Are Pastoral Nomads Less Civilized?

Decent Essays
John Green argued that we think that pastoral nomads are ‘less civilized’ than settled peoples because they did not have great agricultural land and they were not state-liked societies. In order to be a state society, there are some rules that had to be followed. First, the power of the state mainly depended on the army and taxes. Before the state could raise taxes or create a powerful army, there would have to be a sedentary, or stationary population. This is very important because… Also, it is very important for foods to be produced in state societies because it is valuable to them to feed their people and army. Lastly, agricultural production and creation of states are closely connected, so the pastoral nomads, who lives in the hills, had

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Jared Diamond, a geography professor and the author of Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies, was asked a question posed by a native, Yali, to the island of New Guinea. Why do some people have “cargo”, meaning material goods and other useful items, but others did not? This simple question had such complex possible answers and Diamond attempted to create his own. According to Diamond the environment where societies initially started evolving was the main factor that decided whether a society would become more advanced than other societies because aspects of the environment such as arability of land would control the types and rates of development and advancement of technology, the types of governments societies had, the types…

    • 1613 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jared Diamond, in Chapter 19 of the novel Guns, Germs, and Steel, proposes that the black Bantu ethnic group was able to exert dominance over the other four cultural groups in Africa in areas that food production was viable because the Bantu’s sedentary lifestyle was greatly advantaged compared to hunter-gatherers living in the same area. Diamond supports his claims by illustrating the major societal and organizational difference between the Bantu and hunter-gatherer groups and pointing to the methods by which the Bantu expansion was carried out. The author’s purpose is to show what environmental factors led to certain peoples asserting dominance over others in order to support his theory about geographic determinism and refute racist explanations about the fates of human societies. The author writes in a logical scientific tone for an educated and intellectually honest audience. The factors all come together to allow Diamond to create a convincing argument about the factors that led to the Bantu expansion in Africa.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Even though we consider ourselves to be a highly advanced society today, I don’t think I can say that we are the better society. What this book has made me realize is that there is never a right way to structure your society that is better than all other societies. Every society is unique and has its share of benefits and drawbacks, including our own. Agrarian societies have complex ecological systems that utilize every last resource. Native American societies only took what they needed from the land to preserve nature as much as possible.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Taker Culture

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages

    ultures of human culture, those being “leavers” and “takers”. His first allusion, a biblical reference to the fall of Adam and Eve from the Garden of Eden is actually the story of when the leaver and taker cultures separated historically. Ishmael explains that after eating from the tree of knowledge of good and evil, humans gained what they thought was “the knowledge of the gods”. This is where the leaver culture, which modern man descends from, developed an attitude that their way of life was the right way and that it should be spread. Takers began to believe that entire purpose of evolution was the arrival of mankind on the planet, and that we are here to dominate all, or that all resources on earth are ours to exploit.…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If, however, the population of the whole country grew and the population of town population grew as well, the case would have to be that less people produced more food, ergo agricultural productivity rose. This logical outcome, however, is not the only indicator of agricultural productivity. In fact, this rise was even greater, given that the percentage of labor force engaged in agriculture decreased dramatically from 76% in 1520 to 33% by 1750. This led to more services offered in villages and, therefore, development of rural areas. Since an average farmer could now feed more people, villagers were more confident to go to the cities and seek employment there, knowing that food would be available.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout Karl Jacoby’s Crimes against Nature he analyzes four distinct myths about conservation that he intends to refute in his book. I will analyze the “conservation’s final myth involved the relationship between the movement and the people it most directly affected. Ever since Marsh’s Man and Nature, a key component of conservation’s degradation discourse has been the need to use science and the state to protect nature from the recklessness of rural folks” (Jacoby, 198). Jacoby attempts to bust the myth by advocating that government and science worked well together by negatively impacting most of the rural folk through hunting, law making, and military protection in the Adirondacks, Yellowstone, and in the Grand Canyon national parks.…

    • 1887 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nomads have influenced Europe and China socially, politically, and economically due to them helping spread there ideas on the government, also by introducing other countries to the vast resources that the place they conquered had and by sometimes transferring the power from being passed down by heritage to actually to people who studied and knew how to rule ,however, not all the time when a nomadic tribe invaded/conquered a territory they actually helped the empire sometimes all they did was further destroy it like the Mongols and some Germanic tribes. Nomads have long since lived on the Eurasia continent, however, during the late 16th hundreds due to the increase in civilized settlements being created nomads and civilized settlements began constantly fighting over the ownership of the…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As a result, it increased domesticated wild plants, which served as a good alternative for them. As population densities raised, food production attended well in feeding the numerous people. Lastly, food producers were outnumbering hunter-gatherers. This led the hunters and gatherers to be displaced by the food producers or follow their…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As explained in his infamous essay, “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race,” Jared Diamond argues that the adoption of agriculture led to many negative consequences that have hindered the general livelihood of humans. His argument is based on the comparison of the lifestyles of agriculture-based societies and hunter-gatherers, claiming that the latter lacked many of the challenging aspects that emerged with the beginnings of domestication and civilization. Diamond’s main points of focus are the negative health effects of people’s new diet, the increased spread of diseases, and the development of societal inequalities. In general, I agree with Diamond’s claim that the adoption of agriculture had some negative effects on humans,…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A settled lifestyle was more superior to the hunter-gatherer lifestyle in early societies because they had a lot of food,women were able to have many kids, and they were able to have many different things due to having a settled life. “The birth interval for higher birth of food producers is around two years, half that of hunter- gatherers. That higher birth rate of food producers, together with their ability to feed more people per acre” (89). This quote shows that having a settled lifestyle is better than being a hunter-gatherer because you are able to produce a lot of plants like potatoes and carrots and have animals reproducing can also get you different things like milk and meat. This also means that the population can grow at a higher…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Justifying Rulership: a comparison of the Olmec and Ubaid cultures There are many similarities in the rise of complex society in both Mesopotamia and Mesoamerica. From monumental structure building to well integrated trade, cultures such as the Olmec of Mesoamerica 1200 BC - 400 AD and the Ubaid of Mesopotamia 4500 BC-3000 BC, have many parallel elements relating to their success as complex societies and what one may refer to as states, despite thousands of years between the two. Comparatively, there are also key differences between the two, particularly the timescale in which complexity took place and the practices of agriculture. Most, if not all of these elements that factor into the success of a state are generally under control of the ruler of the state, but how do these rulers keep their subjects loyal and in order; justifying the vast inequalities…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The physical barriers created by challenging mountainous terrain leave the mountain people isolated from society. As a result, mountain people are deprived of opportunities available to lowland people and are subject to difficult challenges not seen in non-mountainous regions. Mountain groups are faced with the challenge of growing crops under difficult weather and soil conditions. They lack adequate supply lines to replenish their scarce resources. They are not able to avail themselves of the latest technological advances.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Other Greeks, Hanson suggests a similar socioeconomic model of the Hoplite reform, yet he centers his study on the object of farming land rather than the whole picture of tradeoffs between the hoplite and the agricultural activities. He concurs with Viggiano and Cartledge in that overpopulation and relative land hunger were stimuli of revolution and struggle both inside and outside the polis. Within the local affairs of the city-state, “the population pressure on limited land led to the use of more intensive farming techniques, such as the cultivation of marginal lands and farmstead residence” (Hanson on Viggiano, 122). The concept of “land hunger” originates from the fact that as population escalated at a faster rate, land became increasingly scarce – especially quality arable land –, and small farmers started colonizing terrains around mountain slopes and relatively away from water sources.…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ju Hoansi Analysis

    • 1831 Words
    • 8 Pages

    There were more than 10 plus different crops being planted, tobacco was the most planted crop at camp. Farming was a challenge for them because of the need shade and they need water. With village more, permeant and not need close water sources at that time, the villager should be flexible with the water. Also, from farming, lead to the factor of herding, men did have knowledge and experience with herding cattle from working with nearby camps before globalization entered. Now they are working with their own cattle, and holding cattle for others….…

    • 1831 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq Nomads

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A common ideology is that agriculture societies created enough food to develop technologies and art, because survival required less time and labor. Unfortunately agricultural societies became infatuated with the development of government and less mobile preferring a sedentary lifestyle . The nomad societies were foragers requiring them to become masters of mobility as they needed to follow seasonal paths of wild game and plants. This directly correlates to their mastery of horse riding, and hunting with the bow and arrow. The nomads developed into excellent warriors during their times of disunity.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays