Comparison Of Henrietta 'And' Troug's Cells

Improved Essays
The article and the book both have some close similarities and some differences between one another. A similarity is the fact that the in the book not only did the Lacks family not get paid, but also John Moore lost a court case and never got paid either. Moore’s doctor was using the cells in a similar manner as Henrietta’s and Troug’s patient cells were used. In all three of these cases not a single patient was compensated for donating their cells. The difference between the article and the book is how in the book both Henrietta’s cells and Moore’s cells were being used secretly to conduct the research. In Tim Ulrich’s article the patient is fully aware that their cells would be used for research purposes because there are laws in place for

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In 1951, it was not illegal to use human tissue cells for research without consent but, publically identifying Mrs. Lacks as the HeLa line source was. Therefore, Mrs. Lacks identifiable health information was transmitted to the world. Today, this breach of privacy is known as a HIPPA violation, The Health Insurance Portability Privacy Act.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pervading the story of Henrietta Lacks and her “immortal cells” was the idea that doctors should be required to obtain informed consent from their patients before conducting any extensive research that could affect the patient. Aside from the HeLa case itself, another situation mentioned in the book was Mo versus Golde, a case where a doctor- David Golde- patented and profited off of the cells of one of his patients- John Moore. Doctor David Golde should have been prosecuted for taking and profiting off of John Moore’s cells without his informed consent. The main and most important reason that John Moore should have received some sort of compensation through the suing of David Golde is that informed consent- keyword: “informed”- was legally…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Historically slavery and segregation systematically design to oppress a person or race, specifically African Americans. In the mist of laws of segregation, it enforced experimentation, unjust condition, and poverty inflicted on the specific community of the African American. In 1950,’s an African American woman led and transformed scientific breakthrough of the 21st century. Although, Henrietta Lacks provided the ultimate sacrifice, she lived on through cells (HeLa). HeLa cells enable unbelievable discoveries from treatment to cures of various…

    • 78 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Benefits

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The question is simple. Is the person’s personal rights over their tissue more important than contributing to science and research to benefit the common good? I believe that a person’s rights to his or her own body is more important. Scientists seem to exploit people for samples of cells only to make a profit.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He talks not only about the cells, but all the wide range of topics she poses through the Lack’s story. “It is also about a wide range of topics, including bioethics, race in America, social class divisions, poverty, public understanding…” (Gifford) Gifford uses the story as a means to point out the issue that even 60 years later, Henrietta’s decedents still can’t afford medical care. He tells of how the biggest benefits they have received from her cells are free tuition and books, through the Henrietta Lacks Foundation founded by Skloot. This really shows how little the family was cared about, even though Henrietta cells were so important to science. He also points out how until Rebecca published this book, nobody had told or cared about the real human faces associated with HeLa.…

    • 2273 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being overly dedicated to their work caused Grey Tilinde ,the man who organized the cell extraction procedures, to never introspect on Henrietta’s identity or what her opinion of the experiments would have been had she ever known about them. Instead they viewed the women as an end-supply of easily attainable test subjects. “…as Howard Jones once wrote ‘Hopkins, with its large indigent black population had no dearth of clinic material.’” This kind of attitude…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poverty played a huge role in the Lacks family. Due to poverty, the majority of the Lacks family was uneducated, so for many years, the family was unable to take justice upon the people who decided to take Henrietta's cells without permission and turning it into a profitable business; since they knew very little about what was actually going on and what the HeLa cells meant for the rest of the world. Further expanding on the idea that since Henrietta's family was not educated enough due to poverty, they could never grasp the concept of what Henrietta's cells actually meant and the value associated with them. For a while, the family didn't even know Henrietta's cells where being used in the first place. They had no idea Henrietta's cells where being used almost worldwide in various studies and making millions in profit.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The actions that were taken didn't just affect Henrietta but her family as well especially her daughter Deborah. Henrietta's family didn't even find out about her cells till a few years later and they don't even have medical insurance, many said they should-be been given credit; "patients and, when appropriate, their families are informed about the outcomes of care, treatment, and services that have been provided including unanticipated outcomes. " Plus, they misdiagnosed her cancer since it was much more severe than…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks Elie Wiesel is quoted saying, “We must not see any person as an abstraction. Instead, we must see in every person a universe with its own secrets, with its own treasures, with its own sources of anguish, and with some measure of triumph.” The story of Henrietta Lacks, or “HeLa” as she is most commonly known, is a story of how one woman changed history so much and yet she has very little recognition. The reason Henrietta Lacks is not a household name is because the mainstream media and the scientific community overall does not know the person behind the cells, they only know what her cells have done to benefit them. Elie Wiesel mentions in the first part of his quote, “We must not see any person as…

    • 1672 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The intern sighed as she threw away, yet again the remains of a manipulated human embryo into the receptacle. As the intern began to clean the petri dish that once held such a small but significant life, she wondered how the rest of the scientists took killing an innocent life so lightly. Stem cell research is beneficial because it helps to further the research towards the cure of diabetes, cancer, other various diseases and illnesses, and the advancement in the growth of such stem cells also helps further the research in organ growth. However, some ways the scientists conduct and carry out stem cell research is neither morally correct nor practical. Stem cell research helps further the advancement in the curing of diseases such as diabetes…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The depth of the social and ethical issues involved need extensive legal and political resolutions of how this experiments (for now) may not turn into an industry that may endanger human rights. Here in this article": The Ethics of Embryonic Stem Cells-Now and Forever, Cells Without End by Juengst E. and Fossel M. (Dec. 27, 2000): "The ethical issues are not primarily matters of scientific fact nor of political belief. Consequently, these issues cannot adequately be addressed simply by reference to the biology of embryonic stem cells or the contemporary political context of stem cell research. To successfully make the case for developing the therapeutic potential of human embryonic stem cells, the biomedical community must engage these issues as genuine questions of morality and social policy. Just as an accurate understanding of stem cell biology is crucial to sound policy making, an accurate appraisal of the substantive and inseparable ethical issues is equally crucial.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When viewed like this, using stem cells for research is equivalent to murder. The chapter also presents another issue that relates to this case presentation regarding funding by the federal government. If someone believes that something is unethical and morally unacceptable, should their tax dollars be used to fund it? The final major objection to stem cell research that was presented in Chapter 6 said that an embryo would grow into an autonomous human being in the future. By using the embryo as mere research, it takes away the embryo’s ability to have a productive future.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Had the information been given to the Lacks family from the start, many of the problems that arose could have been avoided entirely. Another way their level of education was used against them was when the HeLa cells began to be available worldwide. The Lacks family did not understand what was happening, and they believed that Henrietta herself was still alive. Neither the scientific community nor the media chose to inform them of the truth, and they got away with it because the Lacks family lacked the education to fully grasp what was happening with Henrietta’s cells around the world. In the end, their lack of education did not stop Deborah from pursuing, and eventually finding, the information she wanted to find about both her mother and her sister,…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book had a ten paged chapter including extensive medical records from Henrietta that the Lacks family had never seen or given permission to publish. The question arises was this situation and invasion of privacy as Henrietta’s medical records were released to the public, and does it make a difference that she has been dead for over thirty years? Because Henrietta’s case took place in the 1950’s, there were no laws to restrict publishers from using medical information that was given to them from a source (Skloot, 211). Gold claimed that Howard had given him the details but he was not entirely sure, he just knows that he talked to hima good amount. The disclosure of medical records by the reporter was questionable as it was common for the reporter to contact the family and ask questions, verify all of the facts, and inform them of the info that is going to be published.…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Henrietta Lacks is a poor, middle school dropout, mother of five, African American woman who is forced to drive miles upon miles to get to Hopkins Hospital that provided free medical treatment (Skloot 33). During this point in history, all hospitals were segregated, and if any blacks wanted medical treatment they had to travel further for treatment. Also, African Americans were put in a bad economic spot, and most did not have the money for adequate health care. Therefore, Lacks did not have any other options other than to go to Hopkins, where they treated her poorly by taking a sample of her cervix without asking if this was acceptable (Skloot 33). Because Lacks was uneducated, the doctors did not feel the need to ask for permission because they did not believe she would understand what they were looking for or why they would do it.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays