Historians Ingrained Controversy In Research

Decent Essays
Historians are fixated with deriving meaning from various types of sources and is their most basic task. With what they find, they then derive wider arguments about why history happened and what it in turn means. By telling a story, historians derive meaning from the larger historical context. Actions, documents, and experiences, provide explanations, further understanding, and the ability to discover meaning and interpret it. Although all historians produce meaning from their work, it is controversial. Can we really determine the meaning behind someone else’s actions, experiences, or writings? The argument of whether or not historians are postulating or presenting hardened fact is an ingrained controversy within history. Differing conclusions

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    John Fea attempts to answer the question posed in the title of his book, “Why Study History?” He answers this question in eight chapters that talk about the different aspects of history. In chapter one, Fea talks about the role of historians as “revisionists.” Though history can be revealed through simple facts, it is meaningless without a story. Historians try to identify the story behind the facts by following the five C’s: change, context, causality, contingency, and complexity.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The Strange Death of Silas Deane” The object of historians is to tell the facts of the past without changing the details or changing the perspective of the past. Historians serves as couriers between the old times and the modern times. The transition between the past and to the present can create a misconception of what really happened. For example, the death of Silas Deane.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    146). How the world works has no value without relating it back to the people within it (Dilthey, pg. 146). Thus, it makes sense that what humans give value to and express as rules for the will within society is rediscovered and given meaning when looking at world history (Dilthey, pg. 146). The findings we express as a discovery of history are nothing but reflections of our own thoughts and consciousness’s (Dilthey, pg. 146).…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rashomon Effect Analysis

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Writing Response Hayden White’s most cogent assertion relates to his claim that all written descriptions of events or narratives employ figurative language constructed in a prose form. He creates this theory to suggest that the written form of the novelist or the poet is shared with that of the historian. In the retelling of history the historian must make sense of writing which has been designed with its own designated beginning, middle, and end and is enforced with a political point of view or author agenda, a process similar to what a novelist or poet might do. White emphasizes on this theory in the following quote, “Of course, it is a fiction of the historian that the various states of affairs which he constitutes as the beginning,…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Or, is history an open wound? Is it the wax and wane of domination and cruelty throughout time? Kincaid strongly suggests that only those who desire an objective standard to name things are those who wish to control those very things. History, it seems, rests in an open wound. Through the use of such a loose and personal rhetorical style and through the use of differing perspectives of the truth, Kincaid implies that anything that we choose to stamp with an immovable name is ultimately us naming the nature of…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The slave system in Guinea was not permanent. It would not reflect the slave sytem that later develops. In Guinea men and women in debt or had a criminal record would become slaves. And those from wars were also chained. For these reasons, the slavery in Guinea would not “mirror” the sytem in the European colonies.…

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carr Vs Elton Analysis

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The debate between E.H. Carr and G.R. Elton signifies the conflict between the “Old School” of historical studies and the Revisionist model. Carr proposes that there exists within historical studies the need for interpretation, and that there is no such thing as a universalized “truth” or “fact”. This is evocative of the Postmodernist phenomenon to critique and rethink approaches to history, which I will discuss later in this paper. Elton, on the other hand, emphasizes the universal “truth” within historical studies. He insists that there is no such thing as “subjectivity”, and all facts within historical sources are indeed just that – facts.…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    History Adrift History, according to Edward Said, is an being that “leaves its traces on all of us whether or not we recognize them”. Said’s suggestion within this statement is that we all, whether voluntarily or involuntarily, become historical subjects and are intertwined through the relationship of past and present moments. Examples of the unknown traces of existence that history can leave be behind are found in modern academia, art, and many other areas of life. However, due to various accounts of “cultural amnesia”, the historical contexts that underlie in our modern world are easily overlooked. Moreover, it should be noted that the events that occur in history are entirely singular, yet the effects of their occurrence do not fade away.…

    • 1604 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In fact, while making a reputation about someone, we must be objective by not engaging our feelings and opinions and act like detectives, examining people’s motivations and assumptions while describing others, we must not judge anyone; therefore, we should also suspect our own motives. That is how historian must work to avoid being judgmental and subjective,…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    William Stubbs had transformed the study of history to a continuous and research driven university discipline. It is important to note that the study of history was not created by Stubbs as it was present for centuries. However through Stubbs’s work the subject of history began to have an impact for academic studies and future historians. The legacy of Stubbs can be seen through the introduction of the Constitution History of England. Stubbs’s articulates a warning to his audience before reading the history of the Constitution of England as it lists what history was and what it is now to become.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead, Becker argues that historical facts can only exist in the minds of individuals—individuals who are subject to bias and deficiencies in memory, which then carry on in what they believe to be reality. Although these critiques are vital to keep in mind when researching history, Becker’s overly cynical point of view brings up issues of its own. He does touch on some of the positive sides to his case, particularly the mention of historiography and the insinuation of freedom to interpretation. Nonetheless, Becker chooses to forgo additional analyses of these subjects, and, as both he and Howard Zinn stated, there is no value in not properly acknowledging facts essential to a bigger whole, whether it is through omitting them or “[burying] them in a mass of other information.”…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the course of the existence of mankind, events concerning many individuals have been able to drastically alter time. The causations of crises, whether they were accidents or fate, shape history—the study of past events— and many groups of diverse individuals from all around the world. While others argue against the importance of history, and the necessity to study it, others boldly defend the significance of analyzing the past. Countless historians, such as the five authors of the following sources, endlessly enforce their own diverse range of opinions, while including other aspects that contribute to their arguments. However, there is no doubt that history serves as a key role in keeping records of ancient events, learning lessons…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shared Knowledge

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages

    However, potential bias may exist when studying only certain types of textbooks or artifacts from only certain regions that causes the ‘factual’ shared knowledge to shape personal knowledge. For example, during 1941-42 the Ensatzgruppen, the German killing units in charge of massacres, kept records of the number of Jews that were shot on the Eastern Front and buried in large pits (Rhodes 215). Without the detailed records, knowers in present time might never…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When we study history we accept the main ideas and theories of historians if they are supported by evidence. A trustworthy historian should be objective in order to provide a picture of a certain event authentically. For example several historians claim that the reasons why America bombed Japan in the Second World War was that the American government wanted to end the war as soon as possible. However they also question if the bombing was necessary. In this case to a certain extent it is necessary to accept, because we do not evidence to disprove it.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    History is the past analyzed and recorded, it is not everything that ever happened or everything that historians have already written about. While the existence of subjectivity in history is not often questioned many philosophers have rejected the possibility of objective historical knowledge. This essay seeks to explain the ways in which history consists of both elements of objectivity and subjectivity. Objectivity refer to the lack of bias.…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays