Dichotomy Between Convergence And Diververgence

Improved Essays
In the modern management system, it is very difficult to make strong dichotomy between convergence and divergence. The best HRM practice will certainly universalize in the days to come. But the perspective of HRM in a particular culture may not suit in another culture. Similarly it defers from company to company because all companies do not have same motto and they are not operated in the same context (Pudelko and Harzing, 2007). Furthermore Hofstede’s country comparison portrays the cultural difference through power distance and individualism that has direct effect in the perspective of HRM. According to the diagram [Appendix 1] Germany has the lowest power distance, Japan has the highest power distance and USA lies in the middle position among these three countries. Hence, USA has highest position in individualism, Japan has lowest, and Germany lies the middle position while comparing these three countries. Definitely power …show more content…
They are normative, regulative and culture cognitive. Normative pillar believes that a MNC is operated based on the culture of a country where the organization is first established. Regulative pillar believes that globalization forces to adopt the management principles practiced in other countries and supports for divergence. The third pillar is cultural cognitive which is based on the principle that for the smooth operation of company, both convergence and divergence competencies are needed which is crossvergence (Paik et al, 2011).
The globalization trend has created a debate between convergence and divergence competencies. The managerial practices are not only affected by the principles of management but also affected by various disciplines of social science. Political, economic, cultural and occupational status are the major factors to determine either convergence or divergence competency will based suit for MNCs (Quintanilla and Ferner,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Such issues are specific imperative for MNCs that work in these nations. It can be contended that the social and institutional environment turns out to be significantly more critical for HRM exchange to host nations that…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Jaguar Land Rover Essay

    • 3307 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Task 1: Evaluate the approach taken by the selected organization in managing its employees. Identify the HRM function in the organization and how they relate to contemporary perspective of HRM Introduction Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) is the UK’s largest automotive manufacturing business, built around two iconic British car brands: Land Rover, the world’s leading manufacturer of premium all-wheel drive vehicles and Jaguar, one of the world’s premier luxury sports saloon and sports car marques. Under the ownership of Tata Motors Limited, Jaguar Land Rover is transforming its business to realize the full potential of its brands and deliver profitable results. (Jaguar Land Rover About us, n.d.) Human Resource Management Human resource management is a modern approach…

    • 3307 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The work place HRM polices and business cultures can be dramatically different from business to business and different people have different views on them and how they incorporate them into their working lives. Activity 2.3 shown how businesses HRM polices and culture can mix well or clash badly as such Pauls Bourne shows how that if people of a work place buy into the ‘norm’ this can sometimes override what the HRM polices state resulting in problems. However that HRM polices should be a state of first call when people need to be reminded what is truly expected of them in the place of…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Global Human Resources specialist is vital to the success of a global organization. In this paper Snell & Bohlander will demonstrate the core competencies in economic, political-legal and cultural factors in many different parts of the world, the core impact of globalization in HR practices and local adaptation. Globalization gives the employees’ rights and privacy they can expect in the workplace. Snell & Bohlander (2013) the internet and social media are also having an impact, because social media has become the new way to find employees and check them out to see if they are acceptable candidates (p.12). A growing number of organizations are allocating HR representatives to their core business teams to make sure they are educated on core business issues.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My suggestion is for us to examine the HR practices of U.S multinationals in Denmark. According to Ferner (1997), there appears to be limited amount of research discussing the systematic differences in which a particular MNC of a given nationality (e.g., United States) manages its human resources. However, there are some generalizations made from these body of research. For example, one such generalization is that there are some human resource management/industrial relations issues that tend to exhibit more local isomorphism (i.e., resemble the practices of host environment) such as wage determination, training, number of hours to work, among others.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the MA.IB program is a truly international master’s program we did a lot of intercultural activities, especially in form of teamwork, presentations and discussions. Hence, I would like to focus on cross-cultural management as the main topic of my reflection paper. First of all, I am going to introduce briefly the Hofstede model and the Globe study. Another important theory, which is connected to cross-cultural management is emotional intelligence, which became popular with Daniel Goleman.…

    • 1393 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Done By – Irtifa Tazkia Islam 25. Reality of Strategic HRM in Bangladesh Figure: The Reality of Garments Industries’ Workers in Bangladesh Source : http://daniellesabai1.wordpress.com/ Although in principle SHRM is the best way to go, however the reality in the RMG sector of Bangladesh is quite different and bitter. The Reality of the HRM condition of The Garments Industry is tabulated below: 1) Child labor: still a realism Garments industry employs child workers by ten percent of employee respondents in the clothing commerce.…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hrm Goals For Starbucks

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages

    HRM goals regarding expansion into a foreign company must be the result of linking measured results from important data collected about expanding internationally to the strategies of the company in there setting up of the company. In this case study the goals that Starbucks has to being a profitable company in a new country must be met with plans that HRM planners have designed based on known factors gathered from data available about the location and desirability of such a firm in its new local. The textbook for the course described the task of the HRM team as a team that is driven in its practice by the research that has been done on it (Bernardin & Russell, 2013). When considering what goals the HR team has that are critical to Starbucks’…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction This paper will talk about how the cultures affect worker loyalty and career flexibility in the Japanese and American workplace. Also, work-life balance will be discussed. The countries that I chose to study are Japan and the U.S. because both countries are big well-known developed countries and I find it interesting to research the effects of cultures on worker loyalty and career flexibility. Among the many democratic countries in the world, many rights of Americans, defined within the amendments of the constitution allows Americans to have less restrictive practices unlike countries like japan.…

    • 2287 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the 20th century, with the growth of globalization and nationalization, the current business environment and corporate management have transcended geographical boundaries, multinational companies are becoming more and more competitive, which means that multinational companies need a cross geographical and cultural boundaries (Baruch, 2002). Therefore, in order to adjust to this new world rank, multinational companies need to develop more international managers, in addition, multinational management quality in the international arena is very important. In entering the international market, without a high-quality international managers, will confront a lot of risk (Forster, 2000). International managers face challenges of ethnic diversity…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    THE IMPACT OF MANAGEMENT IN THE GLOBALISATION OF BUSINESS Globalization has been a human activity since the era of human colonialism and the more recent globalization as has been evident in the post cold war era. We have seen the dominance of global corporations like Walmart, Mcdonalds, Toyota etc. Most of these corporations Franchises in particular have used standardized methods of management especially in relation to the Management framework (P-O-L-C). Good management has played a huge role towards the success of Global business as they seek to enter new markets, raw material and cheap labor from abroad, Such were obviously strategic moves as the corporations were exploiting opportunities and obviously encountered competition from new markets…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The impact of the Middle East culture on the IHRM The Middle East region has grown during the past years and today is considered as one of the most diverse regions in the world. In fact, the Middle East region is home of hundreds of nationalities of professionals who work in the different countries of the region. Genuinely, the diversity of human capital has created a multi-cultural environment in the region of the Middle East, in which the HR managers set different strategies and approaches in order to benefit from this diversity. International human resources management IHRM consists of a set of processes and procedures that manage the different cultures and ensure the effectiveness of the organizations while doing business abroad. In point…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Human Resource Management: Repatriation: Repatriation can be defined as the process in which a person comes back or returns to its home country from the host country after working there for a specific number of years (Hurn, 1999). Repatriation is considered important because the person has to re-adapt himself to the home country and the pattern of work and at the same time begin interaction with their friends and fellow workers. Normally all the managers and expatriates assume that adjusting in their home country and culture will be really smooth but it has been seen that for most of them it’s the other way round that is adapting themselves to the host country, that is living abroad is easier. According to Adler (2007) the re-entrants undergo…

    • 1766 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Changes in Japanese HRM Systems: Case of Sony’s Restructuring (Group 10) IBE455: HRM in Japan Toshihiro Roppongi A1367977 Rika Kitanaka A1368678 Misa Sekine A1368348 Keito Okamoto A1468667 Introduction: In 1990s, slow economic growth, financial crisis has lead Japan to the lost decade. Due to lower productivity, economic growth, increase in global competition, and the financial crisis, many firms in Japan faced severe competition and declining profits.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    David Guest sees HRM as a different methodology to dealing with the workforce. HRM has a unique approach to select and train staff and should be focused on the individual’s performance and capabilities. Davis Guest suggests there should be 4 crucial components to create an effective workforce: • Strategic Integration • Flexibility • High Commitment • Quality Davis Guest mentions the two differences between HRM and Personal Management/IR: HRM Personnel / IR 1 Time and planning perspective Long term, proactive, strategic, integrated Short term, reactive, marginal 2 Roles Highly integrated into line management Professionals and experts and specialists 3 Employee relation perspective Unitarist, individual, high in trust Pluralist, collective, low trust 4 Control system Self-control system External system 5 Psychological contract…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays