The Broken Home Theory

Improved Essays
In regards to the second example, Fagan & Churchill (2012) provide that children from broken homes display a low commitment towards marriage. In the context of divorce, however, the reverse is true. According to Fagan (1999) compared to girls, teenage boys are far less likely to marry as a result of being brought up in a broken home. Even if they did marry, they would still experience higher levels of marital instability that could ultimately fuel divorce (Fagan, 1999). The underlying reason, according to Fagan & Churchill (2012), is the inability for young adults raised in broken homes to commit to relationships that could potentially lead to marriage. This is reinforced by Fagan (2000) who states that young adults from broken homes find it …show more content…
According to Siegel & Welsh (2011), since 1950s, opponents of this theory have questioned the use of records obtained from police, courts, and correctional facilities to establish the connection between children from broken homes and delinquency. Siegel & Welsh (2011) argue that even though it is true that there exists a natural propensity for children from broken homes to be arrested, it does not necessarily imply that they engage in frequent delinquent behavior compared to their counterparts from intact families. To this effect, opponents argue that children from intact homes are just as likely to engage in delinquency as those from broken homes, and that the absence of parents weighs more on the behavior of agents of the criminal justice system, rather than the behavior of children from broken …show more content…
Ultimately, this analysis will endeavor to show that there is a continual cycle of negative behavior in children from broken homes that essentially negatively affects the structure of the family, and propagates a whole new generation of children from broken homes. In essence, this analysis will reinforce the arguments by proponents of the broken home theory. In the absence of parents, teenagers are likely to become exposed to and engaged in sexual behavior. As argued by Fagan (1999) and Fagan & Churchill (2012), this could ultimately lead to pregnancy and the birth of children outside marriage. Considering the fact that most children from broken homes have a low expectation of marriage, it is highly likely that their children will be raised either by a single parent, or through the welfare system. The meaning of this assertion is that the impact generated by children from broken homes dents the structural functionality of the family. It presents a situation whereby children become parents of children, and the behavioral pervasiveness extends from generation to generation. It is no wonder research provides that the face of the American family is

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Divorced Parents

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If the child witnesses the breakdown of trust between their own parents, they are more likely to not trust their significant other. Many young adults from divorced families report a universal belief that couples do not have what it takes to overcome marital conflicts. They are also more prone to repeating their parents’ mistakes and believing their future relationships are likely to fail (e.g., Wallerstein & Lewis, 2004) The children of failed marriages have increased rates of infidelity, moodiness, excessive drinking, conflicts over money, jealousy, and drug use. Some have even conducted studies on how boys and girls from divorced households act differently than one another in their relationships. Daughters of divorced parents are more likely to divorce more than sons of divorced parents do.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dysfunctional Families

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages

    According to the research, many social commentators argue that children perform best when raised in a home with married parents than when brought up by a single parent. However, unhappy, abusive, or unsupportive marriages are often more destructive to a child 's well-being than divorce. In fact, many children and adults, according to one study, perform better at school and at work once a dysfunctional marriage is dissolved. (Hetherington, "Dysfunctional Marriages Contribute to America 's Decline”). Public policies aimed at promoting marriage and discouraging divorce often fails to take these factors into account.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The smallest attributes of parents, such as, age at the time of their children’s birth has much to do with the way those children are raised. A parent’s attitude toward violence is another factor that can determine whether a family is abusive when it comes to confrontation or if they are understanding in verbally resolving the issue. Moreover, child maltreatment within a family has been opted to producing juvenile delinquents. Children who endure “physical, emotional, and sexual abuse/neglect are more likely to bear the brunt of the maltreatment,” whereas teens are more likely to take it out on themselves or feel harassed at all times (Bates & Swan, 2014). Most children today are living in a fluctuating degree of alternative family…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Broken Home Research Paper

    • 1048 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A person’s childhood is a very important and fragile time of every person life. Children shouldn’t be raise in certain conditions that may affect them later on in life. My hypothesis is that I believe children from broken homes get behavioral, academic and social problems because of their unhealthy relationship between them and their parents. I will be testing my hypothesis by naturalistic observation, giving out a questionnaire, and doing individual case studies on both children and parents. I would hope that my hypothesis will correlate to my results at the end of the experiments.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In high conflict marriages, the children tend to model parents behaviours, and fail to learn appropriate social skills and psychological effects. Study notes that young children exposed to violent or repetitive severe conflict experiences disturbances in affective regulation or emotional arousals (Kelly, 2000). With repeated exposure to severe conflict, there is negative cumulative effect on the psychological stress system that creates difficulties in emotional responses. It is also noted in this review that research indicate parents in intense marital conflict tend to be distant and less warm and empathetic with their children using more quilt or anxiety inducing disciplinary techniques which are associated poorer social awareness and social withdrawal in the child. Childs interaction with the father could also suffer as mothers tend to act as gatekeeper in during and post marriage (Kelly, 2000).…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Single Parenthood

    • 1547 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In most cases the absence of the right paternal figure affects children tremendously. Anne E. Barrett and R Jay Turner explain in their journal, Family structure and mental Health: The Mediating Effects on Socioeconomic Status, Family Process, and Social Stress, a child is more likely to suffer mental health risk when exposed to single parenthood and poverty. However, when one of these single mothers gets married is expected a paternal figure would be present for those children. Supposedly children’s behavior would improve just as their grades in school and depression would improve notoriously. However, studies prove that is not the most common case scenario that children from single-parenthood have.…

    • 1547 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With their mother or father seeing someone else, it might be harder for the child to come to grips with the divorce, especially if there are other children involved. New families also mean new rules and new rhythms to adopt. Some children are affected negatively and are unable to get the help and support they deserve. It has been shown in studies that divorce has strong negative effects on children such as heightened levels of depression, suicide, delinquency, and a negative effect on school performance. Children have also been shown to have lower self-esteem, more feelings of loss, and severe fears of abandonment.…

    • 1951 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Relocation, new family structures, and change in income are some key factors that can change for children who are impacted by parental divorce (Bing, 2009). These factors can cause lasting serious effects on the children involved. This may be due to the weak sense of self-control that is brought on by the environment of divorce for the children (Utz, 2012). These broad changes that are brought upon the children of parental divorce can have an influence on the child’s perception of divorce. Some of these lasting effects include changes in their relationship with their parents.…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Certain children will have destructive ways to handle conflict, which could result in criminal acts by the child. Fagan also mentioned, “For instance, compared to students from intact families, college students from divorced families use violence more frequently to resolve conflict, and are more likely to be aggressive and physically violent with their friends, male or female.” (“The Effects of Divorce on Children”) Children growing up in broken homes may know no other way to deal with conflict. If the child continues violent patterns into adulthood, it is no doubt the child will end up back into the criminal justice system as an adult. Without guidance or control form the parental aspect, it is hard for the child to behave properly when…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Amato and Keith (1991) reports that children of divorce have more difficulty than children in intact families adjusting both socially and psychologically. Surveys show that children of divorce are more likely to exhibit behavior that is antisocial, impulsive, or acting out” (Gruber 805). With a child having issues with communication and being impulsive it can make it hard for them to make friends. This could cause depression and the feeling of being alone. These challenges can be avoided by a stable household and both parents raising the…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays