Comparing Two Criticisms Of The Utilitarian Approach

I think a utilitarian would agree with both scenario’s and they would more likely say that in order to benefit the happiness of the others (who could die in the bombing), the right thing to do would be to torture the suspect just like in the Waterboarding scene from Zero Dark Thirty in order to save the life of all the people that live in a major American city. Two criticisms of the utilitarian approach would be that torture that man for just being a suspect is wrong and is violating his human rights, and the fact the suspect is just getting punished for something he or she might have not been a part of the bombing, but if so then they are not getting serve proper justice.
A utilitarian would respond to the criticisms above by stating that