Comparing Martin Luther King And Malcolm X

Improved Essays
Martin Luther King and Malcolm are well-known African -American figures who shaped the African- American identity and culture. They both had two distinct politics, that had both similarities and differences.
Martin Luther King was born in a very well educated, middle class family, never suffering from hunger or poverty while Malcolm X didn’t grow up with a proper education, his family abused him, making the home atmosphere the same violent as the outside one. Luther King was a Christian and followed Christian rules and principles, promoting peace and understating. Malcolm was a Muslim and followed Muslim principles, using the strategy of violent behavior. He was known among people as a” black Klu Klux Klan” of race discrimination.
It is
…show more content…
He attacked all white people and reckoned that it was their fault in all the problems of the society such as crimes, poverty, etc. He critiqued Martin’s nonviolent norms and gave, as he considered, nonviolent speeches, making them sound rousing. Only later, after visiting Jerusalem, his points of view changed and he was sure that the government had to protect black people because it if didn’t, they would not be able to do it themselves.
Malcolm respected all people and guessed that the only way for black people to be free is to leave the society of white people.
In order to achieve this aim, Malcolm wanted black people to greet, at first, each other with respect and pride, but only secondly, greet white people in the same way Only after gaining self-esteem, respect and pride achieving equality among various racial groups.
Thus, Both Martin Luther King and Malcolm had very different ideas about the idealized society. Martin imagines a Dream that could be promoted in the south whule Malcolm idealized a nightmare in the north.
As for me, I would join Martin Luther King because he to build an integrated society of both black and white people I don’t agree that black separatism of Malcolm practice will lead to anything good in the African-American

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Malcolm X and Dr. King were different in style but, they had similar goals. Dr. King was a christian and he was preacher. Malcolm was a radical Islamic leader from Harlem, who meant well for his fellow blacks. Dr. King preached for civil rights and racial equality from the church. Malcolm used his Islamic sermons in temples to address similar problems in the black…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Malcolm X is certainly one of the most controversial figures to be engaged in any movement for Civil rights. In large part, the discord and confusion about what he advocated can be attributed to the fact that he was a contemporary of Martin Luther King. In the study of the Civil Rights Movement, Martin Luther King tends to overshadow any other Civil Rights leaders during the time and his teaching non-violent resistance and civil disobedience is considered the gold standard for what social progress should be. For this reason, it is helpful to talk about the ideas of Malcolm X in conjunction to King’s ideas. Malcolm X’s rhetoric is viewed as especially extreme when standing next to King’s rhetoric, yet ultimately, these two men longed for…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Being the son (and grandson) of a respected minister, Martin had an "easy" childhood compared to most blacks during this time period. It was declared that he was well loved by his family and the community, and experienced little to no direct prejudice or racism during his childhood. I believe that the events that lead up to adulthood create and mold an individual in their beliefs and actions as a human. When comparing the two childhoods of King and Malcolm X, one can see the reason for these two individuals to take such different approaches to the same issue. Malcolm 's childhood was not as easy as that of the beloved minister 's son. At the age of three his house was burned in Omaha and at the age of six his father was killed by a streetcar in Lansing, which had suspicions leading to white supremacists for being the ones involved with the murder. Later in his life while attending school he was asked by his teacher what he wanted to be when he was older. When he replied that he had intentions to be a lawyer, the teacher simply laughed at him and said that it wasn 't a realistic goal for a "nigger". After his mother was checked into an insane asylum, he was moved around to foster homes, and eventually lived with his aunt in Boston where he led a life of crime. The drastic differences in these leader 's upbringings can account for why they said and did as they did. The single most important aspect of…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Martin Luther King Jr. was a famous civil rights activist who used the nonviolence theory to get equality. He had made a great contribution in helping African American strive for quality and made them realize the importance of achieving the real equality. At the same time, Malcolm X also was a civil rights activist who advocated the way of violence to improve the position of the black people. Although Malcolm X had more militant perspectives about how to promote the black power than Martin Luther King Jr., both of them had made a huge influence on promoted the African American to achieve more rights and equality position in the United States. The connection between nonviolence and violence is important in the Civil Rights Movements. I will deeply explore what Martin Luther King Jr and Malcolm X did in the Civil Rights Movements and their influence for African Americans and the whole…

    • 2074 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    preached nonviolence to achieve his civil rights agenda, Malcolm X gave a voice to the rage of millions of black Americans. Malcolm X emerged as an alternative voice to Dr. King and grew the Nation of Islam from 400 members to 4,000 from his time in prison to 1952, a testament to the success of his charisma and gift as an orator (Biography para. 10). Although not largely successful in cementing public policy change while publicly denounced by Dr. King, Malcolm X was influential as a leading voice of the radical wing of the Civil Rights Movement. Because of his aversion to nonviolent revolution, I believe that his legacy is not as realized in American politics to the same extent as Martin Luther King…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mlk Vs Malcolm X Essay

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were two of the most influential civil rights activist. Both civil rights leaders shared many similarities and differences in their philosophies, speeches and how they were received by society. Both Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. philosophies differed but both impacted the public. MLK’s “I Have a Dream” and X’s “The Ballot or the Bullet” speeches gave the audience two different ways of viewing the Civil Rights Movement. Lastly, the way African Americans and Caucasians viewed the leaders were similar yet different.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    One of the most fundamental similarities between these two men, though, was their pursuit of freedom for their people. While both Dr. King and Malcolm X viewed freedom differently, they both alleged their form was the best option, and this belief was combined with their unwavering awareness of racial tension, which both men had from young ages. This search for freedom, for liberation from white supremacy, pushed them to become activists in their communities. They both knew since childhood the way blacks were treated was different and, most importantly, cruel and discriminating. Over time, this awareness led to anger and resentment, which eventually morphed into the ideology they had as adults and as Civil Rights leaders. Their passion, their…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. had different beliefs that radiated from their childhood and the values that were taught to them . Malcolm X was born into a christian family that resided in Lansing, Michigan. Malcolm’s childhood had started out rough with the death of his father when he was only six years old and his mother being placed in a mental hospital when he was thirteen. Malcolm’s father passing away soon caused him to drift away from his religious side of life. Soon after, Malcolm had started to engage in immoral and unethical activities in life. He started to gamble, deal drugs, and commit robberies. At first Malcolm’s impetuous lifestyle wasn’t affecting him much yet it soon did, in 1946 Malcolm X was arrested for larceny and…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X sustained the ideas of equality from the Bible. They both stressed that any person should refer to God at first, in order to find the right way for oneself. As it was said before, both of them were the leaders who spoke about the ideas of equality and ending the discrimination towards Afro-Americans. As a reason, Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were both threatened by the government for the ideas they supported. In their speeches, they used to talk a lot about dying for the concepts, they maintained. Furthermore, Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X claimed that Blacks should develop their businesses in order to reach the economic independence and be respected among white businessmen. Moreover, both of these leaders talked a lot about the offensive exploiting of the Afro-Americans and described this as a way of the government to become…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Malcolm X Dbq

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Malcolm X explicitly believed that African Americans and white people should continue to remain segregated while obtaining a more equal status to one another. He told the public “work in conjunction with us-each of us working among our own kind” and then further explained that “working separately, the sincere white people and sincere black people actually will be working together.” (Document C). In comparison, Martin Luther King Jr. persistently homilized parity and integration. He encouraged the races to work together to achieve these civil goals. According to some of his famous words, “we will be able to work together, to pray together, to struggle together, to go to jail together, to climb up for freedom together, knowing that we will be free one day.” (Document B). Based off of this logic, Malcolm X was not only holding America back, but he was actually pushing America further away from the solution. At the time when integration of schools was already set into motion, he was proposing the establishment of all-black institutes within the black communities to provide African American children with a fair education (Document…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He wanted all African Americans to be free from slavery and when the Civil War started he was right there in the midst of the war not as a soldier but as a recruiter to enlist more African Americans for the war, his evolvement during the war was key for the north winning the civil war. Also Malcolm X “was a black leader who, as a key spokesman for the Nation of Islam, epitomized the ‘Black Power’ philosophy.(“Malcolm Little)” His approach was unorthodox and got the attention of many African American, especially the ones that were growing restless with the peaceful movement that were growing restless with the peaceful movement that Dr. Martin Luther King jr was leading. Both men were and still are important figures not only to the African American community but to America in…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Malcolm X Dbq Analysis

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages

    both had different ideas about how to deal with two other major difficulties in the lives of African Americans. African Americans faced de facto segregation in the north and de jure segregation in the south. In response, King focused on pushing for an end to segregation in an effort to allow for integrated facilities, such as schools (Document 4). In contrast, X felt that it was necessary to being to explore alternative options for African Americans so they would be able to have places of their own to learn (Document 5). X’s idea would have helped African Americans to be able to become educated in an environment that is less pressured than some of the schools in the south, which made it a necessity to use the army to escort African Americans to school. Also, during the 1960s, African Americans struggled to find employment to be economically self-reliant. While Martin Luther King advocated for boycotts of businesses that did not support African Americans (Document 6), Malcolm X took his ideas a step further. X advocated for individuals to patronize their local businesses to improve the quality of their own neighborhoods (Document 7). This thinking would help to grow African American communities and help to bring them to be closer to economic…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While both King and Malcolm X showed leadership, logic, intelligence and clear thinking, they both seemed to see different solutions to the problems that black people faced at that…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both MLK and Malcolm X were eminent leaders in the Civil Rights movement, led the movement to address the oppression and racial segregation and discrimination against African Americans in United States. Both of the leaders aspired for equal opportunities and decent respectable life for Afro-Americans along with whites. Their styles of leadership was shaped according to their socio-cultural circumstances and conditions of their upbringing in their life. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was a more effective leader and became popular compared to Malcom X in many aspects of his leadership approach.…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have chosen to examine both theorists Martin Luther King Jr, and Malcom X in my proposal. The reason for choosing Dr. King and Malcolm X is that they were both famous African Americans in the 1960s. These two individuals grew to be famous in their own right. Today many people throughout the United States continue to read their writings, and magazine articles. Dr. King was a peaceful man who came from a middle-class family and where education was important. Malcolm X came from an underprivileged home, where he self-taught himself most everything that he has learned and achieve greatness through his own intelligence. As Civil Rights activist, they both fought to see a world free of segregation. However, their views on how to accomplish their…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays