Comparing Sir Thomas More's Utopia and Virgil's Aeneid Essay

2381 Words 10 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Identity and Power in Sir Thomas More's Utopia and Virgil's Aeneid In Utopia and the Aeneid, Sir Thomas More and Virgil describe the construction and perpetuation of a national identity. In the former, the Utopian state operates on the “inside” by enforcing, through methods of surveillance, a normalized identity on its citizens under the guise of bettering their lives. In the latter, the depleted national identity of the future Romans in the wake of the Trojan War must reformulate itself

middle of document…

The inhabitants of Utopia become docile bodies, whose mere acquiescence to the system is precisely what perpetuates and gives power to the state’s commanding gaze. In effect, More’s description of the Utopian society foreshadows the shift of the modern day nation-state from juridical to disciplinary powers. Laws are not needed because the code for living is already so naturalized that they are considered to be obvious and unchangeable.

This ability of the state to enforce a normalized identity simultaneously gives it the power to eliminate all that falls outside this narrow category. For example, Raphael describes the game of vices versus virtues that the people play for leisure, “a pitched battle between virtues and vices, which illustrates [. . .] how much strength vices can muster for a direct assault, what indirect tactics they employ, what help virtues need to overcome vices, what are the best methods of evading their attacks, and what ultimately determines the victory [. . .]” (76). The “game” takes on warlike qualities legitimating militant ways of enforcing values. Additionally, practices such as euthanasia are justified on the basis of efficiency. Priests can “officially sanction” suicides when the ill cannot work with the rest any longer(102). Although death is supposed to be “strictly voluntary,” it is widely accepted that “[i]t’s also an act of piety to
CRAM Exclusive
Hand85901Maple

Related Documents

  • Essay about Analysis of Thomas More's Utopia

    done by "Mr. Windbag," the son of Raphael's sister, declares, Plato's Republic now I claim To match, or beat at its own game.[8] More's work aims to take into account a "true" and pessimistic view of human nature, one quite different from Plato's Socratic optimism. If Utopia is truer, it is therefore better. So if we look at Utopia with More's Augustinian eye, we see a witty play on how life might develop in a state that tried to balance these two impulses--human depravity and a communist

    Words: 5937 - Pages: 24
  • Eliminating Evil in Thomas More's Utopia Essay

    under the watchful eyes of the rest of the group. Greed and gluttony, another of the seven deadly sins, are therefore eliminated because if they do not share their food, not only will their children starve, but also everyone will know about it. Thomas More's motives behind promoting communal living and communal property are fundamentally religious. He is seeking to bring an end to exploitation because it in the end makes life unbearable for those at the bottom of society and causes those at the top

    Words: 1664 - Pages: 7
  • Comparing Plato's Republic and Thomas More's Utopia Essay

    Leonardi Bruni, who newly translated Aristotle's Ethics and Politics in 1414 and 1437, respectively, refused to translate the Republic (Manuel 104). He said that "there are many things in these books that, to our ways, are loathsome" (Manuel 105). One such problem is that of Plato's abolition of the family within the ideal city--"All these women shall be wives in common to all the men, and not one of them shall live privately with any man; the children too should be held in common so that

    Words: 2967 - Pages: 12
  • Comparing and Contrasting the Epics of Homer and Virgil's Aeneid

    requested to tell his story of Troy. While Telemachus was the quest of Nestor, the aged king of Pylus, he attended a banquet and was told stories about his father, Odysseus. A serpent also came out the sea in the Odyssey and crushed Odysseus men. In the Aeneid, two serpents came out of the sea and crushed Laocoon and his young sons. Homer's Iliad also gets into the act with the ghost of Hector, Aeneas' cousin. "Book 2 At a banquet given in his honor, at Dido's request Aeneas narrates the story of

    Words: 986 - Pages: 4
  • Visions of a Perfect Society Illustrated in Machiavelli's The Prince and Thomas More's Utopia

    the power of others, by criminal acts or extreme cruelty, or by the will of the people. Utopia is located on an island, thus it would be difficult to take and keep more land in the first place. Machiavellian societies are ruled by families, so if your father is a prince or king, you will be the prince one day. You gain land by those aforementioned methods, and lose it by the conquests of other nations. In Utopia, The leaders or government officials, chosen from the citizens of superior intelligence

    Words: 518 - Pages: 3
  • Sir Thomas More Essays

    go against the Act of Succession, but doesn't tell us why until the end of the play. In the conclusion of the play because Thomas chose to go against Kings divorce, he was put to trial for treason. Sir Thomas More is still given chances to escape death throughout the trial, but chooses not to because of his strong religious beliefs. Cromwell asks "Sir Thomas you stand upon your silence" More answers "I do" to this. Richard Rich is used as convicting evidence against More, and he is found

    Words: 673 - Pages: 3
  • Thomas More’s Impact on Humanism and Socialism Essay

    negotiator of the Holy Roman Empire, king’s cabinet, and Lord Chancellor (Utopia & Utopian Literature). His multiple responsibilities in the government expose the emphasis and respect he has for government, which is blunt. Concurrently, the refusal of King Henry’s annulment demonstrates the subjected equality within the government, meaning that everyone is trialed with the exact same standards, regardless of social position. Thomas More’s actions were not the only facet that portrays his relevance to socialism

    Words: 1187 - Pages: 5
  • The Virtue and Vice of Reason in More's Utopia Essay

    them without some social or legal reason to do so. More points out the fatal flaw in this ideology, however, as the Utopians do not see that the inherent beauty of some riches provides aesthetic pleasure, some forms of which are not present in Utopia. One of the great traits of gold is not its monetary value, but that it is pleasing to the eye. Earrings may glisten in the sun, necklaces may add a bit of fashion to clothing, and a building may look better when parts of it are ornamented with gold

    Words: 1425 - Pages: 6
  • Essay on The Imperfection Of Thomas More's Utopia

    By the end of his story, he thinks he has proven that philosophy simply goes in one ear and out the other when related to politicians. Instead, he receives another rebuttal from More: "there is a more civilized form of philosophy which knows the dramatic context, so to speak, tries to fit in with it, and plays an appropriate part in the current performance." The “dramatic context”` of this particular debate pits the practical More against the idealistic Hythloday. While the thought of giving

    Words: 1432 - Pages: 6
  • Essay on Sir Thomas More

    begs for understanding. His tactic succeded. The king tells him that he understands. After that they start to speak about a musical piece composed by the King. Everything seems to go well until Henry remembers that he didn’t succed to convince Thomas More to change his mind and starts to yell at him that he will not accept any opposition. Then he goes to his ship and tells More that it is to late for him to stay at the dinner. But More appeal worked- not because it would have made the king change

    Words: 2116 - Pages: 9