Analysis Of Robert Paarlberg's 'Attention Whole Food Shoppers'

Improved Essays
In the modern world today, many people cook and eat organic foods. They do this because they believe that it is better for them, despite the higher price. Robert Paarlberg noticed this when he was writing his article, “Attention Whole Food Shoppers”. While writing this article, he brought up the fact that while this entire process helps local farmers and fight climate change, the global issue of hunger is not solved. He approaches this topic by pulling in his readers with an ethical appeal, and supports his argument with factual evidence as well as a very confident, firm tone. While doing all of this, Paarlberg is able to convince his audience that we must worry about world hunger more than how our fruits and vegetables grow.
Robert Paarlberg
…show more content…
Paarlberg brings in celebrity author Vandana Shiva to explain just what is going on. He states, “A 2002 meeting in Rome of five hundred prominent international NGOs, including Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace, even blamed The Green Revolution for the rise in world hunger” (Paarlberg 613). This appeals to logic as it references an expert opinion. Paarlberg may not be credible on his own to make this statement, but by bringing in an expert opinion of eco-activists he appeals to logic. Because of this, he makes an even better point to the argument so that the audience can believe his …show more content…
He uses good judgement by telling readers that they are not to blame for the crisis. He also uses emotional appeal when explaining how serious the situation is to readers and why they should help. Finally, he uses expert opinion from an eco-activist to tell readers what is going on with the situation they are reading about. He uses the combination of all these appeals to prove to his audience that solving the world food crisis is more important than shopping

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Modern times offer a very diverse way of expressing oneself. The expression of a single person who consumes more than they need may not be enough to hurt the environment; however, the overproduction of harmful waste from big business is big enough to impact the environment. Critically acclaimed author Anna Lappé describes the climate crisis through the food production industry in a sector of industry where people rarely scrutinize in her article “The Climate Crisis at the End of Our Fork.” In a very different, yet scarily similar way Carolyn Merchant metaphorically describes the problems with modern human tendency and desires through the image of a shopping mall in “Eden Commodified.”…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Its purpose is not to dissuade consumers from purchasing organic food. He also discusses the positive implications of buying and consuming non-GMO organic products. For example, Shapin cited Michael Pollan’s book which explained the peace of mind when it comes to eating organic, “…but he wanted to test what it felt like to have ‘a meal that is eaten in full consciousness of what it took to make it.’ That consciousness, for Pollan, is more religious than political.” (438) This can be a true for many consumers who migrated towards the organic trend who felt it is morally inhumane to be eating corporate food when you have the option to eat “free range chickens” or “non-GMO fruits”. Furthermore, Shapin stated that organic farms can minimize its negative environmental impact by citing that Earthbound Farm “annually obviate the use of more than a quarter of a million pounds of toxic chemical pesticides and almost 8.5 million pounds of synthetic fertilizers, which saves 1.4 million gallons of the petroleum needed to produce those chemicals.” (429-430) Shapin aims to educate the readers on what it truly means to be…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Despite its publication more than a decade ago, Pollan’s argument remains relevant today as the globe struggles to find the best balance between accessible or healthy food and efficient or moral food production methods. Regardless of what course the food industry will decide to take, the power it holds over society and our future is…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For instance, he uses true, emotion based facts to help portray his message: “World Bank President Robert Zoellick warned that high food prices would be particularly damaging in poor countries, where ‘there is no margin for survival’” (Paarlberg, par. 2). Paarlberg uses the words “there is no margin for survival” to connect with readers emotionally, which helps him to convince them that something needs to change and allows him to follow up with a proposal. Yet again, he plays with people’s emotions reporting that “in Africa, more than 70 percent of rural households are cut off from the closest urban markets because, for instance, they live more than a thirty-minute walk from the nearest all-weather road” (Paarlberg, par. 3). The reality of this evidence allows Paarlberg to affect the reader’s emotions in a more personal way. This type of personal emotion is another factor that makes it easier for him to suggest to readers that change needs to occur. Paarlberg’s use of true and credible facts, along with discussing other views, helps him earn…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “America’s Food Crisis” by Bryan Walsh is a mind stimulating read on Walsh’s examination of food production. No one really looks into the depths of food production as they should. In this article Walsh attempts to bring out the negatives on food production by stating facts on how it has affected us financially and health wise. Swift states that we should make smarter food choices instead of going by more are better. Walsh prosperously reveals his argument not trying to scare us into being vegetarians, but for us to make healthier food choices.…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Strolling through Stop and Shop, customers always seem to lay their eyes on the organic aisle for a split second, and think "What really labels this aisle as organic? Why would I ever want to be healthy?" Some, nonetheless, walk through the aisle, picking up these overpriced products that claim to allegedly be free of artificial flavors and genetically modified chemicals; products that claim to be unlike those found in the other ten aisles of the supermarket. The article "What are you Buying When You Buy Organic," by Steven Shapin depicts the corporate food industry, specifically Earthbound Farms and how the discussion of organic produce is more of a profitable matter, than what matters most, the health of an individual. Organic food is dictionary…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a society we have seen more muckrakers emerge since Upton Sinclair than ever before. The Jungle was only the beginning of an exposé on the food industry that is still relevant today. Great writers and journalists continue to try and educate the public on just where their food is coming from. Michael Pollan presents the reader with his own work of food journalism in the form of Omnivore’s Dilemma, in which he defines industrial logic and how this idea motivates industry to produce the food we receive today, then offers the alternative of local food chains to combat the distrust in supermarkets.…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We see this form of satire when the People-First states that, “Conservation pushed by these people always goes too far”, “The wackos have a broad and mostly hidden agenda that always comes from the left, usually far left”, and “They want environmental laws and regulatory surveillance to create government supported jobs for their kind of bureaucrats, lawyers, and consultants.” These claims not only attempt to explain the environmentalists’ faulty motives, but it also may be false. Similarly, the Environmentalists states that “What they are really after, especially the corporate heads and bigtime landowners, is unrestrained capitalism with land development über alles. They keep their right-wing political agenda mostly hidden when downgrading climate change and species extinction, but for them, economic growth is always the ultimate, and maybe the only, good.” Once again, this form of dramatic irony to try and explain the motives of the other party does not provide a valid…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The increased need for eco-foodies has been on the rise. Robert Paarlberg in an article Attention Whole Food Shoppers provides dissenting views on how food security can be achieved. To Robert Paarlberg, changing our shopping and eating habits is a crucial aspect in helping the poor gain food security. Robert Paarlberg, however, argues that the aspect of food security should not be based on the international food prices. To Robert, international food prices do not reflect the true picture on demand or the supply of the food. The aspect of international food prices is not supported by Robert Paarlberg because some regions especially Africa and South Asia do not heavily rely on purchasing foods in Central joints.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book “Harvest for Hope”, written by Jane Goodall, outlines and inspires the audience to eat mindfully and healthily. The author explains how a great portion of our nutrient intake is unknowingly mixed with toxins, and made in miserable conditions. Dr. Goodall explains this successfully by analyzing the typical practices of industrial agriculture, which then leads her on to examine the repercussions of these techniques, pressing the point that we are fatally detached from nature and it’s ethics. This novel informs the public not only how to leave a small environmental footprint, but also how one can do so positively.…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to statistics, more than one billion people in the world are undernourished today. In his article “Attention Whole Foods Shoppers”, Robert Paarlberg discusses recent food policy of Western countries, according to which food products should be organic and local. In result, poor African countries experience hunger and worsening of the agriculture infrastructure because most Western countries lost their interest to invest the agricultural systems of developing countries. While in the West food becomes more and more exquisite, poor countries become deprived of the most basic food products, such as rice, wheat, and others. Paarlberg emphasizes that helping developing countries is no more a trend today and the world market is justified…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He asserts “the fact that better food — measured by taste or nutritional quality (which often correspond) — costs more, because it has been grown or raised less intensively and with more care.”(Pollan 23). According to The Rationalization and Persistence of Organic Food beliefs in the Face of Contrary Evidence by Olson, Erik L, the authors disprove Pollan’s claim through a content analysis of 710 reader responses for a Stanford study, which objective was to examine the ‘pro-organic’ and ‘organic-skeptic’ reader comments and determine the personal impact of organic food consumption, as well as the environmental impact of organic food production. The exposure of a Stanford University meta-analysis, which concludes that organically produced foods do not offer any significant nutritional advantages, as opposed to, conventionally produced food completely refutes Pollen’s claim. The study proves that just because a food has the label “organic” on it does not mean it is significantly “healthier”. The only difference between man-made food and so called “organic” food would be the price. Although Pollan’s claim was intended to help the reader, it resulted in doing the complete opposite. Due to his invalid information, his argument was convincing the reader to waste their money on overpriced “organic” food when in reality it has no…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Forks Over Knives Analysis

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This film offers the opposition of this topic virtually no time to give their side of the story. I believe that to have a successful argument, the audience should have the right to hear both sides of the story before they start making their own ideas. Connie Diekman, food expert, was only given a small opportunity to explain why eating animal meat is important. This film also does not offer any negatives that could come from switching diets. They fail to mention how prices of these organic food might make it impossible for certain families and students to make the switch. This film should show that any person with any kind of economic background can have the opportunity to switch. Forks over Knives never talk about the concept of balance. They give off the impression that all Americans eat crazy portions of meat and dairy products. They over-exaggerate to scare the audience more and to get their point across. If Forks over Knives tried to convince the audience to eat less meat and dairy products instead of completely cutting them out of our diets, they might be more successful. The diet would be less effective at the beginning, but if they teach Americans to take baby steps more change will ultimately come. This film should also provide steps and…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Food Inc Summary Essay

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Food Inc. reveals the truth about our food and how we must fight a corrupt system in order to get something as basic and clean, healthy, and honest food. It is unfortunate that animals, growers, and even buyers, must all suffer at the hands of these companies just so that they can fill their pockets. It will take a long time before there will be organic and humane food sold in our supermarkets, but if customers demand better quality, then they shall receive better…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “Food Security: The Challenge of Feeding 9 Billion People,” published on January 28, 2010, Charles Godfray asserts that because of the continuing growing population and the growth of food consumption, the demand for food will increase for at least 40 years due to the lack of certain factors which could prevent the issues being faced with the demand for food. Godfray supports his implication by supplying the reader with a variety of causes as to why the demand for food has continued to rise such as the yield gap, production limits, the change of diets, yet at the same time provides solutions to these certain complications which could reduce the demand for so much food. Moreover, Godfray wishes to convey the readers into understanding the importance of reducing the impact of the food system on the environment and the certain precautions or actions that can be taken in order to better the situation by creating a “multifaceted and linked global strategy” to…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays