Morgan's Argument Analysis

Great Essays
In her article, Manitoba First Nations children's advocate fasting to raise awareness, retrieved from http://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/manitoba-first-nations-children-s-advocate-fasting-to-raise-awareness-1.2575655, Puxley (2015) sheds light on Manitoba’s “broken child-welfare system” as she interviews Cora Morgan, a First Nations children’s advocate. (para. 1). Morgan explains her plan to “go without food or water, along with five other women” for two days, in protest of the injustices associated with Child and Family Services. (Puxley, 2015, para. 1).
There are two key issues, which stand out while reading this article. The first issue is the considerable number of Aboriginal children living in out-of-home care in Manitoba (Puxley, 2015, para. 4). Morgan addresses the startling reality that
…show more content…
Singha, Ellenbogen & Trocmé (2013), make the structural connection to Residential Schools by explaining that “the overrepresentation of First Nations children in out of home care extends a long historical pattern of state-sponsored removal of First Nations children from their homes.” (p. 2080). The practice of forcibly removing “children…from their families and [placing] them in institutions” as seen in Residential Schools (Nagy & Sehdev, 2012, p. 67), is structurally the same approach seen as Puxley (2015) describes Lee-Anne Kent’s experience, having her children taken from her and placed in an off-reserve foster care program (para. 8- 10). In both cases, the child is physically taken from the home and placed with an unfamiliar family/institution. This method enforces the statement made by Cora Morgan in Puxley’s article. She claims that the government is primarily concerned with removing children from their families, instead of a focus to implement programs, which promote family unity (Puxley, 2015, para.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    One of the biggest flaws within this act is the care and treatment of our aboriginal citizens. As stated prior, Katelynn’s case was bumped from Children's Aid Society of Toronto to the Native Child and Family Services and then to Toronto District School Board, and back around like an endless circle (CBC News). The issue with all of this is while Katelynn was part Native, legal guardians were not, therefore Children’s Aid deemed this a case for the Native Child and Family Services, while they pushed it back to Children’s Aid, all the while the TDSB was sending information to these two groups, and neither of them were handling the case. While the Native Child and Family Services would have handled the case if Katelynn identified as an aboriginal child, or her mother did, neither of them did. My main critique of the Child and Family Services Act regarding the Native Child and Family Services portion would be the sheer length and vagueness.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This weeks reading, Walking This Path Together by Kundouqk and Qwel’shi’yah’maht, was very insightful to the Anti-Oppressive practises across Canada. I appreciated the in depth detail into indigenous studies, and could easily see the transition to all cultures. I was taken by the phrase, “best interest of the child”, as I have heard this phrase many times over my lifetime. (p. 40) The need to protect children has been thrust to the forefront of the country as if a necessity, but rarely is the child’s family or community been considered.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As previously mentioned, the Act sets up requirements for agencies to follow in regards to the placement of Indian children and gives tribes jurisdiction in custody hearings. The ICWA recognizes the unique political status of Indian tribes and the historically biased treatment of Indian children by both public and private welfare agencies (ICWA, 1978). However, while the ICWA standards were supposed to remediate this inequity Indian children are still removed and placed in homes outside of their culture more than any other race or ethnicity in the United States (Bussey, et a., 2013). This is in part due to the government failing to recognize the generation of parent-less boarding school survivors trying to raise children of their own while simultaneously having no cultural identity, coping skills or any idea of how to parent.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As indicated by pbs.org, before 1978, it is evaluated that in specific states, between 25 to 35% of Native American kids were taken from their homes, with 90% of these youngsters being set in white families. The procedure neglected to comprehend conventional Native American culture and kid raising practices. Authorities and social laborers from open and private offices guaranteed that the expulsion of Native American youngsters from their families was in the "best enthusiasm of the kid. " The underlying damage was that the Native American kids were in some cases taken through false means, and guardians were frequently deceived or surrendered their kids under pressure. A comparative pattern of fake and manufactured evacuation happened among Native youngsters in Canada and Aboriginal kids in Australia.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The recent emerge of child welfare agencies that are managed by Indigenous communities across provinces and territories are intended to reduce the overrepresentation of Indigenous children in care. However, social services and child welfare agencies have a difficult time serving Indigenous children and families with complex needs and this further complicates the intergenerational effects of past colonialism (Evans-Campbell, 2008). Thus, for this reason the social policy concern that will be discussed in this paper is how the CFCSA (1996) fails to provide adequate services to responding to the overrepresentation of Indigenous children in care in British Columbia. The word adequacy “refers to the quality and completeness of service according…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Misconception – Aboriginal children are involved in foster care at the same rate as non-indigenous children in Canada Findings- A 2015 report entitled Aboriginal Children in Care- Report to Canada’s Premiers, was developed by the Aboriginal Children in Care Working Group. The report presents a comprehensive analysis of the current state of the child welfare system in Canada and explains how systemic inequities in social determinants of health lead to the over-representation of Aboriginal children in Canada. Important findings contained in this report include the following: Aboriginal service Delivery Models vary between the provinces and territories. This creates a number of definitions of what the term “child maltreatment” means and while…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lifestyle between Canadians and Aboriginal Canadians are not completely the same. There are many differences from family all the way to entertainment. In the following paragraphs I will compare my life to an average aboriginal person’s life. One of the most important parts of life is family.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The New Life of Aboriginal Children Aboriginal children can not forget what happened in the past. In the 1870s, above 150 000 aboriginal children took from their parents to attend Canada’s Indian Residential Schools to learn them the culture of European and learn them reading, writing, and math (CBC News,2010, p.49). Unfortunately, aboriginal parents have not choice, even if they want to send their children to school or not (CBC News,2010, p.49). Because of Indian agents who make sure all children went to school (CBC News,2010, p.49). However, there are negative aspects of Canada’s Indian Residential Schools on aboriginal children, such as they beaten and physically abused if they speak their native language, do not pay attention, or…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Indian Residential Schools

    • 3011 Words
    • 13 Pages

    As a result, TRC Canada disregarded the continuing trauma that the residential school experience still has on individuals, families, and communities (Androff, 2012; Corntassel & Holder, 2008; Corntassel, Chaw-Win-Is, & T’Lakwadzi, 2009). Government-centered routes towards reconciliation made an effort to heal the harms produced by residential schools but did not help to reconcile and renew the Indian families and communities scattered and disrupted by the suffering garnered at these schools (Angel, 2012). This is a quantum failure in the eyes of these…

    • 3011 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Canada has not always been the prime example of a human rights haven. From roughly 1884 to as late as 1996, the Canadian government operated so called “Indian Residential Schools”. In all, 150,000 native Canadian children belonging to various tribes were forcibly removed from their homes and taken to various residential schools across Canada in a savage attempt to assimilate them into Canadian society. The planned agenda was to teach them values of the Christian faith, and teach them how to read and write English; however many children were subject to severe physical, psychological, and sexual abuse.2 Over 4,000 children died while attending the schools, and the vast majority of the survivors still suffer post traumatic stress disorder.…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One current issue impacting Aboriginal children in E.C. settings is that the families of Aboriginal children often feel disconnected with or excluded from the E.C service, as did the Indigenous Melbourne father of two young girls who eventually found their "safe place" at Bubup Wilam (as seen in the youtube video). And yet for Indigenous people family is central in their lives (Fleer, 2004). Fleer (p.59, 2004) writes, "the child is a composite of an extended family, community and set of cultural beliefs that do not always match those of the centre". The notion of the child being shaped by their family (amongst other important aspects of their culture) is a sociocultural one, and the importance of family is recognised in many E.C. centres,…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The children of white men had often been taken away from their Indigenous mothers after birth and given to a white family. As a specific policy by the authorities, Indigenous children had been removed from their homes since the Aboriginal Protection Board was set up in the 1880s. Indigenous children were taken away from their parents for many different reasons by the policy’s foundation was essentially a racist one. The white authorities believed that Indigenous parents were unable to look after their children properly and so they were removed.…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginal Children Essay

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Our Populations project on Aboriginal children in foster care in Alberta has been very eye-opening, I went into it not knowing much about the subject. Which developed into a very interesting topic. I am very glad I took the chance to search something I had no knowledge in, it made a great learning experience. Although there are many failures and negative things involving this aspect of the First Nations children, there is an also a good amount of strengths in this field. One of the biggest positive things about Aboriginal children in foster care is that when they are adopted they may not be in their culture, but they have an adoptive family who is obligated to uphold the child’s culture by letting them attend cultural events and even allowing…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Citizen Ethnicity

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Specifically speaking, Canada lacks access to housing for aboriginals and almost, 52.6 % aboriginals are forced/willingly live on reserves with unwelcoming factors such as, few social services, poor sanitation,poor water quality,infectious diseases,growing population and poverty. These individuals dreamt of going to school, having access to nearby…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Quandamooka Pros And Cons

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After so many years of oppression, racism and dispossession, it is understandable that Aboriginal families may feel a sense of apprehension or even a lack of trust when it comes to the cultural competence of their child’s early education provider. We as educators need to understand the difficulties faced by the aboriginal communities by getting to know the history of the area, take the time to research,, speak with the community, speak with families, and then discuss this with our peers and supervisors to come up with ways to include activities, events and experienced that include the aboriginal…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays