Pros And Cons Of Criminal Profiling

Improved Essays
Criminal Profiling: More than Movie Magic
Aspects like age, marital status, ethnicity, and identifying characteristics are what define a typical criminal profile and are crucial in catching serial criminals. Criminal Profiling has made a debut in the media with shows like Criminal Minds and novels like Sherlock Holmes, but the science behind profiling is often left to the imagination to create the idea of a profiler as a magical and all-knowing being, when in reality they are highly trained individuals with great attention to detail. Due to the relative newness of the field, many people are skeptical and profilers have been under scrutiny by the general public as well as law enforcement for years, which left them with a fortuneteller-like reputation.
…show more content…
Most commonly used and preferred by the FBI is the CSA method which takes details about the crime scene and turns them into personality trait of the perpetrator. For example; a victim with excessive amounts of assault or mutilation points to an attacker who may have a compromised mental status or could be in a rage fueled rampage and with this information, law enforcement can narrow down a suspect pool to those who have anger issues or a history of severe mental illness. There will always be exceptions to the rules but in most cases, the crime scene does not lie. Forensic Psychologist Richard Kocsis states in his article on the history of profiling, “human behavior is in some capacity a reflection of personality.” (“Criminal”). What the suspect leaves behind or purposely doesn’t leave behind, tells law enforcement a lot about their distinct personality. For example: crime scenes that are disorganized with evidence left behind may mean that they’re psychotic and unintelligent while organized scenes point to a more intelligent offender who has carefully plotted his attacks and taken care of evidence. Knowing background information may seem like a secondary priority but in cases where the suspect left little to no evidence, behavioral clues is vital for their

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Homicide In Psychology

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages

    is a particular way or method a criminal commits a crime; it is the resulting correlation that connects cases, and the learned behavior that is dynamic and malleable. When linking murders together, the M.O. is a critical step in crime scene analysis due to the similarities the offender leaves in each scene or on the victim. Secondly, there is Personation or otherwise known as a signature, it is the unusual behavior done by the serial killer that is unnecessary to commit the crime. Furthermore, the serial killer’s signature behavior may reveal their psychological or emotional needs, and a reflection of an underlying personality, lifestyle and developmental experiences.…

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The theory also has logical constancy as it is rational in explaining why disciple mass murder committed the crime and why they chose a particular victim. This theory can be testable, by testing each element individually. First, you would research past disciple killers and interview them about their motivations to see if they committed. Additionally, it can utilize these same methods to see why individuals joined groups or followed disciples.Additionally, you can implement target hardening policy to notice if having capable guardians in certain areas reduces crime as well as studying the victimology of similar offenders. This theory lacks empirical validity as these elements have not been researched together.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The other difficulty in criminal profiling is the ability to link the evidence at the crime scene to an accurate profile without guessing or making assumptions (Miller, 2011). When creating an offender profile, personality and behavioral traits are the key factors; however, a person experiences many forms of moods and this probes the validity and reliability of using the two factors. Moreover, different persons have varied personalities depending on the circumstances they…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Criminal Profiling is a technique whereby the probable characteristics of a criminal offender or offenders are predicted based on the behaviors exhibited in the commission of a crime. The job of a criminal profiler is very crucial in homicide cases. It helps the law enforcement to find and arrest the killer by knowing little details that determine possible suspects for the crime. Criminal profilers investigating serial killers have always tried to formulate some idea of the characteristics of unknown culprits as an aid to finding and convicting them. This is not an easy task.…

    • 1603 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Profiling simply defines the use of information from the crime scene to describe the offender’s behaviour while committing the act of crime. (Criminal Psychology: A Beginner’s Guide, p. 6 to 7) Criminal profiling or offender profiling is one of the used techniques in identifying a criminal in several cases besides scouring for physical evidences like blood, murder weapons, and many more. It has already been used in various scenarios when it comes to solving cases pertaining to rape, murder, kidnapping, etc. It is commonly used in narrowing the number of suspects in an investigation, and to also evaluate suspects using psychological means which is profiling. However, it does not identify the main culprit, but on the bright side, it’ll most likely be able to identify the personality and behavioural characteristics the perpetrator possesses.…

    • 2474 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Such evidence includes figure prints, hair, and other forms of DNA. They use this evidence in help to create a psychological profile of the criminal. Criminal profilers would also often time interview serial killers in jail to find other unique patterns between different serial killers. The more criminals criminal profilers study, the more easy it will be to find patterns between serial killers, robbers, and serial rapists will be. One of the many different areas criminal profiling covers includes not just the criminal but also the victim in victimology.…

    • 1697 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: Offender profiling can be defined as making predictions about offender’s characteristics from the way they behaved during a crime (Davies & Beech, 2012). Offender profiling can play an important part in criminal investigations, especially when there is no DNA left at crime scenes. It requires using other types of evidence such as characteristics of the crime scene and eye-witness testimonies from victims and witnesses. Profiling techniques can be unified with police forces to help elicit and prioritise suspects and may predict what an offender may do next (Canter & Youngs, 2009). However, it’s important to assess the reliability of such psychological procedures as they are frequently applied to serious and violent forms of crime…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another high-risk area of police work in terms of a potential for corruption is the use of informants. Police officers who handle informants are exposed to offenders far more frequently and in a less controlled environment. While guidelines that advise on the way that informers should be manages might be issued, however the concerned procedures do not address the ethical dilemmas that can arise. Sometimes, individuals may also be tempted to engage in corrupt behavior indirectly through the knowledge that such behavior is often difficult to investigate and detect. Further, where investigations are successful in uncovering incidents of corruption, there are still further problems in providing and punishing such behavior (Porter,…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Brutality And Crime

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Third theory: which can measure the level of brutality or violence associated with a crime as well as explanation of behaviour associated with the different levels. Till now brutality/violence associated with a crime seems to be only due to psychological factor. We don’t have any theory to explain why the level of brutality vary in different crime. Social scientists have integrated violence with the psychopath but they have not explained the cause of varying level of brutality. Further studies and rigorous research method are required if we want to cover each and every aspect of criminal…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Orange was a sort of police informant. Police informants typically are someone who can be trusted by the criminal and by the police, relaying information to the authorities. Sometimes, however, they can be police officers themselves trying to catch the criminal without the worry of the informant getting spooked and halting the flow of information. He posed as a criminal in order to get inside the ring to which he was able to gather information and tell the rest of the police. This is true there are police officers that pretend to be a criminal in order to catch one such as Sam Panchal and Bobby Hom in the book Bravehearts by Cynthia Brown.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays