Comparing Sir Thomas More's Utopia and Virgil's Aeneid Essay

2381 Words 10 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Identity and Power in Sir Thomas More's Utopia and Virgil's Aeneid In Utopia and the Aeneid, Sir Thomas More and Virgil describe the construction and perpetuation of a national identity. In the former, the Utopian state operates on the “inside” by enforcing, through methods of surveillance, a normalized identity on its citizens under the guise of bettering their lives. In the latter, the depleted national identity of the future Romans in the wake of the Trojan War must reformulate itself

middle of document…

The inhabitants of Utopia become docile bodies, whose mere acquiescence to the system is precisely what perpetuates and gives power to the state’s commanding gaze. In effect, More’s description of the Utopian society foreshadows the shift of the modern day nation-state from juridical to disciplinary powers. Laws are not needed because the code for living is already so naturalized that they are considered to be obvious and unchangeable.

This ability of the state to enforce a normalized identity simultaneously gives it the power to eliminate all that falls outside this narrow category. For example, Raphael describes the game of vices versus virtues that the people play for leisure, “a pitched battle between virtues and vices, which illustrates [. . .] how much strength vices can muster for a direct assault, what indirect tactics they employ, what help virtues need to overcome vices, what are the best methods of evading their attacks, and what ultimately determines the victory [. . .]” (76). The “game” takes on warlike qualities legitimating militant ways of enforcing values. Additionally, practices such as euthanasia are justified on the basis of efficiency. Priests can “officially sanction” suicides when the ill cannot work with the rest any longer(102). Although death is supposed to be “strictly voluntary,” it is widely accepted that “[i]t’s also an act of piety to
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • Comparing Plato's Republic and Thomas More's Utopia Essay

    The Relationship between Plato's Republic and Thomas More's Utopia        The trite cliche that no man is an island applies equally well to political philosophies. Thomas More's Utopia was written both as a product of his time, and also as a product of a previous time--that of Greek civilization, especially around 380BC, when Plato's Republic was written. The similarities between the two books are not limited to them both being a dialogue. Both contain a description of the perfect state

    Words: 2967 - Pages: 12
  • Essay about Analysis of Thomas More's Utopia

    Analysis of Thomas More's Utopia The historical Thomas More, the author of Utopia, was an extraordinarily complicated man who tied up all the threads of his life in his heroic death. The Utopia is the sort of complicated book that we should expect from so complicated a man. It is heavy with irony, but then irony was the experience of life in the Sixteenth Century. Everywhere--in church, government, society, and even scholarship--profession and practice stood separated by an abyss.

    Words: 5937 - Pages: 24
  • Essay on The Imperfection Of Thomas More's Utopia

    explain a rational idea or form a logical conclusion? Is the authority of his discourse trustworthy? Or is he just a man with name and nature in perfect harmony? These are all questions that Thomas More leaves us asking of Raphael Hythloday, the garrulous sailor-philosopher who describes and extols the society of Utopia. From his memories of a five-year stay on the island, Raphael conjures up a thorough depiction of the sociopolitical practices of the Utopian way of life, which he proclaims "the happiest

    Words: 1432 - Pages: 6
  • Eliminating Evil in Thomas More's Utopia Essay

    Eliminating Evil in Thomas More's Utopia Thomas More's Utopia is in many ways a very hopeful book; it implies that humans can be good if put in the right environment. Many people would argue that this could never happen; that the inequalities and injustices in our world are a product of human nature. Thomas More however would argue that rather than being a product of human nature, they are a product of the corruption within society. Thomas More believed that although humans may be inherently

    Words: 1664 - Pages: 7
  • Comparing and Contrasting the Epics of Homer and Virgil's Aeneid

    Comparing and Contrasting the Epics of Homer and Virgil's Aeneid Books I and II of Aeneid are an account of Virgil's adventures narrated by him. He includes the actions of the gods in his point of view. The tone of the epic is tragic and sympathetic. Books I-IV is Aeneas wanderings. "In the first half of the epic, Aeneas tells the story of the siege of Troy and his escape, causing Dido to love him. Venus and Juno contrive to isolate Dido and Aeneas in a cave during a hunting trip, and there

    Words: 986 - Pages: 4
  • Virgil’s Aeneid Essay

    Virgil’s Aeneid In literature, the feats of a main character are defined by the sacrifices he/she makes with respect to those he/she holds dear. In this way, loved ones are woven into the story to give perspective; they multiply the joys as well as the sorrows, allowing the protagonist to experience a wide range of emotions. In Virgil’s Aeneid, an epic narrative about the legendary founding of Rome, Dido is present to strengthen the character of the protagonist, Aeneas. Many tragedies befall

    Words: 1402 - Pages: 6
  • Essay about Virgil's The Aeneid

    Virgil's The Aeneid      In Webster’s dictionary, a leader is defined as a person that has commanding authority or influence over others. Such a leader can be found in The Aeneid, written by Virgil. The main character in the epic, Aeneas, shows the journey of a leader through struggles and trials. One can see the true definition of leadership through Aeneas’s strategy, bravery, and persistence.      During the Fall of Troy, Aeneas shows strategic leadership while pushing through the Greek

    Words: 485 - Pages: 2
  • The Virtue and Vice of Reason in More's Utopia Essay

    Virtue and Vice of Reason in More's Utopia  When reason permeates society, it does not necessarily imply greater happiness. When brought to the point of rationalization, or when there are errors in the analysis used in reasoning, reason tends to have adverse effects. On the other hand, when analysis is well thought out, and the correct conclusions are drawn, reason can have an overwhelmingly positive effect on a society. Many may think that Sir Thomas More's Utopia infers that reason must be

    Words: 1425 - Pages: 6
  • Visions of a Perfect Society Illustrated in Machiavelli's The Prince and Thomas More's Utopia

    different idea on the topic. For example, Thomas More wrote in ‘Utopia’ of a society where all of the cities were exactly the same. Whereas Niccolo Machiavelli wrote about how a society should be ruled in ‘The Prince.’ Both works paint a portrait of leadership and laws, as well as life and society. In ‘The Prince’, Machiavelli isn’t describing the aspects of a perfect society, he is speaking of how a prince should rule it in order to make it ideal. Whereas in ‘Utopia’, More describes the society as a whole

    Words: 518 - Pages: 3
  • Thomas More’s Impact on Humanism and Socialism Essay

    Thomas More’s Impact on Humanism and Socialism The socialist movement began with the coining of the term in 1832 in France, concurrently with the revolution in England (Birth of the Socialist Idea). Thomas More was born in 1478 and Utopia was published over 300 years before this uprising, yet there is much parallelism in Thomas More’s humanism and the socialism that is moderately practiced throughout the world. DEFINITION OF HUMANISM (ENGLISH BOOK), whereas socialism is a societal and governmental

    Words: 1187 - Pages: 5