The CSI Effect

Improved Essays
There are a wide variety of creative and interesting crime shows on television today that a great deal of today’s society follow. Shows such as CSI, Law and Order, Forensic Files, and NCIS are becoming increasingly popular and the way the shows are scripted makes for compelling television. While these shows are indeed interesting, they are giving viewers a false sense of knowledge when it comes to the real world of forensic science and the criminal justice system as a whole. The “CSI Effect” is causing everyday jurors to feel more confident in decision making when it comes to cases they are trying which is causing them to need more evidence to convict even for the simplest of crimes.
The “CSI Effect” is “the phenomenon in which jurors hold
…show more content…
Although it would seem that this might not have any consequences because it is making jurors more cautious when convicting, it is, in fact, making jurors too cautious and causing an expectation of scientific evidence in every case which is resulting in defendants being “wrongfully” acquitted (Barak …show more content…
The results of the study were that “almost half of the surveyed jurors expected the prosecutor to present scientific evidence of some kind in every criminal case. They found that as the seriousness of the charge increases, so does the expectation for scientific evidence. Almost three-quarters of the jurors expected scientific evidence of some kind in cases of murder, attempted murder, or rape. Even in the less serious cases of breaking and entering or theft, a significant number of jurors expected some scientific evidence. Specifically as to DNA evidence, the jurors in the Shelton, Kim, and Barak study had high expectations in the more serious cases, with almost half expecting DNA evidence in murder or attempted murder cases and almost three-quarters expecting DNA evidence in cases charging rape or other criminal sexual conduct” (Barak 153). This study found that frequent watchers of these forensic type shows had higher expectations than those who did not watch

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    CSI Effect

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It raises the bar high. When you watch the show CSI it makes you think and wonder, wow, if they can solve a crime and make it seem so simple, then why do it seems so hard for a lot of crimes to be solved in the real world today? People will develop high expectations and expect more from forensic technology. It also can place the ones committing crimes at a vulnerable state and make them more willing to commit a crime thinking they can get away with it. Just like the show Snap, I personally think that it can set up a person’s motive of wanting to commit a crime by showing them how they solve the crime may make the criminal think of tactics to get away with committing a crime.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    DNA In Forensics

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For example, cases where DNA is used as evidence to help convict the suspect; there are higher chances that the suspect will be convicted at a trial level compared to cases where there are different witnesses involved in providing evidence for the case (Smith & Mann, 2015). Comparing the use of DNA in criminal justice system and use of witnesses to provide evidence indicates that most cases that are free from biases depend on DNA forensics findings to determine the truth in the…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Their audience is rapidly increasing. Reality shows often generate negative publicity towards police officers. Reality based television shows create fear among the general public. People who tend to watch police based reality shows tend to be more violent than people who does not watch police based reality shows. According to Curry (2001), "Reality-based policing shows such as COPS also provide the public with a look at the life of a police officer as well as the TV show, Disorderly Conduct Video On Patrol ' '.…

    • 1857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crime Shows

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Factual accounts are recapped by the actual law enforcement professionals involved in the case investigation and individuals close to the case. Crime scene dramas such CSI, on the other hand, are scripted and fictional often depicting true crimes taken straight from today’s headlines (Parker, 2013). They draw millions of loyal viewers each week to prime time television prompting networks to create new shows based on their popularity. But research shows that in order to keep large audiences, crime scene dramas exaggerate certain aspects of legal procedures (Parker, 2013). False or embellished presentations of crimes have given viewers an inadequate picture of the American legal system in respect to suspect treatment, the case building process, and trial length (Parker, 2013).…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    CSI Effect On Crime

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The correlation between the standard of proof associated with the CSI effect and the general opinions of the public at large can be stated that there is a rising interest in criminal forensics and even the belief that crime is prevalent. When individuals are flooded with events from the news and entertainment shows about murders and other such crimes it is easy to see how peoples belief systems…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If defendants were forced to testify they wouldn’t only have access to answering the questions from the defense attorney, possibly explaining the evidence against them, but they’d also be vulnerable to the cross-examination of the prosecution. The prosecution is supposedly supposed to uphold justice, meaning if they don’t have a strong enough case to convince the jury beyond a reasonable doubt of the defendant’s guilt, then they should drop the charges. However, we can imagine that that rarely happens, even if the defendant is innocent. Therefore, if an innocent defendant is being cross examined, the prosecution should be convinced of their guilt, otherwise, they should have dropped the charges. It’s also important to note that an overwhelming majority, almost two-thirds, of those convicted of crimes haven’t graduated high school.…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The findings supported the arguments that people do and the sad truth is, the Reid technique facilitates most of these confessions (Malloy, Shulman & Cauffman, 2014). People under age 25 are more likely to be pressured into making a false confession that links them to a violent criminal activity (Malloy, Shulman & Cauffman, 2014). The innocence project found that in the last 25 years 38% of young people age 18 and under were later exonerated through DNA evidence after being convicted on false testimonies (Rubin, 2014). Juveniles make up a significant number of vulnerable population in society (Rubin, 2014). Therefore, they are susceptible to pressure as they do not understand their rights and how the criminal justice system works (Rubin,…

    • 1978 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The technology of DNA is mainly used by police, prosecutors, defense counsels, and courts throughout the United States and it has been accepted more through society in the past decade. With forensic scientist and the improvement of DNA profiling has enhanced the way that law enforcement apprehends criminals. Before this process of DNA profiling, law enforcement had to only fingerprints and circumstantial evidence to convict. With the use of DNA profiling gives detectives and other law enforcement solid proof to use in convicting and allowing the case that is trying to make a strong and solid case. Using…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In most countries where it is still carried out, it is mostly carried out the punishment for murder. In other countries, however, it extends to culprits found guilty of treason, rape, fraud and adultery. According to data from a 2008 survey by Amnesty International, China had the most executions annually at that time, followed by Iran, the USA and Saudi Arabia respectively. Just like abortion and homosexuality, capital punishment…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theories Of Moral Panic

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The moral panic were starting to be about the fact the moral panic has gotten to be so popular that the real issue was often pushed to the side(Jewkes, 2015. p. 103). Another criticism was the narrative of crime is at an all time high or that is it a untrue story line being manufactured by the new companies (Jewkes, 2015. p104). If the crime rates are going up in another area of the world and there is lots of war and violence going on, and that is all the new companies are reporting, it creates a very violent picture of the world. Which creates a wrongful image to the audience of the world being a very violent place leading them to believe that were they live locally the crime and violence is a huge problem (Jewkes, 2015. p.104). Moral panics have helped contribute to the cultural wars in society, because of the influential power that the news companies have over its viewers.…

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays