Compare And Contrast The Book And Movie The Help

Improved Essays
“There’s nothing healthy about segregation” a quote from Michael Gargano. This statement is relevant to the book and movie “The Help” because during the 1960’s, when people were segregated by race, people thought it was normal to be separated. For example a character in the book and movie, Aibileen, a black maid that works hard for Mrs.Leefolt everyday and is mistreated because she is black, but she still keeps an amazing attitude and is great at her job. During the 1960’s many black women,like Aibileen, worked for white families.I have recently read the book and watched the movie “The Help” and there are many similar things from the book to movie, but there are also a few differences, an example of a similarity is the plot stayed the same …show more content…
Another difference is the character traits between the book and movie differ,the book is more descriptive with some character traits than the movie. Also in the scene where Minnie left her husband the movie gave a very good visual of how it all happened. Finally, the last difference is, as you read the book you were able to create whatever picture you wanted in your head, you had your own visual for different scenes in the book which is different from the movie because in the movie actors/actresses played the characters so you no longer had a mental picture of what was happening it was just whatever the actor/actress looked like and what they did.
Although there are some differences there are many similarities between the book and the movie,”The Help”. One similarity is the climax of both the movie and the book, when the book was being published and Minny,Skeeter, and Aibileen anxiously wait for the community’s reaction.Another similarity is how black maids work for white families in both the book and movie. Also in the book and movie the black maids were not allowed to use the same bathroom as the white families because white people didn’t want to use the same restroom as black
…show more content…
There is something I didn’t talk about yet and that is, the conflict and resolution in the book and movie, it stayed the same, Aibileen and Minny are two mistreated black women that are getting tired of the way white people talk to them and then they meet Skeeter and they work very hard to publish a book, which eventually does get published and the community took a little while, but they realized how awful the ladies had been treated, there were also a few funny stories in the published book that the public seemed to enjoy,black women finally had a voice. So overall, between the book and movie “The Help” there are more similarities than differences and even though the book and movie differ a little the same message is received by the reader and viewer, segregation isn’t

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A specific culture influences life by simply existing. The only way to change the way that a culture exists is to significantly influence the lives that hold to the culture. In the movie, Skeeter writes “The Help,” a story about the under-paid maids, in order to influence change among the folk that think black people lack legal rights to voice an opinion because of the skin that they wear. Aibileen’s best friend Minnie, who eventually contributes to the book through her story and “insurance,” helps ensure protection before the release of the cultural changing book. Despite her negativity, Miss Hilly Holbrook is a perfect example of an…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This movie takes place around the time of the Civil Rights Movement so racism is at its peak. Skeeter, is a white journalist that realizes the horrible racism that is going on around her and wants to bring it to the public. Skeeter was raised by a black maid herself and was one of the very few people during the 1960’s who realized the good that they do and the kind of people they are. Since Skeeter respected the colored people in her community she decided to go against her ethics, and her friends, by asking their maids to tell their stories about racism and their life. The women talked about how they couldn’t use the bathrooms of the families they worked for, or how the mothers of the children they watch do not care for their children in any way.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Minny works for Hilly 's mother but Hilly is sending her mother to a nursing home therefore Minny loses her job. When you watch the movie you see that Minny can’t find a job. She goes from place to place only to be rejected due to Hilly 's influence on all of the families with the bathroom project she made (where black people werent allowed to use the same bathrooms as white people but had to use outside bathrooms specifically made for them). When bathrooms were segregated, colored people had to use the bathrooms outside while the white families had one inside. When colored people were lowered to use outside utilities it showed that white people already had a higher privilege of using a inside home bathroom.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Following the life of two women, each with their own child, we find a mixed household of half black and half white. At the time this was a big step to have two families of different colors living together and treating each other as equals. However we do see concepts that we prevalent during the time come to light. Around this era America saw many advertisements and movies value blacks as less than whites, and the darker you were the less valuable you were. As explained by Gooden, many girls during this era would bleach their skin to become lighter colored just in order to be treated better than their dark-skinned family (Visual Representations of Feminine Beauty in the Black Press, Gooden).…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Help Movie Analysis

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 2011 the movie The Help was made and based off the best selling book of the same name. The book portrays how white women treat their black maids in 1960’s Mississippi. The life lessons one can obtain from this movie are moving and life changing. An insight one can gain from this film is that a person must always do what is right, even if it results in the person becoming a social pariah. The main character, Skeeter, exposes the racial injustice that southern women inflict upon their black maids.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She openly speaks against the new idea, even though it causes tensions in the group of women creating new problems. The mistreatment of the black maids that take care of the white families is hard for Skeeter because she was raised by a black maid, and thought of her as part of the family, so when other blacks get dehumanized, she feels like she had a duty to help them out. Another scene in The Help was Skeeter trying to get a job at a writing company. She gives the man her resumé who is very impressed that as a women, she has an education and all the work she has done. He makes a comment “Girl don’t you have fun?” she replies “Is that important?” (Taylor).…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As an activist toward civil right movement, she writes about the oppression of African American by speaking of the issue through her writing, like many great leaders. Maya word connects with her reader to understand whom word speaks to the people. Maya is writing give hope when those who suffer from mistreatment. In her autobiography I know why the caged bird sing she talk about anger of watching her grandmother staying silent to a disrespectful white girls As a child she couldn’t understand why black peoples were treated as second class citizen even if they hold higher standard in the community. She experiences first hand of seeing her grandmother who would punish her so quickly for disrespecting adult stay quiet toward “poor white kid” that display such poor manner toward her momma.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This even tempered, strong, black woman works in the home of another to provide for her ungrateful child. She serves with happiness and pride. In the fifties, job opportunities were slim for African Americans especially women. Housekeeping was one of the few jobs they could be trusted with. Annie took Miss Lora on as a friend and stayed with the family much longer than she ever had to creating a mixed race existence between a black woman and a white woman that was only seen in movies.…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This movie is an eyeopener to some of the profiling that Black people had to deal with. As I watched this film, it saddens me due to humans treating other humans like animals. The movie is narrated by a young woman that grew up in this era with such hate. Her name was “Skeeter”, she came from a rich prominent family that also had a black maid that raised her for most of her life. She never thought of this woman as the house’s help, for all she knew was that this…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many changes were made to the characters in their appearances as well as omissions and additions to the movie, some were noticeable as where others were fine-tuned. The story line remained the same yet some of the chronology has been switched around, the essence of the book remains wholly intact. In an effort to bring the book to film the most important chapters were recreated for the audience to finally see what they had visualized while reading. The level of harshness was not depicted in the film as many of the audience had experienced in reading the novel. Tate Taylor’s decision to make changes to the film was to avoid too much harsh criticism from the public.…

    • 1025 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays