City Between Worlds Book Review

Improved Essays
City Between Worlds : My Hong Kong takes the reader to the metropolitan city of Hong Kong, exploring its colonial past and uncertain future. In this uniquely sized tome Lee travels through the bustling city, highlighting events that occurred and recalling buildings and landmarks that have since been demolished or relocated. In eight detailed and informative chapters, Lee discusses the structure of the city as it is today compared to its past, Hong Kong’s colonial past, and the values and lifestyles of the Hong Kongese. Lee, a long term Hong Kong resident born in Mainland China explores the city from a unique perspective as he provides a view that is neither native, an expat, nor a colonist but a combination of the three; this, in a way, …show more content…
A poignant point that Lee explains is the concept of a generic city which was formulated by Rem Koolhaas (3). These generic cities are near warmer climates, skyscrapers abound, and feature “[an] airport, hotels, and shopping malls” (3). Another feature of these “generic cities” is that “history is meaningless” and “the past has become too small to be inhabited and shared by those alive” (3). By these definitions alone, it seems as though Hong Kong would fit and as such Lee postulates that Hong Kong is the model city on which this definition was created in his prologue (3). However, I believe that Lee has provided evidence that the Hong Kongese may have unconsciously recognized this phenomenon and are attempting to preserve what little historical hallmarks are left. Lee states in chapter eight titled “City and Country” that “[e]ach government project of urban renewal in Hong Kong has been challenged with a spontaneous outpouring of popular protest” (272). As Lee speculates this surge in conservation could just be nostalgia driven. Whatever the intentions are behind preserving the historical features of Hong Kong, it seems like it is something that will help Hong Kong preserve a unique identity as city versus the looming threat of becoming a fully generic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Meaning of the Title, “When Worlds Collide” In the first chapter of US History, the title, “When Worlds Collide” is given to describe this chapter. This represents that the Europeans and Natives had different cultures, diseases, plants, animals, and technology, as if they were in 2 completely different worlds, then met up with each other once Columbus set foot in the Americas. These worlds collided when Columbus, rather than sailing to India, accidentally sailed to the Americas in 1492, meeting the Tainos for the first time. From then on, Europeans and the Natives interacted with each other, and their worlds became entwined.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Quebec City in Canada is a city rich in both culture and history. The city itself is split into two parts, the old city and the new city. The old city is bordered in by an a fort that was once used for war and the new city surrounds the old. There’s beauty in the contrast of the two. New Quebec is all bright lights and businessmen while Old Quebec is brick roads and local shops.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Year Of Red Dust Analysis

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages

    On the other hand, the latter story demonstrates how particular elements of the city remained the same, such as the Chinese’s unfavorable attitude towards foreigners. With further analysis of these two tales, the audience can visualize the circumstances that Shanghai experienced prior to and during the control of the CPC. With reference to the story “(Tofu) Worker Poet Bao I,” there are several instances that reveal how social infrastructures were…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Like Chinese American students, Lee realized the different between school and her home. It began from the different of her culture and the way she was brought up. She didn’t know the Chinese heritage would play any role in her future as much as other students. This is easy for her to become an American and fit with American culture in here.…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This literary analysis will define the themes of feminist identity and cultural assimilation in the novel Disappearing Moon Cafe by Sky Lee. Lee’s novel provides a multi-generational view of the struggles of Asian that have immigrated to Vancouver, British Columbia. Kae Ying Woo narrates the history of the Wong family, which begins with the story of Wong Gwei Chang, and his wife, Kelora, and the familial relationships that extend into the Chinatown community in Vancouver throughout the 20th century. The female experiences of Wong family involve the matriarchal tyranny of Lee Mui Lan and the complex relationships that she shares as a restaurant/business owner, which challenge patriarchal stereotypes in the European and Chinese community. Kae…

    • 1513 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sabloff claims that urbanization is “one of the most significant trends of the 21st Century” (Sabloff 2008, 69), this claim is followed by the inclusion that two hundred years ago, only two and a half percent of the world lived in cities but now, it’s more than fifty percent. This has huge consequences because urbanization is increasing, not decreasing. The resources necessary to maintain a functioning city are also increasing, but this isn’t a new 21st century problem, ancient cities had the same issues. Archaeologist have researched ancient cities and urbanization, and their founding’s, should be applicated to cities today. The ancient city of Angkor in Cambodia, and its method to maintaining the largest pre-industrial city functioning well, was to not densely concentrate the population in one area but was to spread it throughout (Sabloff 2008, 74).…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Systematic Oppression In the biography, Between the World and Me, by Ta-Nehisi Coates, he explains to his son the challenges of being a black body in society. Coates writes about his transition from childhood to adulthood. He discusses learning about the truths and laws for being a black body. He questions the American dream, government, and history.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Between the World and Me Book Review Ta-Nehisi Coates, an African-American writer and national correspondent for The Atlantic, published his book Between the World and Me in 2015. Ta-Nehisi Coates demonstrates a letter writing format and introduce the thesis of this book with an interview. By using his unique writing style, outstanding using of languages, and narrative form, Coates emphasizes a currently serious issue in American, which is the gap between whites and blacks. Ta-Nehisi Coates adopts a letter writing format in the book Between the World and Me to denote the awareness or racism issue. Coates begins his writing with one word “Son”, which indicates the primary audience is his son, Samori. However, Coates intends to notify…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ta-Nehisi Coates is a journalist and national correspondent who writes about culture, politics and social issues. He grew up in west Baltimore Maryland where he came about race in America through a combination of patient instruction, firsthand experience and tragedy of his friends’ death. Mr. Coates attended Howard University, where he described it as being the loveliest and unique. Howard University can be known as a historical black institution, having African-Americans from all over the world attending its prestigious background. His book Between the World and Me, is a written letter to his son Samori.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One Out Of Three Analysis

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Chapters 4,5, and 6 of One Out of Three, written by Annelise Orleck, Min Zhou, and Pyong Gap Min discuss Soviet Jewish, Chinese, and Korean immigrants. These chapters were more narrative based than the first three chapters of One Out of Three and did a better job of including statistics without overwhelming the reader with data. I really liked that academics who specialize in each of the three immigrant groups wrote these three chapters. I found Min’s note about this own immigration experience at the end of chapter 6 particularly compelling. However, I think that some topics, such as the experiences of Bukharan immigrants in Queens, were glazed over and simplified.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From 1849, the beginning of California’s gold rush, to 1940, the Chinese in Chinatown faced harsh lives. The Chinese were never treated fairly-the town was treated like a “different planet altogether,” according to San Francisco's Chronicle. Still, the Chinese persevered and endured through their harsh lives in San Francisco. After struggle after struggle, the organized Chinese reestablished their town, gained strong bonds, and soon became a great landmark of San Francisco.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Goddess Film Analysis

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages

    While classical Hollywood biopics often featured “self-made individuals” who undergo trials “that set the extraordinary individual off from his or her peers”, “contemporary bio-pics from Hong Kong portray the great and the good trying, but failing, to take hold of a situation that is beyond their control” - reflecting the general mood within the political context of that era (Stringer, 1997). Centre Stage, by focusing on Ruan Lingyu, draws a parallel between “1930s Shanghai and 1990s Hong Kong”, both of which are “clearly contrasted as modern, cosmopolitan cities that suffer invasion by an occupying force (the Japanese and Communists, respectively)” (Stringer, 1997). The “absence of the lost films” that Ruan originally performed in also “provides a space within which” Kwan’s idealized imagination of Shanghai with a “Hong Kong subjectivity can be inserted” (Stringer, 1997). This sense of identification with and nostalgia for the selectively constructed Shanghai is especially evident in the film with how “the “1930s” is filmed in color while the “1990s” is in black and white, suggesting that the past is more colorful and desirable”…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine a seven-by-seven-mile metropolis, surrounded by several neighborhoods filled with homes with unique design in Presidio Heights or Nob Hill, tall office buildings in the Financial District, and amazing views of San Francisco and the Bay from the Golden Gate Bridge or Twin Peaks. As many people view San Francisco as one of the most expensive and difficult cities to live in, I like to think of it as my home away from home. It is a city of seekers and adventurers. I am a city girl and I love everything about what an urban environment can offer me. I got lost within the crowds, found small hidden spots, interacted with others around me…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Texts 1 and 2- an extract from a non-fiction piece titled 'Ghost Train to the Eastern Star' by Paul Theroux and a travel blog written by Cristian Bonetto from lonely planet.org entitled 'Singapore'- have in common the subject matter of Singapore. Even though both texts have a common thread of Singapore, the reader is shocked by the contrasting viewpoints that the texts offer on the same city of Singapore. While the audience of both texts is people who are looking for insightful information on Singapore, the purposes vary greatly. Text 1 aims to persuade the reader to not visit Singapore, describing it as a rather dystopian city where "rats are rewarded" (line 20). On the other hand, text 2 aims to persuade readers to visit Singapore, describing…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What Is Liminality?

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Liminality is a central theme to most of Arthur Yap’s work, extending his material to a broad range of interpretations and possibilities that elude a definitive and denotative meaning. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, that which is liminal has three interpretations: “minimality”; something “characterized by being on a boundary or threshold” or a “transitional… state between culturally defined stages of a person’s life”. This liminality is evident in Yap’s distinct artistry, where he engages in a sparse and economic style, representing the physical environment “sufficiently to give the reader a sense of what one feels, but not at the same time overwhelm the reader in any way” (Whitehead 2). Unlike other contemporaries like poet Edwin…

    • 1921 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays