Differences Between Homer And Hesiod And Homer's Theogony

Improved Essays
Women have had a long history of being inferior to men. The inequality of genders can be traced all the way back to Greek mythology. Both Hesiod’s Theogony and Homer’s Odyssey demonstrate the Greek’s early thoughts on this issue. Homer and Hesiod would agree that women are deplorable creatures and marriage usually leads to suffering. Hesiod spares no detail of his despise while describing the creation of women in Theogony. He claims that the sole reason for the female was to punish men. They are described more like an object that make men weak and useless rather than an actually human. Hesiod never describes a single positive aspect of a woman; instead he focuses on how they negatively affect men. He goes on to describe how women lazy, useless, …show more content…
At the orders of the son of Cronus, the famous lame smith-god [Hephaestus] shaped some clay in the image of a tender girl”. Nothing that harbor even a small amount of respect is described as a “plague”. Hesiod emphasizes this point again when he calls females “the damnable race of women-a plague which men must live with”. Both descriptions clearly show that women had a very low place in Greek society during the time Theogony was written. These same ideas are supported by Homer in the Odyssey. He also believes that women are nuisances to society and are only useful if they are in some way benefiting a man. Most of the women in the Odyssey are painted as either manipulative, untruthful, or unfaithful. By the end of his journey, Odysseus is under the impression that he should not even trust his wife Penelope even though she is the epitome of a perfect woman. The overall theme conveyed by Homer is that women are more trouble than they are worth, which is demonstrated continuously throughout the …show more content…
Because Agamemnon’s wife Clytemnestra plotted his death, she “has shamed not only herself/ But all women to come, even the rare good one”. This highlights how all females are seen as deceitful and troublesome, even if they have done nothing wrong. They are considered a burden to the success of a man above all else. In addition, they still serve to punish men. In conversation with Agamemnon, Odysseus proclaims, “Ah, how broad-browed Zeus has persecuted/ The house of Atreus from the beginning,/ Through the will of women”. Homer could not be more direct in showing his low thoughts of women than by making them a retribution from the gods. Hesiod is also very blunt about his thought on marriage in the Theogony. He makes it very clear that a man will most likely be unhappy whether he is married or not. If a man chooses not to suffer a marriage, then he will have no one to take care of him in his old age. On the other hand, if he does choose to get married, he will probably suffer. He will either have a bad wife, or she will give him bad children. There seems to be no way for a man to live comfortably when it comes to

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Upon reading The Epic of Gilgamesh and Antigone by Sophocles were able to draw a connection in the way both of these pieces view women in society. Both pieces show, women were once seen as frail beings that should stay in their places and be brought out just to please men. Fortunately, we as a society have come far in terms of women being viewed as more equal to men than in the late B.C. times but that does not mean women are finished gaining the same rights that men have. During The Epic of Gilgamesh , we can see that the place of women in society is seen as less than men 's but not completely viewed as a nonentity in ancient Mesopotamia. The civilization sees women 's place as just the bearers of life: we see that with the prostitute…

    • 1319 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the “Odyssey”, Homer portrays the women as temptress of men and are below them in the presented hierarchy of this tale. This is portrayed at the very beginning when Telmachus (Odysseus son) tells him mother Penelope “You should go back upstairs and take care of your work, Spinning and weaving, and have the maids do theirs. Speaking is for men, for all men, but for me especially, since I am the master of this house” (page 340). Homer has the women use their beauty and bodies to seduce the men in this tale. One example is when Odysseus’s men come to Circe’s house and are lured by a voice, she gives them food and drinks and a ‘potion of Pramnian wine”.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this chapter, Foley describes the ideas that other ancient Greek has about woman and how wrong those ideas were. He continues explaining that back in ancient Greek, people used to believe that men will always be superior to woman, and that the only role the woman had to fulfill was to take care of the men. Now he contrast those ideas with the role of women in The Odyssey; a clear example he gives is Circe and Calypso. Both of those goddess manage to control Odysseus while he was in their land. Odysseus was attracted by a unique virtue that only woman can have, beauty; it did not matter how strong or how smart Odysseus was, at the end he was captivated by the glorious looking those goddesses had.…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Homer’s Odyssey, Odysseus has several interactions with women on his journey back to Ithaca. No two women have the same exchange with Odysseus, but they all demonstrate different variations of the masculine-feminine relationship. Instead of the traditional masculine-feminine relationship, some women give Odysseus help instead, some don’t rely on depend on him entirely, but some however, swoon for him and give him her aid because of it. There is a strong masculine-feminine balance in the Odyssey, where the women are able to survive without depending on a man. The women all show individual versions of strength and all have contrasting relationships with Odysseus throughout his journey.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Ovid women are mistreated and abused, as well as in Hesoid’s Theogony. For women in both stories they were punished by mens arrogance and had very little value in the plays. Especially in Ovid’s Metamorphoses, as he talks about Jove(Jupiter) and how he is disrespectful and lustful towards women. Since he rapes them and treats women like pieces of meat, turning people into animals so he can hide his doings. As Ovid writes “ he changed Io into a heifer, white and shining lovely” (Humphries pg.22 610-611).…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Homer’s description of women in the Odyssey reveals the Greek’s notion of fear in women’s beauty and of the prevailing power of men over women. Throughout the plot female characters, namely Penelope, Circe, and the Sirens, are portrayed as dangers that men overcome and devices that emphasize men’s strength. In the Odyssey, beautiful women bring danger to men with their seductive powers. The Sirens, with their alluring voices, try to lure Odysseus and his men away from their journey (190) and toward their deaths.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Epic of Gilgamesh and Lysistrata are texts that depict the human relationships within their respective cultures in a manner that relates to today’s society. Although humankind has progressed in the past 5000 years, the issue of societal gender roles is still prevalent. In the two texts, gender roles are greatly impacted through sexual relationships. Although sex plays a major role in the establishment of gender roles in The Epic of Gilgamesh and Lysistrata, sex serves to establish male dominance among gods and women when used by men, while sex is used by women to defy their typical role in society in order to achieve a political goal.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Misogynistic views do not have one specific root and seem to have been prevalent for all traceable history. These harmful views lead to women being oppressed, which could range anywhere from sex slavery to slurs shouted in one’s face. Homer, writer of epic poem The Odyssey, is no different than many men today, when discussing oppressive views towards women. Such views range from an overall motif of misogyny, stemming from Homer’s own background views, which cause Odysseus to act hypocritically to the most important woman in his life.…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As a clever female character in the Odyssey, Penelope devises a cunning plan to trick the suitors. Antinous describes how she had proposed to marry one of the suitors after she finishes weaving the loom. He states that the suitors “were persuaded by this appeal to [their] honor” (Homer 18). Penelope’s claim that the robe would be for “the hero / Laertes” causes the men’s honor to prevail over their desire to wed Penelope and take over the great Odysseus’ house (Homer 18). Although these men are characterized as rude, obnoxious, and disrespectful, they are still honorable in the fact that they agree to this proposal since it is intended for the hero Laertes, father of the godlike Odysseus.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The actions of the Goddesses during war illustrate the different characteristics women possess in the world of The Iliad. Each goddess embodies different stereotypes of women during the Bronze Age. These stereotypes are even seen in today’s…

    • 1006 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the Epic of Gilgamesh prefers high ranking mortal women to other social and religious figures, as high ranking mortal women are seen as wise and well versed. Hesiod paints women as trouble makers or not important under most circumstances. However, both works give some importance to certain types of women. Antigone, a myth from the classical Athens era that introduces a woman challenging a man’s authority and creating controversy. The myth goes that Antigone’s two brothers died with battling each other.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the midst of all the chaos of being away from home, Odysseus comes across many complications, some of which include life or death interactions between himself and the legendary gods and goddesses of Greek culture. However, these interactions are not included within the epic simply to entertain the audience, rather, it is thought that Homer is attempting to make a point about how the women of his time in the eighth century were unfairly treated and discriminated against. To make his point, Homer wisely portrays the female characters of his poem in an admirable fashion; he makes sure to include how women can have wisdom, elegance, authority and several other traits of which only men were acknowledged to possess. It is because of Homer’s unique recognition to the fact that women should be treated as human individuales that his poem is being read by audiences around the world up to this…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Euripides sheds more light onto the condition of women and the injustices and disadvantages that women face, this time, regarding marriage. Of all the living creatures with a soul…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Greek Conceptions of Gender Gender inequality has been the major topic of discussion for many cultures right the way through history. Throughout Greek mythology, women are portrayed pessimistic and troublesome symbols, while men are known for being strong and controlling. Greek mythology has always been thought of as a patriarchal society and there are many reason as to why. Talking about Greek Goddesses we always think of a typical woman who is correlated with women’s roles, for example being a loyal wife, kind and caring towards her children and husband and be the idea women.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout The Odyssey, Homer enlightens us in the tribulations Odysseus faces as he fights to return home to his loving wife and son. He uses his mind and cunning abilities to outwit the creatures he encounters along the way. As we follow his travels, he faces many different types of women. Including Athena-the protector, Penelope-the loving wife, and Calypso-the devastatingly beautiful goddess-nymph.. These women are all so different, yet all so alike as well.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays