Division Of Labor And Capitalism By Smith, Marx, And Durkheim

Decent Essays
In this world division of labor and capitalism is essential for capitalist, most people would also think is important for the workers as well. Which it is for a period of time, but after a while the benefit fades away. There are more negative consequences of division labor and capitalism than you think. This essay will analyze all the negative consequences of the division and labor and capitalism arguments by Smith, Marx, and Durkheim. In Adam Smith’s book “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations” Smiths argue that the division labor destroys “intellectual social and martial virtues”. Smith also argued that capitalism is a free market of trade, governed based on competition and individual which wage will be determined …show more content…
Alienation is the when workers are constantly working on the task, it becomes a routine for everyday and that lead to workers become disinclination and poor skills for their daily routine work. Marx also mentions in “Economic& philosophic Manuscripts of 1844” that workers are depressed spiritually and physically to the condition of a machine. Although he believed in division of labor they produce more which is essential, he still criticize capitalism for exploitation of labor. First is the alienation from the product. Under capitalism individual doesn’t receive any benefits from whatever they produce, they lack the ability of to produce to gain money or feel satisfy after an accomplishment, followed by a quote Marx said, “When human beings become alienate from what they produce they lose control over their product”. Secondly he argues about alienation from productions. Individuals who works hard long hours yet gets paid low wages, it doesn’t matter how many workers were producing, because of that works were alienated cause to not seeing gains or higher wage from their hard work and productive producers. Another alienation was from the individuals lack of control. When you build something for yourself or your company you put more energy into because the more profit you make from is more money in your own pocket, not under capitalism. Individuals was doing whatever they were order to do, in Marx alienated labor this situation reduced the labor force, especially to workers who are repeatedly working in the same tasks, in result they found themselves lacking of skills and creativity plus value to the company. Last is the alienations from workers to workers. Capitalism makes a competitive market workers are competing with each other’s for a better reward. Overall capitalism takes full advantages

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The lack of regulations let the owners of the companies force the workers to work beyond what was fair for little pay, and this caused them to not live fulfilling lives as they lived paycheck to paycheck. The stress this created linked them together in a common struggle, and this is what Marx was trying to monopolize on. If he could get the lower classes to realize they all had one common enemy they could join forces to rise against the rich and powerful. Many of the things Marx argued for in his time are now simple realities today that people would be aghast if the government did not provide them, such as public high school and progressive income tax. While many of his ideas were a bit farfetched or unachievable in the current society today with how far into capitalism America sinks its…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Another interesting point made is that trade is based on voluntary exchange, meaning sweatshops, are not the horror protestors make them out to be. These jobs pay more than any other job offered to the workers of an impoverished country. Coincidentally, all the protests and boycotts for the rights of these workers and the demand for fair treatment of them, is problematic in the long run. The less people buy from the company these people work for means…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the theory of Communism, the bourgeoisie doesn’t allow the prestigious people to succeed in their field. It is a reality that communism can’t actually work fairly because there are many factor that prevent that. These factors are the struggle between the working class and the Bourgeoisie, these struggles doesn’t allow communism to work because the high class always get the benefit of the people who actually work. The working class always has to go to the struggle of getting more benefit from the work they done from the owners of factories. The struggle is that factory owners doest want to pay a fair salary because if they do that they wouldn’t have gain as much profit as the actually do.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Alienation occurs when the workers are no longer happy with their jobs and an individual has no meaningful purpose to work there other than for a pay check. Alienation makes workers distant from nature and from other people. They lose and forget who they really are and what they want to be. They separate them-selves from the natural world and just be limited as a working machines (AOW, 396-397). Marx represented four types of alienated labors that workers are suffering from working under the capitalism.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As a result, the system is inherently unequal in the treatment of social classes and the earnings. The capitalists frequently come out on top on the backs of the laborers. Trade within capitalism is never truly equal with workers receiving less than what they are owed for their work, so owners can maximize their profit. Supply and Demand is a significant piece of capitalism as it determines prices, the amounts of production and even the number of laborers. Laborers are at times dispensable and then other times greatly needed.…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Therefore, due to the low wages, workers have to work more hours. Employers see this as an advantage because more production is completed. What is important to businesses is profit and running a business cheaply as possible. To save money is the most important factor of why businesses offshore to other countries. It’s inhumane that workers are paid low wages and must work more hours to get enough barely money to provide for themselves.…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They work in unfavorable conditions and get paid much less then what Americans would get paid. The sad part is that they do not realize that they are making less than what Americans would make; they are only worried about keeping that job and making the money they can use to support their families. One of the problems the workers face is that it becomes a competition for them in order to get the job. Even though the job does not pay well, they still need every penny, or the currency they use, to make their own lives easier. Due to the NAFTA, the United States can open up factories in poor countries and have that country’s people work for them.…

    • 1062 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While the debate between Mises and Marx continued, other philosophers would also debate if capitalism and socialism was better, and how each system would affect the entire society. Marx was against capitalism because of the gap between the two social classes that the capitalist system formed. Marx saw this struggle first hand during the Industrial Revolution and decided to write in his “Communist Manifesto”. He saw how the working poor became more of a commodity as the bourgeoisie obtained more and more power. Marx said that capitalism would make the rich richer and the poor poorer.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Karl Marx Vs Adam Smith

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Adam Smith advocates that division of labour and specialisation is the finest way to produce goods as firms can become extremely efficient and produce numerous more goods in a day as the production is divided into various parts. Karl Marx disagrees with this method as he states this will cause a state of alienation. Due to the face workers are only working on a portion of the good rather than producing the whole good itself, they are alienated from the product and do not feel a sense of accomplishment or satisfaction when working. Which will cause a reduction in labour morale. Both of these two economist provide us with theories that are both extremely useful and important to modern day economics.…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With this concept, the work that the worker does has no connection to the worker himself. Basically, the worker works with no life purpose and as a result Is disconnected from life activity. Finally, the fourth concept is the worker’s alienation from man. With this concept, the worker begins to feel alienated from the system of private property. The worker feels this way because the capitalist uses the workers labor and benefits from it by selling the product in which the worker receives little to any acknowledgment from.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays