiences job prospects similar to those of a white felon” (Ore 344). The discrimination that Blacks face in the job market is evidence that people have a lack of control over their own lives. Regardless of ability, there are generalizations made about people of African American descent as a whole and they do not get the luxury of being viewed as an individual. The job market in the United States is another social force that contributes to Blacks being low on the power…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within the United States’ culture, racist and sexist ideologies permeate the social structure and serve as norms to such an extreme degree that they become hegemonic and seen as common and natural. From corporate institutions, to religious institutions, to academic institutions, Black women have been slighted the opportunity to be seen as equals when it comes to their counterparts. The education of African American students and women alike have been influenced by a number of institutional and social reforms. The movement from legally denying African American students the opportunity to an education; to the separate but “equal” educational system; to the integration of the American schools; these remedies attempted to afford African Americans an education and fight the pattern of injustice and discrimination. Women and Blacks can theoretically…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Affirmative action or special race based treatment only furthers discriminatory mindsets in society. Affirmative action with motivations based in race can take the form of passing a student who does not understand the material or hiring a client because they are of a specific nationality even though they are not fit for the job. According to Walter E. Williams’ novel “Up from the Projects: An Autobiography,” many African Americans believe that progress in equality cannot be made until discrimination is eliminated, and view discrimination as the reason for their plight which creates a mental self improvement barrier and an attitude of complacency. Throughout the autobiography, Walter E. Williams expounds upon his views of discrimination and…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ralph Ellison, author of On Being the Target of Discrimination, did an excellent job describing the daily life of an African American child during the segregation era. This text has powerful lessons that he went through that shape the story into what it is today. On Being the Target of Discrimination is a narrative essay that relies on pathos to persuade its primary audience of white people in America how racism affects a kid’s childhood. The author had a very clear image of how he wanted to present the sole purpose of this text which was by presenting lessons the main character experienced. There are some things, particularly audience and word choice that overlap together in a way that make you think of the text in another dimension.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a well-known fact the African Americans tend to have higher levels of unemployment and lower levels of education than their white counterparts. The constant debate that whether or not that happened because of the structure of laws in the United States or because black people do not have a culture of working hard. In “Revisiting the Debate on Race and Culture”, William Darity Jr. talks about how different aspects of black identity play a role in the education and wealth of an individual. Chapter five of When Affirmative Action was white the author, Ira Katznelson , talks about a bill that contributed to the disparities between the earnings and the standards of living between white Americans and Black Americans. The chapter focused on the…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore, Ifemelu notices that it is often for African-Americans to get opportunities like jobs or casted roles in the media merely to fill a racial quota. Adichie displays here how white people earn their place in the world, while black people get jobs just because their…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Affirmative action policies places non-minorities at a disadvantage along with analysts believing that these rules impact the individuals they are attempting to help. Affirmative action was established to put an end towards discrimination. Shelby Steele, who is an English professor at San Jose State University, acknowledges instead of affirmative action to resolve the problem it intensifies the problem. In addition, someone who is a minority may never know whether their skin color, sex, or ethnic origin be a key factor on the person's employment or admission decision. In the article, Steele argues minorities should have more job training, better education, safer neighborhoods, along with increased financial assistance for college.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays