Comparing Sophocles Creon And Homer's Telemachus

Improved Essays
The creation of a hero is only decided through the actions that the character takes. Sophocles’ Creon and Homer’s Telemachus are clearly not worthy of the title “hero”, but they are forced into this hero’s journey so that they can realize what their effect has on others that surround them. It can not be known for sure if either one has completed the hero’s journey because in order to see that change, we would need to see a continuation of the story, however by observing their personalities, it is made aware that there is a transcendence back to reality and back into a hero’s mindset.
To begin with, these two characters exhibit selfishness meaning they operate in a manner that proves to be convenient for their own personal gain starting with
…show more content…
The whole principle of the hero’s journey is the becoming and the start of a new life and that is exactly what Telemachus does, but the transcendence into this mindset takes longer than expected. Right from the beginning of his journey, when Telemachus arrives on Pylos, he and Nestor are talking and Nestor mentions how maybe when he returns he could attack the suitors at his house, however Telemachus replies and says “I do not think this will pass, dear lord; what you have said is too immense… I know it’s not to be even if the gods should will it so” (III, 49). This insecurity could strive from the fact that he did not have a father growing up and lacked a certain stereotypical “man” presence in his life. Nevertheless, after being persuaded by Athena in a hidden identity, Telemachus ends up pursuing the call of the journey and once he returns to the palace, he lets the suitors know that he is no longer the weak child they once knew and could take advantage of and gives them a warning as mentioned in the following “Be warned: within this house, let no man flaunt or strut; I note all that is done- both good and evil; I’m a child no more.” (XX, 414). They go from being frowned upon to returning to a better state where they are accepted in the eyes of society. He never had a fatherly influence for the most part

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the first book of Homer’s The Odyssey, Telemachus faces a variety of dilemmas, including, but not limited to, an identity crisis, a vast assortment of men exhausting his estate, a father on hiatus, a weeping mother, and quite frankly the ability to think independently. All of these adversities culminate into the overarching issue facing Telemachus, in that Telemachus is a bit over zealous to do something, anything really, without truly thinking through all of the possible consequences. Afore, a layer of context is essential in understanding Telemachus’ condition.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Odysseus and Telemachus share many similarities and differences as they are father and son. One of the main differences between the two is the amount of experience each individual has. Odysseus is a character that has gone through the worst in life: The Trojan war that lasted ten years, Poseidon’s form of torture, and a journey home that took ten years. Three things that the Phaeacian’s stated only one man can endure, Odysseus. On the other hand, Telemachus is only twenty-one years old and has only gone on one year-long journey that Athena sent him on.…

    • 118 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, he really came across as incapable and doesn’t receive the support he was hoping for. The men did not want to hear any more of what Telemakhos had to say: “Vexing though it may be; we fear no one, / certainly not Telemakhos, with his talk” (II. 209-210). After this Telemakhos is finished with pleading his case; he realizes the men and suitors are only going to do what they think is best since Odysseus is gone. With his speech failing, Telemakhos is more determined than ever to find news of his father.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Athena challenges Telemachus to leave boyhood and enter manhood. Athena calls Telemachus to subdue his grief for one year. During that year, Telemachus is to call an assembly with the purpose of gathering and scattering the suitors inhabiting the palace, commandeer a ship with twenty oars with the purpose of searching for whispers and rumors regarding the status of Odysseus. Telemachus must first visit Pylos and interrogate King Nextor. Then, Telemachus must sail to Sparta in search of the red haired Menelaus.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This was a lesson not imparted to him, as he grew up only with the grieving Penelope and a nurse that doted on him. This is further reinforced when Pisistratus obeys his father’s command to accompany Telemachus to Sparta. He is showing obedience, and more respect to his elders as a result. And, Telemachus keeps this in mind as well. Therefore, without his…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ”(9.544). Odysseus’s arrogance definitely affected how fast he and his men were able to get home, as if Odysseus had not told the Kyklops his name, then the Kyklops wouldn’t have told his father Poseidon, that Odysseus angered him. Unlike Odysseus, Telemachus doesn’t seem extremely arrogant, but he rather seems to be more humble, and confident, but not in a boastful way. Telemachus shows this during a conversation with Odysseus before they fight the suitors. When…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before Telemachus speaks with Athena he never addresses his mother with a disapproving tone. This is proven by her “stunned” reaction when her son commands her to proceed to her room (I ln.380). Athena further demonstrates her power when she grants Telemachus the audacity to confront the suitors. Telemachus confronts the suitors after talking to Athena; he calls the suitors “arrogant pigs,” and he commands them to leave (I ln.387-401). Previous to his conversation with Athena, Telemachus would never stand against the suitors because they could overpower him.…

    • 1596 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By commanding his mother, Telemachus is demonstrating his growth into a man. By telling his mother what to do, he is showing he has the authority to tell her what to do, and by doing so infant of the suitors helps to build their view of him. With his first commanding his mother, Telemachus is demonstrating his first taking of the powers typically granted to men. This growth is further seen when he declares that he holds the “reins of power” in his fathers house while he is gone.…

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When he meets his father for the very first time, Telemachus finally has the new role model that he has been missing for his life. The whole motive of his journey, which helped him mature, is to find Odysseus. Meeting him after twenty years of not having a father made him realizes his full potential and bravery. He felt the need to fill his father’s footsteps, and make him proud, and: “...Telemachus-too quick- stabbed the man from behind, / plunging his bronze spear between the suitor’s shoulders / and straight on through his chest the point came jutting out” (22. 97-99). By having the courage to kill the suitors at the end of the story, it shows how Telemachus develops through his experiences.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Both Telemachus-Odysseus son-and Odysseus himself experienced this. When Odysseus leaves for war, Telemachus is only an infant, but now he has become a young teenager. During his teenage years, like many others, Telemachus struggles with finding his identity and voice. These struggles contribute to him not being able to handle the suitors, who have overtaken his father’s house in his absence. However, these imperfections will be rectified, when goddess Athena sends him on a quest (to the city of Nestor and Sparta) to discover information about his father.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is obvious from the beginning that Telemachus misses his father. Telemachus’ mood is “... sad, morose - sat with the suitors. In his reverie, he saw his sturdy father, would that he, returning suddenly, might banish these intruders from his palace, and restore the rights and rule that had been before” (Homer 7). Despite wishing his father was there, Telemachus tries to control the house. He is young, about 21, hence, he is having trouble keeping order.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Athena convinces Telemachus to journey and find out whether his father is alive. He meets King Nestor in Pylos and King Menelaus in Sparta, who both have news about Odysseus. Telemachus's journey—both a physical and metaphorical journey—is essential for him to become the true son of Odysseus because he learns how similar he is to Odysseus, gains confidence, and understands the importance of praying to the gods. First of all, Telemachus's…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Odyssey, Homer shows the transition of Telemachus from a childish and passive young man to a Man worthy of being Odysseus’ son. Through the help of Athena, he learns different character traits and qualities such as bravery that helps him to mature into a man worth the title of a prince of Ithaca. Odysseus’ son the help of Athena. He learns how to be authoritative, assert maturity and acknowledge his wrongdoing. He is also influenced by the return of his father to be more like him.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Odysseus Character Traits

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After Odysseus left Ithaca for the Trojan War, the suitors take over his estate. Odysseus’ absence compels the young Telemachus to take Odysseus’ place and maintain his estate. Telemachus hears about his father’s deeds throughout his life, which inspires him to be a brave warrior and carry out his duties towards his mother and estate. Telemachus is influenced by his father’s virtues of prudence and humility. When Odysseus lays out his plan to first test his servants for loyalty, Telemachus uses his prudence, to propose to kill the suitors first.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Great rulers only come once in Greek lifetime. Oedipus and Creon were both good rulers for Thebes, yet at the same time were men tragic of ill created fates and downfall. Oedipus was swift with action and had courage that could last a life time, while Creon was simplistic in nature and had a good head on his shoulders. Both kings, however had character flaws of stubbornness, as one tried to change and outrun his fate, while the other could not see past his nose, unable to make the right changes at the right time. As both were unable to change their ways in time, it led to the end of their legacies, one with death, and another with a life of loneliness.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays