Women's Roles In War

Superior Essays
When it comes to war, there seems to be the same subject that always comes up. The women’s role and where do they belong. Men have traditionally always been the ones who fought in the wars while the women were excluded. Being seen as the weaker sex would make war tougher for the men to fight, since they would have to look out for the women who are weaker by nature. While some women may be as tough as men there are still factors that can be distracting. The women who would fight in the war could potentially become the main focus instead of the fight. By looking deeper into All Quiet in the Western Front and Saving Private Ryan, these movies both indirectly and directly show how women would negatively affect the war if they were to join the fight. …show more content…
They are too sensitive at times, distracting, and they give birth to the children. These are only a few of the arguments used to justify why women would not be as useful in the army. Men use war to prove how masculine they are and by adding women to the equation it would make it harder for them to do that. Even women being nurses during war wasn’t acceptable at first, until all the male nurses were called to fight in war. (Paul Schue Lecture). By allowing women into the war they were able to achieve honor just like the men. The men who were supposed to be masculine were now being taking care of by women. They were dependent on the nurses to save their lives. Nurses played just as big of a part in the war as the soldiers, but in reality it has toned down. “Inevitably, to represent nursing as a collective female war experience would raise the specter of an alternative feminine war, undermining or even opposing the national war effort” (Darrow Pg.161). Basically the nurses’ roles were put down so that the soldiers in the war could still boast their manhood. If the war was to become more feminine, the men would be less likely to fight. “Misogyny and domination of women, according to some feminists, underlie male soldier’s participation in war.” (Goldstein Pg.6). Men want to be the dominant role in war, and if the war was to become more feminine they would feel more submissive. Female nurses cannot get the …show more content…
Use of emotion is seen as an unnecessary weakness, and is mostly associated with women. In the movie, Saving Private Ryan, Private Caparzo takes it on himself to rescue a little girl, despite being told not to. He explains that the girl reminded him of his niece. By showing his more feminine side by following his emotion, he ends up losing his life. Captain Miller then responds by saying that is why we don’t rescue children. By having a maternal moment during live combat, Caparzo put himself and his fellow soldiers at major risk. By adding women into combat there is a chance that more of these type of moments would happen because women tend to be more emotional than men by nature. The movie All Quiet on The Western Front showcases the same point but in a different way. The character Behn is first soldier to die because he was portrayed to be more feminine by others. He was the only one of his classmates who didn’t want to join the war, and was the first one killed. For Behn it was pressure to either join the war, or to be deemed feminine by all his classmates. Only girly men don’t want to go to war, but a real man would. He let both his emotions and peer pressure to be viewed as manly get to him. Caparzo and Behn were both emotional and ended up losing their lives. Women being in combat would be a bad idea because of how emotional they can get.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Owens also cites women’s inability to stand while urinating as another reason women should be disqualified from combat as well as the fact that during pregnancy women are exempt from performing routine duties such as marching, field training, and swim tests. . Men treat women differently than they treat other men Owens contends that the presence of women in the military undermines unit cohesion because of the possibility of romantic relationships. According to Owens, unit cohesion is necessary in order to be successful on the battlefield citing a 1992 report of the Presidential Commission on the Assignment of Women in the Armed Forces which speaks to group identity, dependency…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, some men do not even fit the physical standards. Another common argument is women should not have to see all the terrible aspects of war. NO ONE SHOULD! That is why it is called post-traumatic stress disorder. It would affect women the same way it already affects men.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women had many responses to the Great War but this was one that I believe surprised many feminists. For the first time in quite a while women were advocating for men to go fight in war. This was not only a shift in overall feminist views as being anti-war and for peace but it showed a sign of overall strength for women to advocate for men to go fight. I believe due to the lack of political leniency that women had they knew that they had very little shot at actually changing policy and ending the war at hand. I believe women came together in support of the White Feather campaign because they believed that the stronger the British army was and how outnumbered they could be over their enemies the faster the war would end and their husbands would come home.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Women During Ww2 Analysis

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Source F and J challenge the view that women were just expected to replace men as they show that during the war, separate industries were introduced specifically for women, implying that woman were considered and shown some significance during the war. The land army (source F) was set up for women work in when the world wars broke out, enlistment was voluntary in WW1 but they were conscripted in WW2. In addition to this, uniforms may have been put in place to create a sense of professionalism within the environment of work. This would appeal to other women to volunteer because it would’ve made them feel that there was some importance for women, furthermore, it could increase volunteering rates. One can deduce that the women in the source seem…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Combat is an emotionally and physically draining experience. Men preform differently in warfare than women, as the requirements for each gender to succeed in the military differ. In the article ‘the truth about women in combat’, David Frum expresses that women are less likely to succeed in the military and the New York Times demonstrates in their article ‘women in combat jobs’, that women are capable of achieving the standards set for men. Although it is harder for women to execute exercises that are simpler for men, raising the requirements in the United States Military could save their lives. While some women are capable of the excruciating tasks, David Frum notes “Physical strength continues to matter in warfare.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, this also shows that, although some men wanted their women to be there with them but Mary Ann’s transformation show that war is not good for anyone, even women. This shows that female and male stereotypes do not always apply. The chapter “Sweetheart of Song Tra Bong,” is a story about a women overcoming a stereotype, however graphic the story may be. The text shows that anyone can adapt to their environment if need be. She challenges the men’s masculinity with her own gumption and courage.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Later on in the Weimar Republic, resent grew for the government for offering a glimmer of freedom but discontinuing the promises made toward women’s equality” (Gardner 4). The desire to go back toward the gender norms was wanted more when men saw women trying to prosper. The New Women and liberation caused a lot of debate because it was seen as challenging male authority and the very structure of patriarchy. With the increasingly amount of men that died in war and the decreasing birth rate, women were the dominate gender. Men saw the aspects of women being the dominate gender and expressing their independence as a threat and were willing to do anything possible to end it.…

    • 2015 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Men are set to a standard of masculinity and strength; if one does not reach these standards one is not considered manly enough. Feminism seeks to exempt men from these standards due to its harmful effect on men; the same goes for the standards set for women. It may seem that feminism is a one way battle, but it truly seeks to fight for the betterment of both sexes. The prefix may lead people to believe that it only promotes women, but the real battle lies within both sexes. What may seem so miniscule to some is actually a rather big controversy to feminists looking to make a difference.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is simply gender stereotypes enforced by society that feeds into the narrative that women would decrease the efficiency of the military and put their fellow soldiers in danger. It has been proven that females face the same obstacles in the field that males do and it is simply a matter of integration, training, and proper equipment needed to ensure the equal success of women alongside the men. For these reasons, it can be argued that the cons presented by those against female integration into combat roles are easily debunked, as it is essentially only the confining old mindset of society that is holding back the progress of women. It is interesting to consider what the world would be like if the power was in the hands of women, and what arguments would be raised against male inclusion in military combat…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite the tireless dedication, women still somehow does not get the recognition in many areas, especially in the military. For years, there have been thousands of debates about whether women should be allowed to fight in combat or not. They work as hard as men, willing to risk their life for the country but there are people Despite the fact that women have been serving in the military since 1775, there are people still believe that women should be excluded from the ground combat and gives many reasons to prove their opinion. They argue that women do not have the physical ability and mental toughness like men have. They lack…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays