Tokenism In Education

Great Essays
Including Indigenous content in the subject of science can seem like a complicated task for teachers and there is sometimes the question of how to avoid tokenism in the teachings because as teachers we do not want to include Indigenous content in a way that is lacking in awareness of actual Indigenous knowledges in science. A good start to not making Indigenous knowledges not seem like tokenism when teaching it is to look at the two sciences and to not to treat them like they are binaries. (Metallic, pg.116) Looking at the sciences in binaries is not helpful to students or teachers because it causes students and teachers to feel that they have to choose between the sciences instead of embracing both. (pg.117) An approach to teaching science …show more content…
One way mentioned in this article is how Indigenous knowledge cannot not just simply be added to the curriculum because it could then become riskier to be a part of cultural appropriation. (pg. 46) A way to combat that potential problem and make the curriculum respectful towards Indigenous peoples is that “research in Indigenous domains needs to be compatible with the historical and contemporary experiences of Indigenous peoples, and their philosophies and cosmologies. (pg. 47) This is applied to Universities in Canada but can be looked at in terms of teaching in elementary schools as using or finding content that is falls into the same parameters that the University follows, which is that the content is actual Indigenous made and consulted content. This article talks about how in order to have both sciences existing in the classroom they need “to co-exist in science curriculum ontological pluralism must be embraced.” (pg. 49) What this means for teaching is that before we can fully include Indigenous knowledges into science, Western science dominance needs to be challenged and if this is not challenged it will be hard to recognize the “legitimacy of Indigenous knowledge systems.” (pg. 49). Another way found in this article to include Indigenous knowledges in a respectful way is to create “programs that are community driven with inclusive curriculum is an important step for negotiating a place in science education where Indigenous knowledge heritage is empowered and not further harmed.” (pg. 50). This is important because it is a step that allows Indigenous knowledges to be included in the science curriculum

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    For a school to be considered an academia it needs to have effective educators and diverse learning methods in order to accommodate the student’s needs. Students are unable to reach their full learning potential due to conformed school environment and their negative learning perspective. To reach their full potential student needs to have the right environment in order to cultivate the right mindset. Every individual has hidden potential and talent, but often times they are not given the chance to develop it. Gatto’s motivation for writing this piece is to advocate for a school reform because students are not given the opportunity to explore and enrich their potentials.…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Charles Taylor also writes about unifying Canada – not through the exploration of Canadian literature, like Atwood and Frye – by looking at the big picture things: individualism, reason/efficiency, and what he sees’ as the consequence as extreme individualism (Seminar Notes Nov. 12) in Reconciling the Solitudes and The Malaise of Modernity. Taylor is an interesting mix between someone who works in academic philosophy and in the political sphere. According to Taylor, Canada represents a united and distinct society whose identity is rooted in cultural difference. There becomes a question of individual identity versus national unity, which can be seen in opposition. The means to bridge this gap may be best made by these groups finding shared goals that unite Canada.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    72). Chen suggest that the participants should me more malleable in echoing their practices for educational reform. According to the author he cites that educational reform can encourage the participants in engaging students with problem solving activities, creative thinking and collaborative but a “culture emphasizing competition and a high-stakes assessment system can strongly discourage teachers from undertaking such innovative initiatives.” (Chen, 2008, p. 73). Contrariwise, the author addresses in the proposed study the importance of balance between teacher beliefs and technology integration. Chen (2008) denotes that the significance in addressing the measuring of teacher beliefs, acknowledges that “more studies should focus on how to develop methods or instruments that can help in the rigorous identification and evaluation of teacher beliefs”.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Humanities In STEM

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Students should be informed about the past so that they can understand why the world is the way it is today. Science and technology did not just come out of nowhere and students are already being educated on its origins. Including history in the curriculum gives a deeper insight on the history and the times of what that students are being taught to do were really needed. It will give a deeper understanding of what students are learning and why it is important. Being educated on the past also prevents people from repeating mistakes that were already…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Brough (2012) highlights the presence of NZ schooling National Standards having influence over the chosen structure of classroom delivery, noting that ‘teaching to the test’ becomes the priority. Beane’s (1995) ideas argue towards the insistence of changing these existing paradigms noting that CI is a fundamental shift away from organising the curriculum around subject-specific lines calling the separate subject approach ‘deadening’ to both students and teachers…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Attitude Of Confucius

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages

    However, it does not mean students should always compare their grades with one another. Good grades and smart title are not important. The significant thing is what students can learn from the school. It seems useless if students graduated from one of the top rank Universities in the world, but they cannot apply the knowledge that they learned in a real life situation. It will be better for students to fail in the exam and can learn from their mistakes, rather than get 4.0 GPA but they do not know what they are lacking.…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parents and teachers need to know that the standardized tests may help their students, but they will not help all the students. The teachers and parents need to see that these tests do not measure their knowledge of the information they are taught, but rather what they can remember later in life. Standardized testing prevents teachers from teaching the parents well-rounded students because the teachers teach the instructional program for the students to be ready for the tests. The teachers teach the students what is on the test, and in turn some of the students are suffering from it while others allow it for them to help further and better their education. Standardized testing is where all the students are to take a test that they are obligated…

    • 1662 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I think option number one is not an appropriate method because it deals with asking teachers that you respect to review your ideas. Just because you respect a person or colleague, it does not mean they are experts in evaluating a discipline system. All the options that I selected during the simulation were focused on helping students learn how to behave appropriately, providing opportunities for them to grow and succeed in the school environment. Some options provided were not appropriate. For instance, some options given were not effective methods such as writing the student’s name on a…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Educators were also hesitant to adapt to the online mode of delivery as they saw it as a threat to their academic freedom and struggled with training themselves to use technology as it drove them away from other demands such as advising, mentoring and researching (Bjarnason, 2003, pp.110-113). Based on the perspective of science and technology studies, online education has been described as being overly dependent on a simplistic understanding of the nature of technology. Hamilton and Friesen (2013) argue that online technology is limited to its arena of technical and scientific law, untarnished from the differences, interests and values that symbolizes the social world and is cast as being independent from its social…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In today’s society they are in an environment that is immensely different from the traditional Aboriginal tradition. Furthermore, this environment lacks reinforcement of the Aboriginal ways. This causes teachers to be straightforward in their teachings of the Aboriginal ways. According to Long and Dickason “disconnect between Aboriginal culture and formal education (is) an impediment to learning and development of positive identity”(41). Some ways Indigenous knowledge has incorporated into formal education is by inviting Elders into the classrooms.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays