Essentialist Arguments Against Essentialism

Improved Essays
He believed that differences in male and female anatomy account for the development of distinct masculine and feminine gender roles. Furthermore, Socio-biologists and evolutionary psychologists have offered an essentialist theory. They also point of view gender differences in behavior are based in biological differences between women and men (Brym and Jhon, 2005: 290). However, sociologists have lodged four main criticisms against essentialist arguments such as those of Freud and the socio-biologists and evolutionary psychologists. 1. Essentialists ignore the historical and cultural variability of gender and Sexuality. 2. Essentialist tends to generalize from the average, ignoring variations within gender groups 3. No evidence directly supports

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The constructionist views of gender and sexuality is the way an individual is born either male or female. With this in mind the constructionist view gender as a social structure and acknowledge that masculinity and femininity as one way of classifying individuals, but they realize that each society and each past society’s time period differs when it comes to defining masculinity and femininity (Ferris, p.246). The constructionist view has changed the way society identity’s an individual because they do not only look at their sex but other contributing factors like other theories. Some of the other theories are the functionalist theory, the conflict theory, and the symbolic interactionist theory.…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unit 5, Activity 4: ISP Essay Gender Inequality in Water for Elephants In today’s society, there is a common misconception between “gender” and “sex”. Although many believe these two identities to be similar in context, they have two different meanings: One’s “sex” refers to their genetic make-up (in terms of hormonal profile, sex organs etc.), while gender describes the characteristics that are classified as feminine or masculine by a culture or society. For example, in western cultures, women are usually seen as “more delicate and compassionate than men...have expectations to be domestic, warm, pretty, emotional, dependent, physically weak, and passive.”…

    • 1730 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gender vs. Sexuality is the most controversial issue that exists in society. Before an individual can choose their sexuality they must have a specific gender to distinguish them in society. Since the beginning of this class we learn different perspective on social constructionist vs. essentialism, which explains different stance on how society is socially constructed. The fact that society requires us to follow gender role create problems for individuals from being there true self. By society definition sex is based on chromosomes, meaning to be a female you must have XX chromosome and a male is XY.…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Biological essentialism is an ineffective method to studying sexuality and gendered relationships because it does not consider the social, familial, and politically imposed regulations and roles on the individual that have influenced his/her sexuality. The culture of poverty theory fails to examine the aspects of racism and prejudice while condemning an individual of an ethnic marginalized community for perpetuating poverty. Psychotherapeutic literature attempts to explain the actions of an individual by diagnosing him/her with a physical malfunction rather than addressing the circumstances that the individual was raised and socialized into.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People in some societies have two different perspectives regarding how they take life to be, the essentialist perspective and constructionist perspective. By definition, the Essentialist perspective is a view that some people have they think that everything comes from nature. Things are the way they are because of nature. They believe that "everything that we see and touch is merely a manifestation of a deeper essence" (Roy 8). The Constructionist perspective is the view that people who believe that “Reality is created by society” (Roy 10).…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many differences between both males and females, from anatomy to the gender assigned roles of society. Through the decades, the gender roles have been put into play, in not only our society, but also the societies around the world. “Sex and Temperament” written by Margaret Mead, explores the cultural norms of societies around the globe and how they align with the norms we have become accustom to in our daily lives. “This study is not concerned with whether there are or are not actual and universal differences between the sexes, either quantitative or qualitative.” (Mead, 710)…

    • 1025 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Female subordination is a universal theme. In the Mexican culture, the power is in the hands of the man and love is in the hands of the women (Diaz, 2014). It is in adolescence that the female is taught her role of taking care of the male (Diaz, 2014). Women are chaste, sexuality is a secondary role and girls are lady like (Diaz, 2014). The home chores are considered taboo to the males but both male and female children are taught obedience (Diaz, 2014).…

    • 228 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Delusions Of Gender Essay

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The differentiation of genders is maintained through systematic oppression. Oppression occurs at a micro and macro scale, from workplace discrimination in the US to mass murder in Pakistan. Cordelia Fine, in her book Delusions of gender : How Our Minds, Society, and Neurosexism Create Difference, points out the blatant sexism that exists within the field of neuroscience. She dissects the words of Thomas Gisborne, who argues that fields relating to science, law, and business should be reserved for men, and that the talents of a woman lies elsewhere: ‘The superiority of the female mind is unrivalled’, enjoying ‘powers adapted to unbend the brow of the learned, to refresh the over-laboured faculties of the wise, and to diffuse, throughout the…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The great debate, this story tells a good example between Essentialism vs. Dominance. When reading this passage the main point to this story between essentialism vs. dominance are essentialist theorist as it say in paragraph 4.” Men communicates to solve problems, where women communicates to establish emotional connections. Also women find intimacy through conversations, and men find it through actions”. This passage is a wonderful example on how and woman and man’s brain functions.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After watching the film, Tough Guise 2, I felt much more educated on the subject of masculinity and the enormous effect it has on men and societal expectations of their behavior. I felt as though I learned a lot about a subject I am not usually aware of, especially from growing up in a home with four women and only one man (my father). I now feel much more sympathy for men’s issues dealing with masculinity and the stigma that surrounds it, that men are supposed to always be strong and in control, and show no sign of weakness or vulnerability. While watching Tough Guise 2, I couldn’t help but notice many similarities to the readings by Alan G. Johnson and Kimmel. In Johnson’s “The Gender Knot”, he discusses a viewpoint known as essentialism, or the belief that women and men are essentially different biologically, as in men are physically stronger and more disposed to violence, etc.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both authors discuss the difference in male and female behavior in society not as a result of innate behaviors but, as a result of learned social constructs. The authors also discuss the need for equity in society to offer…

    • 1105 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The journal article I found is about gender and sexuality. The article title is “Sex Rules: Emerging Adult’s Perception of Gender’s Impact on Sexuality.” The article’s authors are Megan Maas, Cindy Shearer, Meghan Gillen, and Eva Lefkowitz. This article was taken from a journal named “Sexuality & Culture” published in December 2015. In the article it explains a study done on men and women with a question of if gender impacts their sexuality.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Alexandra Duma Professor Helen Kapstein LIT 316 Defying the Gender Binary in Luna Gender identity is the subjective understanding of one’s gender (Morrow 7). The way in which an individual forms a gender identity relies heavily on the socio-cultural environment in which one lives. Gender identity is different than biological sex and sexual orientation. Luna by Julie Anne Peters follows the coming of age story of Luna, a boy who struggles with gender roles and expectations imposed on him by his family from a young age.…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whereas sex is more universally defined, gender can vary in each society; the “norms, roles and relationships” (Newman, 2016, para.14) of socially defined characteristics can change for both men and women. British…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender and sexuality, two things that are seemingly determined at the moment a person is born. It is naturally assumed and projected onto an individual through societal norms that if an individual is born with a penis they are determined to be a male, and as a male once this individual reaches sexual maturity they should engage in sexual relations only with members of the female sex. The same norms apply for members of the female sex, if one is born with a vagina from the moment of their first breath it is determined that the female should only engage in acts of sex with members of the male sex, and conform to traditionally set gender norms. In this paper, I will prove this wrong and explain that despite genitalia and societal norms both gender and sexuality are subjective and range on a wide spectrum varying from individual to individual. Gender, defined as the state of being male or female, this usually in the proper context refers to the social constructions rather than the biological constructs of sex which is determined by the genitalia and reproductive organs associated with the being to which they belong.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays