Young Earth Creationism Argument Analysis

Improved Essays
Throughout history, education and what is taught to future generations has been a hot topic of debate. It should go without saying that preparing young children for the future, and how to operate in and become a functioning member of society should be paramount ideals when considering how to go about educating future generations. In recent history, there has been a sizable push to establish a specific viewpoint into public school curriculum—the science curriculum, to be more specific—around the nation. This viewpoint can be commonly referred to as Young-Earth Creationism, or creationism for short. This fundamentalist Christian viewpoint is a literal interpretation of the biblical account of creation, as written in the Book of Genesis. However, …show more content…
Let’s Talk Science, an organization focused on education and outreach to support youth development, defines scientific literacy broadly to include proficient understanding in the fields of science, technology, engineering and math (STEM). Being scientifically literate not only helps those who are employed, or are pursuing careers in these fields, but it can also help shape how people interact in and shape their daily lives. "Science Literacy…helps us as we interact with our environment, asking questions and seeking answers (Why)." In a video interview with Big Think, Lawrence Krauss, noted science communicator, expresses that teaching creationism in science classes would be akin to promoting ignorance in young children. Krauss critiques the belief that both Creationism and modern scientific theories should be taught side by side, saying that if “we allow nonsense to be promulgated in our schools, then we are doing a disservice to our children (Krauss).” In another interview with Big Think, Bill Nye, well-known author and science communicator, discusses the consequences of promoting this ignorance to children. Mr. Nye discusses the potentially disastrous effects that Creation education could have on the future of the country; saying that …show more content…
Creationists take offense that schools teach things like Darwin 's theory of evolution, as it makes assumptions about the past based upon observational evidence in the present. These same Six-day Creationists insist that the biblical account of Creation in the Book of Genesis is ample "historical evidence ” for their religious beliefs to be taught in the science classroom. However, both usage of and belief in this "historical science" is unique to creationist scientists and holds no sway over the rest of the scientific community. No theories or predictions can be made with "historical science," so the general consensus among most actually legitimate scientists concludes that it is not a real thing (Browning). Another argument often used in favor of teaching Creationism in the science classroom is that not teaching creationism in the science classroom is ignoring the scientific accuracy of the biblical account of creation. However, as discussed earlier in this essay, the account of creation featured in Genesis is anything

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    “Evolution as Fact and Theory” by Stephan Jay Gould outlines the constant taxing debate over evolution among creationists and evolutionists. He outlines the major issues that fuel the dispute and provides the logical and scientific approach to evolution for a clear argument against the claims of creationists. He firstly, provides a thorough explanation of the misconceptions of the definitions; “theory” and “Fact’. In the common vernacular a fact may be perceived as undeniable information with absolute certainty. (gould)…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Polite - or impolite - persecution, each form of discrimination bears its own dangers” (Editorial, The Catholic Times, 9th December). Even in science, education and a nativity scene spiritual warfare hides. Ben Stein’s DVD, “Expelled No Intelligence allowed” documents the academic persecution of scientists and educators who believe nature has design. Darwin’s theory, a bedrock of atheism/Russia/China and an increasing secular Britain rejects design. Sacked was a Christian when discovering blood cells in an alleged 60+ million-year-old dead dinosaur.…

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Should Public Schools "Teach the Controversy" About Evolution? Gregory Bassham examines the controversial subject of teaching evolution in public schools. As it stands, religious entities have made numerous efforts to limit the teaching of evolution and demand the education of creation in public schools. However, for the many attempts, the federal courts have rejected the demands as unconstitutional. Bassham asserts teaching the controversy is a bad idea.…

    • 236 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The concluding opinion stated that it was indeed unconsitutional to teach intelligent design as an alternative to evolution in a public school science classroom, as ID is grounded in religion. However, the process of forming that conclusion is much more important to determining…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In modern times religion and science are increasingly becoming viewed as incompatible, or at least non-overlapping. Damien Keown states that “Scientific discoveries, and theories such as evolution, have challenged many traditional Christian teachings…” at the expense of making them appear “...dogmatic, irrational, and backward-looking” (119). Despite its brief history in the West, Buddhism has gained increasing popularity in part due to its frequent portrayal as an exception to the conflict between scientific and spiritual thought. Proponents of this view—deemed “Buddhist Modernists” or “Secular Buddhists”—argue that Buddhism possesses certain qualities which make it compatible with a secular view of the world, while providing a source of purpose…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Katha Pollitt Creationism

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Why in today's world is Creationism still a major point of debate? From a scientific standpoint, the theory of evolution has been proved time and time again, yet, the fight still rages on. In Katha Pollitt’s argumental piece titled “What’s the Matter with Creationism?” she attempts to explore this continual issue and how it is affecting Americans today in the classroom and later in adult life. She claims that the high percentage of those who believe in creationism or some form of it are a direct indication of the public school system's failings.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning, children are arguing that evolution is the way monkeys became humans. They believe this because it is what they are taught or what they grasp from school. This is what is being discussed in the documentary “The Revisionaries,” the conflicts that appear with the theory of evolution and the re-write of US history when Don McLeroy, a creationist, tries to get re-elected as chairman of America’s most influential board of education. The science debate focuses on evolution while the history debate focuses on conservatism and the exclusion of minorities. Once every ten years a group of people, the Texas Board of Education, decide what will be taught to the next generation of American children.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Casey Luskin who has earned himself a B.S and an M.S in Earth sciences from the University of California, San Diego; has found what he believes to be the three main issues with how Darwinian evolution is taught in public schools. Starting off with how the students should be informed about how fossil records often lack transitional forms and that “explosions” of new species/life forms which challenges Darwinian evolutionary theory. Secondly, students should know that many scientists have come forward to directly challenge random mutation and natural selections ability to create complex biological features. To end his list he states that students should be directed to the many pieces of evidence that Darwinism uses for proof are weak. Such as how embryos contrary to pictures in textbooks actually look different in the embryonic stage.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Assignment: Professional Goals Statement The effective science teaching will help students foster and develop conceptual understandings as science learners for the rest of their life. It emphasizes engaging in and learning about scientific practice [1]. By understanding these perspectives can help educators providing more meaningful science teaching environment. The goal of this professional goal statement is to enhance the science and pedagogical knowledge of professional science teachers to improve the student learning outcome in the secondary education as well as the elementary education with a few fundamental goals such as the following: First of all, the goal is to make the student become an active learner by fostering an engaging in the classroom with students by multiple teaching methods.…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We shouldn’t say “this side is wrong” and “this side is right” but instead present them with the facts and statistics of both sides whether they are positive or negative. According to The University of Chicago Press Books, “scientific or not, creationism maintains an important role in American history and culture as a point of religious dissent, a sustained form of protest that has weathered a century of broad—and often dramatic—social changes. At the same time, the evolutionary theory has become a critical building block of modern knowledge. The key to accommodating both viewpoints, they show, is to disentangle belief from knowledge. A student does not need to believe in evolution in order to understand its tenets and evidence, and in this way can be fully literate in modern scientific thought and still maintain contrary religious or cultural views”.…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many credible scientists will defend the basis for the theory of evolution. High school curriculum should include the element of the theory of evolution because of the support of evidence and the scientific community.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Theory of Evolution, conducted by Charles Darwin brought a grateful amount of controversy in the science and education fields today. Debates between is Darwin’s evolution theory correct and if it should be taught in schools. Many disagree that Darwin’s theory should be taught in public schools because it is not proven and it’s a religious belief. Yet Darwin’s theory has all the characteristics of applying to science education. Teaching evolution in public schools wouldn’t change one’s morals or beliefs.…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    are informing biologists of the opposing views of evolution and creation and whether to or not to teach the biblical accounts of creation. The journal explains the conflict has been existing for over 150 years and stays unresolved. (In fact, studies have shown that) “learning and teaching may be helpful in providing a base for further research.” If both creationism and evolution are taught there is an equal base for what students will believe.” If one is hidden than students and society will be sheltered from what is and is not.…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning “In the beginning,” the famous first words of the most sold book in the world. The purpose of this literature review is not to enforce any of the beliefs on how the universe and it 's inhabitants came to be, but merely provide the evidence that both sides have used in order to defend the beliefs of each side. Creation Creationism, the perspective that the universe and all it 's inhabitants were created out of nothing by God (Triune God), or at least by an intelligent designer (ID). There are three approaches to creation, biblical creationism, scientific creationism, and scientific biblical creationism. In biblical creationism approach, the word of Bible is the sole source used to defend creation.…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    according to its supporters, answers what evolution does not, as it does not make it correct, let alone even worthy of being taught. Despite intelligent design consisting of faulty claims, such as it answering the origin of life, most supporters contend it should still be taught at schools as an alternative to evolution, which it should not. However, teaching intelligent design as a secondary option would still be detrimental. Teaching it would validate it as correct information, when as already established intelligent design is blatantly false misinformation.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays