Police Discretion Case Study

Superior Essays
In this essay a discussion will be explored about the benefits and problems associated with police use of discretion. Which current policing strategies have the most potential for controlling officer discretion and providing accountability, and which have the least, and why is that the case? And finally, how might these issues impact the various concerns facing law enforcement today? Police behavior is different across all communities. In fact, how police react to combat crime is affected by the management style of the various police administrators. Also, local politics will have a strong influence on how police react to crime. When police respond to a call, they will make a determination of the “cost and benefits” of their reaction. How …show more content…
In his article, The Police on Skid-Row: A Study of Peace Keeping, Egon Bittner said, police officers’ role as peace keeper in their training manuals only gave passing attention to this aspect of the job role. He also repeated the point that departments usually do not keep records of processes that do not involve making an arrest. When officers warn, discipline, without making an arrest, there is consensus that they are serving in their role as peace-keeper. In their role as peace-keepers on skid-row, officers deal with persons who are viewed as people not fully accountable for their actions. They are seen as people who need continuous attention and are in need of special procedures. In most cases a department will assign an officer to these areas on a fairly permanent basis and allow them to use their own discretion in running things. The officers’ supervisor takes for granted that the patrolman assigned to these areas primary business is to keep the peace, and not necessarily to control crime. Officers are aware that often the demands they make on the inhabitants on skid-row are a violation of their due process rights. Officers feel that the control they exert over the people on skid-row is in harmony with standard expectations. The large amount of discretion that officers have, although accepted by standard practices, when dealing with residents on skid-row, is still somewhat …show more content…
The District Attorney has discretionary power to decide the disposition of cases. One of the primary ways that the District Attorney uses its’ discretion is in how he processes plea-bargaining. The District Attorney may reduce a defendants’ exposure to a crime if he provides some pieces of information that he needs to prosecute a bigger player in the narcotics trade. It has been said that the administration of justice is a selective process in which only those cases that will not overload the system will ultimately be prosecuted (Cole, 1970) Also the courts use a great deal of discretion in the way it disposes of cases. Because the District Attorney can only have a certain amount of cases on backlog, at times at the end of the year, the court will assist in reducing the amount of backlogged cases by changing the manner it disposes of cases, with pleas and placing more people on probation. Police departments further use a measure of discretion in the way it allocates resources. To accomplish that goal, they develop differential response systems to distinguish between emergency and non-emergency calls (Skogen &ump; Frydell) Some members of the minority communities feel they were being shortchanged by the way police departments disperse officers to calls for

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Police Subculture The police subculture is much the same throughout all the law enforcement careers throughout the world. The police subculture is a distinctive set of beliefs, values, attitudes, and behaviors that are shared amongst the majority of officers working in law enforcement organizations (Malmin, 2012). The subculture is taught to new recruits from the first day they arrive at the academy to the last day. This subculture follows them from that point on throughout their career in law enforcement.…

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Police officers should not always enforce the law equally in all situations. There is wide interpretation of laws and it would be nearly impossible to enforce the laws equally because of this. Discretion is something used by police officers it allows them to enforce the law. You cant write a law that covers every situation a officer will possibly be in. So discretion is necessary.…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Firstly, in understanding Police discretion someone would want to know if the concept has any benefit to society. In fact there are many strengths or advantages associated with the principle of police officers using their discretion. When a police officer uses his or her discretion it allows them to make a decision that is fair and humane, which in turn can improve the way people view the police. If the police were to follow the laws to latter, they would be perceived to be unfair to society and hence rejected (Rivera, 2006). This shows a major strength in the use of discretion by police officers mostly because it helps to build the moral of the officer and also contributes in building a community’s trust in the police, for example in…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Discretion Essay

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The use of police discretion has been effective in achieving…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The findings of the study indicated a negative picture of the police among the black population. Accordingly, the population doesn’t seem to honor the legal duties allotted to the police because of their exaggerated violent interactions. In the cities dominated by the White, the stories take a different course with most people having good comments about the police services. This is to imply that the police treat the White population differently. The journal is crucial in the studies related to crime studies or legal matter as well as other academicians of interest.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Discretion Thesis

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Therefore, it cannot be used in every aspect of law enforcement as strict guidelines are in place and must be followed by officers. For example, a woman claims she has been the victim of domestic violence and has been severely wounded, there is very little space for discretion in this situation compared to if the woman had no physical evidence of the abuse. Traffic violations are where police discretion is most commonly used. In order to come to a rightful decision, likelihood to commit given infraction again as well as impact to a persons life are taken into account when an officer is exercising discretion.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The law provides boundaries for officials to work within, however, it does not eliminate them from utilizing discretion. The decisions to intervene in a situation, cite, arrest, or prosecute the individual are all greatly discretionary (Greenleaf, Skogan, & Lurigio, 2008). A police officers ability to utilize discretion is the beginning of what could lead to a long judicial process. When making a traffic stop, they have the decision to issue a verbal warning or issue a ticket. A major downfall to law enforcements discretionary character is ethnic or racial profiling.…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    but in this case I feel that they would not truly know enough information for the state’s attorney in order for them to bargain with in order to get a lesser sentence. Therefore, he or she should not use discretion in this situation because it will not truly help…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police departments too often use excessive force, injuring people suspected of crimes and occasionally killing them. People of minority groups and the poor or the homeless are often the victims of police brutality. Law enforcement agencies repeatedly try to cover it up. This has become a controversial issue among many countries and communities that have seen police brutality take place in their own neighborhood. Police officers are challenged with dangerous situations every single day, which forces them to make immediate decisions.…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    community or society to another (Katz et al., 2012). The police discretionary actions are noted as an inevitable and always presented in the positive perspectives. Stop, search, arrest and charge offenders are routine of police officers in their everyday life. Ambiguous and obsolete criminal laws and regulations, short of human, material and technology resources for law enforcement and variable level of significance of crime and behavior of criminals, nature of situation to respond are core for the officers to exercise discretions and that stands as legal platform for effective law enforcement (Booth, 1996) Goldstein (1963) stated that the support for police discretionary actions is basically the criminal laws that foster and cause officer…

    • 185 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the style of policing that reflects the departments values (Wasserman & Moore, 1988). Values of policing has not changed much from the article in Perspectives in Policing in 1988, stating that many values to lead and defend the “performance of police agencies. ”(Wasserman & Moore) The article states that “Communities can provide police with assistance…,” and that citizens are priority first (Wasserman & Moore, 1988). Even when one officer choose to do something unethical, the public will look at the whole department as unethical (Ortmeier,…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This problem creates a loophole for officers who may engage in criminal activity. There is a gray area in the issue of police and community relations. The authorities have the mandate to relate with the community as they please without supervision. It requires the law enforcement authorities to…

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The application of discretion is evident throughout the criminal justice field. Discretion, in its simplest terms, is when one makes an informed choice between more than two options. Discretion is more formally defined as “the authority to make a decision between two or more choices” (Pollock, 2014, p. 2). The act of discretion, initiates with legislators; that creates and defines laws, and discretion extends to all areas of the criminal justice field to include prosecutors, judges, correctional officers, and to police officers. By empowering law enforcement officers with the authority of discretion, there is room for abuse, especially when the power is not respected.…

    • 2296 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Discretion Essay

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Police Discretion is at the core of policing, allowing officers to approach different situations with different approaches. Discretion is seen as the most essential element of policing, yet discretion is also the source of many problems. Over the year’s discretion has become a more prominent issue amongst the public, and due to social media and the increased use of the internet, videos and new reports can be shared with millions in a matter of seconds. Yet the truth is the discretion an officer’s use is comprehensively subjective to real-world situations rather than adopted by a certain agenda. Police discretion an essential and required part of police work (Schulenberg, 2015, pg.247).…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Police Officers and the departments they work have a great influence on society; this holds true for many reasons. Whether you like the police or not, it has been proven that they are an essential part of your community. The police are there to protect and serve those in society. This has held true since 1626, the date in which New York City first founded the New York City Sheriff’s Office. Though the way the police do their job today may not be the same as it was hundreds of years ago, the need still exists.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics