Was The Southern States Justified In Joining The Civil War

Improved Essays
The Civil War was a pivot point in the history of The United States. Between 1860 and
1861 Texas, Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Mississippi, South Carolina, and Louisiana were the first seven states the seceded from the Union and carried on with their own political affairs and government hence leading to the Civil War. After the War began in 1861, the seven states were joined by four other southern states, Virginia, Tennessee, North Carolina, and Arkansas. These eleven states formed the Confederate States of America while the rest of the other states remained with the Union. From a Utilitarian point of view, The Southern states were not justified for seceding, while the other four states of the South that remained in the union resisted were, and
…show more content…
Some southern states who fought in the Civil War did not even own slaves. Why? Controlling the slave population was a matter of concern for all Whites, whether they owned slaves or not. The Civil War was mainly over abolition. The Confederate states knew that Lincoln opposed to the expansion of slaves and this was a critical problem. According to Gordon Rhea, Southerners became increasingly isolated; they reacted by becoming more strident in defending slavery . The pro-union states are justified from joining the Confederate States because the Northern States were bound to the constitution. The majority of the citizens did not want to go to war. Four slave states were border states that later on joined the Union. Every free state understood the Constitution, were loyal, and the military pressure kept them from succeeding.
The American Revolution and the Civil war compare in a few aspects. Unity and leadership are the main two similarities between the American Civil War and Revolutionary War. General Robert E. Lee was the commander of the Army of Northern Virginia and is known as the most accomplished Confederate general , and George Washington was one of the many American Revolutionary leaders. These leaders who inspired other people and portrayed
…show more content…
The Southern States did not consider the opinion of their citizens rather they did what was the best for their government. This is usually how Utilitarianism works and it is used by politicians nowadays. The four states that remained away from the Confederate states did not betrayed anyone. Instead, they did not want to fight on either side of the parties involved, while the Confederate states are not justified in breaking the law, breaking the Constitution, and attacking the Union. If a state like Texas began to seriously consider leaving the United States I would consider moving out of the state because secession is illegal and Texas would break the law. All fifty states are "one nation, indivisible." Trying to leave the United States would be pointless. If Texas tries to secede, other American states would try to do the same thing, and this would not be possible without a war/rebellion. Two years ago Scotland tried to secede from New England, but they were not successful, and their government is not the same as the one from the United

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The South seceded on December 20th 1860 and the first state to secede was South Carolina. The Secession was the South trying to take over power. The States that seceded next were Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, and Mississippi. During this secession West Virginia was made as a new state and the Confederate States of America was made as a new country. The president of the new country was Jefferson Davis.…

    • 70 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Earlier this week, after thirty-four hours of non-stop shelling, US Army Major Robert Anderson surrendered control of Fort Sumter to Confederate General PGT Beauregard. Just yesterday, Virginia became the latest domino to fall in Southern secession. That makes eight states now, and rumors continue to swirl that Arkansas, Tennessee, and North Carolina are sure to follow. After years of hostile legislation, menacing Northern abolitionists, and now the election of Abraham Lincoln, the South has finally broken away from the Union.…

    • 422 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    How Did The South Seceded

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The South left because States seceded from the union because the compromise would no longer work The South seceded from the Union because compromises were no longer working, there were fights over slavery, and there were big economic differences. The southern states seceded. It was called the civil war. They were trad food in the north and then they sell or buy slaves. The south seceded because there was no longer no working there was a lot of changes going on.…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Revolutionary War and the Civil war have many similarities. One similarity is the cause of the war. Both wars were fought in the name of unity,the Revolutionary war was fought for the unity of the colonies, and the Civil War was fought for the preservation of the Union. The wars were both fought on American soil.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    North and South, each side fighting for what they believe in. Since the North did not want slavery and the South did, they began arguing about either to have slaves or not. Six states in the southern part of the U.S. seceded and formed “The Confederacy,” against the North. Later, Texas became the seventh state to join the Confederacy. Then began the Civil War.…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Should the founding fathers have kept us as a confederacy or was it a good idea to change to a constitution republic? In 1776 the country that we now call the Untied States of America was formerly known as the confederacy until 1789 then the United States was born as a constitution republic. The reasoning for the change was to make a stronger federal government for the national government. The confederacy was to weak to defend itself from inserection from the people or from other countries that had large standing armies.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why South Seceded

    • 2036 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The North and South states had different viewpoints. The North believed that slavery should be abolished, however the South did not agree. The Southern lifestyle was based around slavery. The southern states ended up leaving the Union in 1861 because their way of life was threatened. In the South their economy consisted of tobacco and later cotton.…

    • 2036 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Secession Dbq Essay

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The legality of secession is an argument still hotly debated in the United States today. In light of the recent presidential election, the issue has resurfaced with vigor; states on the west coast, for example, have proposed a secession from the Union under the name “Cascadia.” The same argument was made in the years leading up to the the civil war of the late 1800s, during which Southern states relinquished their membership of the Union. I would argue, however, that the southerners had no constitutional right to secede and that the view of secession as a legal right is a flawed one. Despite having “seceded” from Britain years prior, the states during the civil war had no legal right to secede from the Union as they had agreed to follow the…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The First Battle of Bull Run was not only a prelude to the way the Civil War would unfold but it highlighted the importance of intelligence and sound judgment. Bull Run, also known as the First Manassas, was the deadliest ground battle the United States had seen in any war up to that point (McDonald, 1999). The battle came after eleven southern states seceded from the union and pushed out union troops from Fort Sumter, South Carolina. The key mistakes made by the Federalist, Union Army, led to a devastating loss and allowed the Confederates to extend the war for another four years. By looking into the intelligence, or lack thereof, we can redirect the Union Army and by sheer numbers and power show how the battle could have been turned.…

    • 1331 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Secession Dbq

    • 1962 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Secession The secession is a process that describes the period in which eleven states in the United States of America left the Union. At the time, the southerners believed in the right to own slaves and utilize them as a source of labor. On the other hand, the northerners identified slavery as inhumane and advocated for its abolition in the country.…

    • 1962 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During the Civil War, many men felt the urge to stand up for their country and enroll in the army. But the downside is that some families had different beliefs, causing different parts of a family to live in either the north or south. When it would come time for battle, families would end up fighting each other and possibly kill a loved one. This didn't just happen between the Union and the Confederacy, and it was more likely to happen in border states. These states were not claimed by either the north or south, for there were many people who had different opinions on what side they wanted to fight with.…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Was the Civil War predictable? Did any events indefinitely cause the South to desire a split from the North? The North and the South had a growing tension between them for many reasons, and the northern abolitionists encouraged a Civil War through their actions of protest. Although many Americans were affected minimally by the changes of the nation, abolitionists inevitably foresaw a Civil War because the growing tensions between the North and the South became apparent in political and social changes, slavery issues, and the growing occurrence of rebellions. Political and social changes occurred in many ways, including The Second Great Awakening, Lincoln’s presidential election to office, the way the North and the South dealt with one another,…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Southern states desired to make decision for themselves within the state, which was ultimately the right to practice slavery. Had we avoided the Civil War, slavery would had probably continued for a much longer period, although eventually it would have been phased out, due to the inventions of machinery and also by the pressure of other…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The south felt like they had no other choice other than secession, this was a decision that led directly to war. The industrialized North may not have had as much land as the south, although, they did have the ability to mass produce weapons much more effectively than the south did, due to their factories. Within four devastating years, the Southern Confederacy surrendered, and America remained one whole nation, under a Federal…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Secession Essay

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although the Northern states and the Southern states had their differences in their beliefs, on profuse occasions—specifically on slavery—compromises had squelch down the bad blood between them. However, in 1789, even after the Constitution was adopted by all of the States to amalgamate as a nation, for more than thirty years, the temporarily ceased frictions between the North and South went to and fro once more. Thus, by 1861, these opposing ideals between the disputants were so prodigious that the compromises do not seem enticing to either antithetical stance. Henceforth, this led to the secession of the Southern states, much to the Northern states’ disgust and eventually to the Civil War.…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays