Antibiotics Argumentative Essay

Improved Essays
Think of the last time that you had a big juicy steak--seasoned to perfection at your house or at a restaurant. Did the thought ever cross your mind that this steak could make me sick? I know that I haven 't but could worrying about it become a reality for anyone that eats meat? Antibiotics are known as a miracle cure. The definition of antibiotics from South Dakota State University is; Antibiotics are medicines that are given to people or animals to treat or prevent certain illnesses caused by bacteria. Antibiotics either kill or hinder the growth of harmful bacteria in animals and people. At one point or another everyone has had an antibiotic. One worry scientists have about antibiotics is that they may be losing their power. These scientists …show more content…
Americans, for example, need to have more meat produced with the increased population. These antibiotics are not the same kind of antibiotics as the ones for viruses and diseases. These antibiotics are put into the livestock’s food or water. These antibiotics are a hormone that is fed to help the animal gain weight faster for less food they eat. However, the FDA(Food and Drug Administration) is trying to limit the use of these drugs that are being used to enhance food production. William Flynn, DVM, MS, deputy director for science policy at FDA’s Center for Veterinary Medicine(CVM) stated, “ We need to be selective about the drugs we use in animals and when we use them,” In other words we need to use them only when there is no other option. William Flynn went on by saying, “Antimicrobial resistance may not be completely preventable, but we need to do what we can, to slow it down.” When these animals need these drugs to make them grow faster, the producer will need to get the veterinarian to give it to them. This is because the FDA is doing their best to slow down the production of these resistant microorganisms. They want these drugs and other antibiotics to be needed by prescription in order give it to their livestock when it is only truly

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Many say that overall they are beneficial; that they allow animals to digest food more readily, that they get more benefits from their food, avoid more illness, and that they will grow stronger due to this. The trend of using antibiotics has increased due to the boost in demand for more meat at a faster rate. The small confinement in concentrated animal feedlot operations means that more bacteria and pathogens will spread, spiking illness rates. At first glance antibiotics may seem like a considerable solution to our problems, but in the long run they may become our inevitable downfall. There is indication that the high volume use of antibiotics is leading to an escalation of antibiotic-resistant microbes. As nature works, nutrients is absorbed from what we eat. If we are consuming antibiotic infused meat then a percentage of antibiotics is infusing our systems as well, because of this meat eaters are becoming immune to the current antibiotics we have to fight disease. Antibiotics cannot be fully metabolized by livestock, so as well as the consumption and handling the meat, the antibiotics can be found in the manure which can runoff into enclosing surface water, therefore affecting us…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For more than 70 years, antibiotics have been used to treat bacterial infections of the body. The first appearance of this life changing medicine, was in the 1940’s on the battlefield. This medicine was named penicillin, the drug saved many from the brink of death, by fighting bacterial diseases; from then on antibiotics changed the face of medicine. Infection was no longer an impregnable wall that had to be broken down before the real treatment could begin, infections could be treated on site, at moments notice. As time passed, the world became co-dependent on the use of antibiotics to treat all of the body 's infections, and was repeatedly misused. Maryn McKenna proposed in her essay“ Imagining the Post- Antibiotics Future.” that people need to cherish the availability of antibiotics. McKenna also argues that even though surviving a post- antibiotic era may seem inconceivable, because of the fact that antibiotics have become highly addictive to the everyday lifestyle, it can become accessible with the persistence of change within the administration of Antibiotics.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The strongest way is to follow the model that Denmark and Aarestrup has set up. Their team has successfully collected data and developed a model that was able to reduce the amount of antibiotics used on livestock, while at the same time keeping the price of meat at a stable price that does not negatively affect the farmers (Aarestrup 2012, 2). This is often a huge concern among many; they worry that a change away from antibiotics will have a huge negative effect on this aspect of the market. Aarestrup’s studies provides direct evidence that they were able to solve this issue. Utilizing their three keys to success—data, political will, and collaboration—we can begin the path of slowing down the increasing antibiotic resistance. We must start today by considering legislation that will put limitations on the excessive use of antibiotics in our livestock industry. That is why I am here today to push for one of those keys which is political will and the ban or reduction of antibiotic use for just growth…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Farms that are not properly maintained can develop salmonella and E. Coli which is passed onto humans through meat, dairy, and eggs. To fight off the bacteria, animals are fed or injected with large amounts of antibiotics. Industrial farms have been adding antibiotics to livestock since 1946. Shortly after, studies began to show that antibiotics were making animals grow faster and gain weight more efficiently. All of which were qualities that were increasing meat producer’s profits. Between 1985 and 2001, the use of antibiotics for farm productions rose fifty percent. Today, they are routinely fed to livestock, poultry, and fish for faster growth and to neutralize the unsanitary conditions in which they are raised in. According to the FDA, approximately eighty percent of all antibiotics used in the United States are fed to industrial animals while the other twenty percent of antibiotics are used as human medical…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philpott Meat Industry

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages

    He starts out the article by stating, “Last year, the Food and Drug Administration proposed a set of voluntary "guidelines" designed to nudge the meat industry to curb its antibiotics habit” (Philpott, The Meat Industry Now Consumes Four-Fifths of All Antibiotics). He goes on to state how the FDA is struggling to implement the new rules. This would not be a problem for the FDA if the meat industry was not expanding at a rapid rate and using more and more antibiotics each day. This constant use, as Philpott shows, is creating antibiotic-resistant pathogens. Philpott shows this growth of antibiotic use for both the meat and poultry industry on a graph. The graph show the millions of pounds of antibiotics sold for both the industries and sick human beings. The use of antibiotics by humans had leveled off at around 7.7 million in 2011. The use of antibiotics in industry however was growing to 29.9 million pounds of antibiotics sold. A harsh difference for sure, but Philpott had a typo when describing the graph.Philpott stated, “...livestock farms have been sucking in more and more of the drugs each year—and consumption reached a record nearly 29.9 billion pounds in 2011” (Philpott). This slipup of stating that the use of antibiotics in the meat industry was 29.9 billion pounds instead of the actual 29.9 million can mislead readers into thinking the use of antibiotics is way greater than it actually…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Europe, the genetic resistance isn’t as big of a problem. In fact the drug penicillin is still has a major role in healing people. But in the U.S. the drug is ineffective because it was used as a cure all drug. But there are other ways to reduce resistance; “such methods might include reducing overcrowding, controlling heat stress, providing vaccination to prevent disease, and using beneficial microbial cultures” (UCSUSA). By giving the animals a stable and human environment, not as many vaccinations would need to be used. Resulting in less resistance from the bacteria, which is beneficial to the American people. However, “the most sensible approach is to identify and reduce nonessential uses of antibiotics and reserve as many of these drugs as possible for wise use in human and veterinary medicine” (UCSUSA). If the FDA set strict regulations, this issue would be solved very easily, but with the power of the food industry will not make it easy. In addition, “the FDA has asked drug companies to voluntarily phase out antibiotics used to promote growth in animals” (Tracy). The FDA has asked to reduce the use of antibiotics, but no one will list because it reduces profit. The FDA needs a wakeup call and restrict the use of antibiotics or else the results will be destructive to human…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should the use of antibiotics be restricted? Antibiotics are a drug that is prescribed from a doctor to a patient to provide faster fighting in a bacterial infection (2). Bacteria can grow and reproduce fast, thus creating a challenge for your immune system to be able to fight them off. Bacteria are classified as prokaryotes and can survive in extreme conditions (3). Bacteria are more commonly know as “germs” (3). There are many advantages and disadvantages if our government decides to restrict the use of antibiotics. The use of antibiotics should be restricted because it can slow down the evolution of bacteria and stop the problem before it even occurs.…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Gestation Crates

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages

    the drugs are then given to the livestock to enhance their growth and meat quality. The 80% of antibiotics sold in the U.S are used on livestock. The U.S uses more antibiotics in livestock than many other nations. Animals that are raised for food in America are given 6 times as much antibiotics. Currently six different steroidal hormone are approved by the FDA for use in livestock. This rampant use is creating antibiotic resistant “super…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ultimately, antibiotic resistant bacteria should not be of concern to consumer because resistant bacteria such as MRSA has not been directly connect to meats, withdrawal date prevent residue on meats and the antibiotics used for humans and food animals are highly used in one or the other, but not both. Approximately 80% of non medically important antibiotics sold in the United States are Ionophores which are not used for human antibiotics at all (Summary Report 17). The FDA is trying extremely hard to push the use of non medically important antibiotics in livestock and as the use of Ionophores increase it will help to ease the…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    2)Bacteria cell wall synthesis: While the cells of people and creatures don 't have cell walls, this structure is basic for the life and survival of bacterial species. A drug that objectives cell wall can in this way specifically slaughter or restrain bacterial living beings. Illustrations: penicllins and vancomycin.…

    • 1768 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the mid 1990’s,”Denmark became the first country to strictly regulate agricultural antibiotics … its animal food industries not only didn’t collapse, they saw benefits.”(Zaitchik). The main argument against not using antibiotics is that it would destroy the meat industry. Other countries have proven that it is possible. According to the American National Academy of Sciences it would only cost the consumer $5 to $10 USD annually for factory farms to stop suing antibiotics. Some states in the US have even gotten pass lobbyists to limit the use of antibiotics in farming. California lawmakers and the US centers of disease control have gotten together to create, “a bill, which goes into effect on 1 January 2018. The bill will restrict the regular use of antibiotics for disease prevention and bans antibiotic use to fatten up animals.”(theguardian). States have realized the health risks of consuming too many antibiotics and have taken action themselves. Other states are also looking into regulating…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some of the illnesses they get are from antibiotic resistant bacteria. The number of people dying from the illnesses is recorded, “The Centers for Disease control and prevention issued a report last month that found that 23,000 people die from antibiotic-resistant infections each year” (Henneberger). The number of people who die from antibiotic-resistant infections is alarming and there are many reasons that the bacteria is becoming resistant. One factor is that medicine is often overused, “Most scientists agree that over prescribing the drugs to humans is the predominant cause for bacteria evolving to outsmart them” (Henneberger). Sometimes people take antibiotics for illnesses that antibiotics have no effect on which can be dangerous, “Taking an antibiotic when it is not necessary can be harmful” (Bren). The bacteria keep getting stronger “...With each passing decade, bacteria that resist not only single, but multiple, antibiotics-making some disease particularly hard to control-have become increasingly widespread” (Bren). The bacteria have evolved so much that the number of antibiotics, it was resistant to was extremely high, “...an outbreak of antibiotic-resistant Salmonella was traced to ground beef. Forty-seven people in five states got sick from this germ, which proved resistant to 11 antibiotics” (How Safe Is That Burger). Another factor in the problem is that animals may also be given drugs that can be used in human medicine. It is also believed that, “Feeding the drugs widely to control and prevent disease in cows, pigs, and chickens… play a role” (Henneberger). Some people would be surprised that records are not kept on antibiotic use on animals nationally, “...the U.S. doesn’t keep national records on antibiotic use in animals, the Union of Concerned Scientists estimates that up to 70 percent of all antibiotics sold in the U.S. are administered to healthy animals to speed growth and…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Pag.). Most meat consumers are knowledgeable about good and bad meants. Sick animals become stressed in most cases. When animals become stressed the lactic acid in the meat hardens and becomes tough. When the meat becomes tough instead of tender, consumers do not like it anymore. Studies have shown that “you are far more likely to die from a dog bite or a lightning strike than from treatment failure related to the use of antibiotics”(Dorman N.Pag.). With that being said, the risks to become affected from antibiotics in meat is very small. The public is concerned about the small issue and not focussing on the big picture. In fact, “none of the urgent threats have any relation to farm animals” (Dorman N.Pag.). With the major concern of antibiotic resistance being pinpointed to farm animals, most do not realize that livestock creates just a fraction of the real problem. The laws that the Food and Drug Administration sets are there for the public safety, some just jump to conclusions about…

    • 1506 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Since the 1940,s, antimicrobial drugs, such as antibiotics, have been effectively used to cure patients with infectious diseases. Over time, however, many pathogens have evolved to resist the drugs that were designed to destroy them, making the products increasingly ineffective. This happens because the bacteria adapt to the environment due to natural selection. Then bacteria with the resistant genotype will reproduce and spread. Drug resistant pathogens are linked with the over prescription of antibiotics, as well as missing doses when taking antibiotics.[28] Inappropriate use of antibiotics has been linked to a number of causes, including people insisting antibiotics, doctors prescribing them because they do not have time to explain why they are not necessary, and doctors not knowing when to prescribe antibiotics or being too careful about prescribing them. At least one third of people believe that antibiotics are effective for the flu, and it is the most common reason antibiotics are prescribed even though they are ineffective against viruses. If we continue to overuse antibiotics, diseases that are currently treatable will become incurable and millions of people will die as a result of this. Society can prevent infections from becoming incurable in the future by not overusing antibiotics, finishing antibiotics even if the infection is gone and not using…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are two different types of bacteria in the body, the good bacteria and the bad. The healthy and good bacteria in the body is often killed along with the bad bacteria which can lead to more problems in the body. Antibiotics are used to destroy the cell walls in bacteria. When antibiotics are prescribed for viruses not only do they not help cure the virus, because there are no bacteria cells for it to kill, but it destroys the healthy bacteria, causing more problems for the body. Then the antibiotics are also being used when they are unneeded which ultimately causes the bacteria to begin to mutate and become immune to common antibiotics. If the bacteria continues to mutate it could cause more problems for the body. To conclude, antibiotics should be restricted to the public because they cause mutations if overused, they do not treat viruses, and they destroy the healthy and good bacteria the body needs to…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays