Discretion In John Dempsey's An Introduction To Policing

Improved Essays
When it comes to law enforcement, officers have to make quick, often challenging decisions every day. They are forced to do what they think is right and just in accordance to the roles and duties of a police officer. The public should be able to trust that they’ll do the right thing and respond to situations appropriately. In order to do so, police must use their discretion to the best of their ability. However, it seems that more and more cases of injustice and police brutality are coming to light around the country. Officers have been caught using their discretion in uncontrolled manners. In certain situations, it meant life or death. Either way it goes, their discretion should be justified.
In John Dempsey’s An Introduction to Policing,
…show more content…
In August of this year, dash-cam video of a police officer from Euclid, Ohio went viral because he was shown using excessive force and beating a man during a routine traffic stop (Hawkins, 2017). In the video, he asks the driver to step out of the vehicle. Seconds later, the officer is shown pushing him and wrestling him to the ground where he then threw punches. The driver didn’t appear to threaten the officer in any way yet the cop used excessive force when it didn’t seem to be needed. The question then is, why did his discretionary judgment lead him to act that way in the first place? It’s possible that the officer had a prejudice against the driver. It’s also possible that he could’ve just been having a bad day and acted out inappropriately. But based on the video evidence, neither of those reasons justify the way he acted. It doesn’t make it right. And when similar situations are occurring across the country, ethics and discretionary judgement need to be justified. In addition, the officer has a history of violence and other suspicious acts that would make anyone question his motives and ability perform his job properly. If an officer’s discretionary judgement can’t be justified, he can’t properly and fairly perform his job as a law …show more content…
In June of this year, a man in Thailand walked into a police station wielding a knife and causing a threat. Instead of pulling his weapon, an officer simply talked to the man who was clearly in distress. He used his discretion to the best of his ability and deescalated the situation. The man put the knife down and hugged the officer. Instead of forcing a violent and potentially deadly situation, the officer used his discretion to make what he thought was the best judgement. Although he could’ve been killed, he put his life in danger to reach the best possible outcome. He proved that he can be reliable and trustworthy in tense circumstances, especially when it meant life or death.
In conclusion, enforcers of the law need to use their discretion in an appropriate manner so that the public can trust them and have fair protection under the law. The process of becoming an officer should be carefully examined for each person so that each one can enforce the equally to everyone. Having discretion is a powerful responsibility and when it’s not used correctly, chaos like what’s going on around the country will continue and issues with injustice and police brutality won’t

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In a statement by Lt. Jim Glennon (Ret), “For law enforcement professionals, communication skills are the most important of all the skills necessary to succeed in your profession” (Glennon, 2010). Communication is not only verbal, but visual as well. On a daily basis, officers interact with individuals with diverse backgrounds, which can influence how an officer will converse. On the flip side, the way an officer conducts and presents his or her self will determine how an individual or suspect will respond to an officer. If an officer conducts his or her self as rude or arrogant, the less likely an individual will be to cooperate, which can hinder an investigation.…

    • 2032 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Ethics Case Study

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Some of the methods are already in place to ensure that people like Spaulding are punished and discouraged from acting in that same manner again. One of them is creating a code of conduct that guides the law enforcement activities. Secondly, the consequences should be reinforced by ensuring that every police officer is accountable for his or her activities. There should also be frequent trainings and talks about ethical standards in service dispensation. This would remind the officers to be more on the lookout to ensure that they do not violate the ethical principles expected of them.…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Insubordination can be detrimental to a department and the image of law enforcement officers in general. If an officer does not follow orders it can expose themselves andtheir department to legal liability, as well as public scrutiny. For example, if an officer does not follow…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Does a ticket violation need to result in a shooting? No. Does an armed man, attacking another? Sure. Police, actually everyone should be able to make judgments like that, but police should be better at making those decisions, since they have training and should know when and how to apply it.…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Police Corruption

    • 1766 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Law enforcement officer are given a great amount of authority to make find solutions to problems and keep the community safe, while being unsupervised. However, having too much authority can change a person, for the worse. So, that leaves room to wonder, who is maintaining the order of the police? Or preventing and detecting whether they are…

    • 1766 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also as a civilization we should understand the real purpose of police officers. The real purpose of the law enforcement is to keep everyone safe and to help them make correct choices. The average person should follow the rules to make the policemen’s job easier. If we don’t follow the law there will be a lot of chaos going on in our community. The policemen also need to follow the rules.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The use of any force beyond what is necessary to arrest a suspect and keep police and bystanders safe is considered police brutality (Segan). It may also be measured as any violation of the due process that the Constitution has set (O’Conner). People try not to believe that such a thing is occurring in today’s society, for the thought frightens them. It is hard to accept that the system that is supposed to protect the citizens would harm them in any way, shape, or form.…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this scenario, both of the victims of the offense might appear to be hurt as one party tried to self-defended his or herself from the attack of the other party. This means that the officer might not be able to distinguish the precise offender. Therefore, this demands effective communication and questioning prior to making a conclusion. Thus, in order to adhere to procedural justice guidelines, the officer should consider the rights of both parties by following the case from both sides. This means that the officer should not start with exerting violence to the suspected party.…

    • 1615 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    73).” The relationship dynamic between the police and the community is extremely critical in the fight against crime. This is due to the fact that when they are on good terms with one another; citizens and the community in general will be more inclined to report crimes that occur, provide tips on criminal organisations as well as willingly serve as witnesses and a jurors (Ross, 2012, p.117).” All of this is imperative in order for the law enforcement and justice departments to succussed in protecting the community whilst delivering justice. However, the relationship dynamic dictates that the police must have a strong understanding the community’s complications, goals and desires; particularly those citizens who are experiencing high rates of crime, poverty, and homelessness perceive police as an occupying and out-of-touch force that does more harm than good. In these situations, police departments must primarily assume a reactive mode of response to community problems. This can only be made possible when the police force possess critical thinking.…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    It became a very controversial issue because police officers sometimes justify their abuse of force. “Since their job is to protect the city streets and to guard the population, they typically say that they were just handling their daily work of enforcing the law” (Lawrence). Reasonably, this created fear in the larger populations since they are well aware of the treatment they get from the officers. Also, they have witnessed exploitation of television and news media or heard it directly from the casualty. The case of Rodney, King and Amadou Diallo had a profound effect on the society concerning the powers bestowed on police officers.…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays